Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
HaKatanParticipant
Perhaps you could add “…party in the Israeli parliament” to the title so that it is clear to which Agudah you refer.
August 20, 2026 11:36 am at 11:36 am in reply to: Seminary prices rising. When do we say enough?! #2587731HaKatanParticipantI don’t see why the lower value of the dollar should make an ideological difference that it would make sense to “boycott” them over that. They have expenses and salaries, etc. that they presumably pay in their currency, NIS. So if they are getting much less money due to presenting that in USD, then that is obviously an issue for them. So, the ideological question is on what they charge in NIS, even if presented to you in USD, if it makes sense to be spending that on a year of seminary in E”Y. The practical question does remain, of course, is if it’s affordable in USD, regardless.
@Rocky
You seem to have misunderstood.Let’s say they want 120k NIS per student. When the conversion ratio was 4:1 NIS:USD, that meant that they would charge $30K in USD.
Now that the dollar is weaker, that means it takes more dollars to get that same amount of NIS. At a 3:1 ratio, that same 120k NIS would be $40k in USD.That is the logic.
HaKatanParticipantRabbi Dr. Soloveichik espoused heretical views (see Rav Shach and others), so his opinions aren’t all that relevant to Orthodox Jews, only to his sycophantic followers who laughingly misappropriated the Brisker Rav’s title (with a kamatz) and shortened it to simply “The Rav” (with a Zionist patach) and applied that to their Rabbi Dr.
“q: Zionists in Brisk
a: there was a letter sent around to support keren kayemet lisrael signed by 50 rabbis, including an important rav from Vilno whom I knew personall, he was ver ehrliche and eydel and full of eras shamayim.”The very name there should cause one to vomit in disgust. The Zionist heretics purposely denied an open mishna we recite every day and instead changed that phrase “keren kayemes” to instead mean their heretical fund. That he made no mention of that is telling, though he was, of course, the head of Mizrachi (which is idolatry as per the gedolim) in America, so that’s no surprise.
HaKatanParticipantPerhaps because idolatry is not rational, and the Zionist rabbis and laymen have been brainwashed with that idolatry since birth – as opposed to non-Orthodox which is a matter of fact, meaning rational thought, and anyone thinking rationally should obviously conclude that non-Orthodox is obviously wrong.
HaKatanParticipant@Chaim87
“So I need to remind everyone that chalac stam isn’t treif. R Moshe zl allowed it and R aron served it in Lakewood even after he was able to get chalav yisroel. Many chashuva communities still eat chalav stam.”Do you really want that, in heaven, other people’s sins or shortcomings would be attributed to you, CH”V?
Rav Moshe has a teshuva specifying in what circumstances it would be permitted, not that he “allowed it” just like that.
UJM pointed out that you are flat-out wrong about your contention regarding Rav Aharon.
And which are those many “chashuva communities” that still do so and, more importantly, why and under whose direction?HaKatanParticipant“From my perspective, the emerging deal appears to be a disaster for both the Jewish people and the State of Israel. Of course, none of us knows the future. We cannot know with certainty what will happen tomorrow. What we can do is look back and honestly evaluate what has happened so far.”
Lev melachim viSarim beYad Hashem.
But before trying to analyze what something might mean for the future, one first needs to know what it is that they are evaluating.
And as the Vice President stated explicitly to the Zionists the other day, the Zionists should be more respectful and less idiotic in claiming that their problem is President Trump because President Trump is the only world leader who is sympathetic to their “nation”.“About the “holy” netanyahu. in the past he was treated by the orthodox community like a king, like a navi. there was no questions allowed”
Perhaps idolaters considered him that. The actual Orthodox Jewish community, as in those who do not worship the Zionist idol, are well aware that he’s the leader of the greatest force of shmad on the planet.HaKatanParticipant@Shadow12:
It was the heretical Zionists, not “the Jews”, that violated the oaths. A wicked band of heretics obviously does not represent “the Jews”.Agudah’s actual position is that they treat the Zionist paradise like they would any other country, and since there are millions of Jews there, they seek the safety of those millions of Jews. As the Brisker Rav pointed out, Agudah was actually founded to fight Zionism, not to make peace with it, so they have certainly changed course from their founding mission. But, regardless, their position is officially that they simply seek the welfare of the Jews there.
June 7, 2026 11:17 am at 11:17 am in reply to: Hypothetical question for everyone to ponder. #2558504HaKatanParticipantThere seems to be no point in going through each post when that has been done multiple times in past threads yet Zionists just mindlessly regurgitate whatever idolatrous propaganda they find, disgracing our holy Torah in service of their idol, rather than wanting to actually know and believe the truth.
But just in case:
@SQUARE_ROOT
Rav Meir Simcha wrote in the context of the recently-issued Balfour Declaration, as quoted, that the “FEAR of the oaths” was no longer, not that the “oaths themselves” were no longer. That implies, of course, that the oaths were not only in effect until then (unlike your error in Rav Chaim Vital) but that they remained in effect, only that the “FEAR” of violating them had been allayed. And he was specifically referring to the oath of rebelling against the nations, since that declaration stated that the Brits allowed Jews to live in Mandatory Palestine.Rav Chaim Vital did not say that at all. Go ahead and quote that piece.
————–
@HaLeivi:
Who has expressed the opinion that any of the oaths are dependent on each other, never mind all of them? How in the world could anyone logically state that dechikas haKeitz, for example, is muttar if the goyim terribly oppress Jews? That’s absurd.Of course all the oaths were flagrantly transgressed by the wicked Zionists.
That’s another Zionist myth. The Steipler never said that. He said that “VOTING” was okay for internal elections as citizens once the State was already established. He never stated that it was muttar to have that idolatrous rebellion against G-d once it was already made.
All believing Jews certainly do believe that, but only in a way that causes no harm to any Jew.
June 5, 2026 12:28 pm at 12:28 pm in reply to: Hypothetical question for everyone to ponder. #2558121HaKatanParticipant@SQUARE_ROOT
Again, the oaths are all independent of each other, both our oaths between themselves and ours versus theirs.And Rav Kluger obviously did not say that and the others are anyways irrelevant in the face of the Torah giants including rishonim!!!! who ruled otherwise.
June 4, 2026 10:05 am at 10:05 am in reply to: Hypothetical question for everyone to ponder. #2557881HaKatanParticipantI commend @SQUARE_ROOT for his post regarding shalom and no machlokes. Thank you.
June 3, 2026 11:21 am at 11:21 am in reply to: Hypothetical question for everyone to ponder. #2557311HaKatanParticipant@redleg:
There are at least three oaths there, and they are totally independent of each other for numerous reasons. Besides, unlike the oath of not rebelling against the nations (which is still in effect regardless), the oaths of not ascending en masse and not taking political sovereignty are obviously totally irrelevant to the nations’ oath of not overly subjugating.——————
““Let us assume the Three Oaths (Ketubot 111a) are actually a halacha applicable today and the creation of Medinat Yisrael was a violation of the Oaths.” (A view which I do not hold)”
As indicated many times on these boards, the oaths are absolutely applicable liHalacha, regardless of what you think you hold. You might also hold that the prohibition against worshiping idols is not in effect, but that doesn’t change that it still very much is in effect – according to all Torah authorities.
“Okay, we and those before us have “sinned” by violating said Oaths. So what should we do now? Leave Eretz Yisrael and move to Chutz L’Aretz? “Absolutely not, because according to that same Gemara, one is not allowed to leave E”Y.””
No comment; ask your LOR.
“Whether wrong or not, it appears that Hashem has given his approval to return to the land, b’di’avad.”
The eigel worshipers thought so too. No, that’s not at all what it appears. The forever Zionist wars and forever “existential danger” the Zionists constantly mention would not lead one to believe that Hashem has nullified any part of His Torah in this regard, of course.
“Which leads me to ask, what other examples in our history did the nation or individual Jews violate the will of Hashem, only to later be judged as acting correctly….I think I found an example. In Shmuel I, the nation says to Shmuel “תְּ� ָ�”־לָּ֥� וּ מֶ�-לֶךְ..”…As a consequence the rule of a human king from the House of David becomes the foundation of Jewish nationalism, which will culminate, G-d willing soon, in the arrival of Mashiach ben David. ”
That’s odd. There is an explicit mitzvah in the Torah to “place a king… “, as in “Som taSim alecha melech”. So, no, the problem there was their intent in their request of the prophet, not fulfilling a mitzvah in the Torah.
HaKatanParticipant@Rocky:
Why would you be machshil people in dishonoring those rabbanim?That call doesn’t show intolerance of anyone. They presumably fully sympathize with those suffering souls, as everyone should.
However, given the “facts on the ground” at that establishment, they don’t want frum people going there.HaKatanParticipant@mdd1:
I did. Please do the same.In case it wasn’t already clear: while anything good could theoretically happen after something not good (for example, after the Holocaust, Torah life and learning began growing in the United States and – despite ongoing Zionist shmad – in E”Y as well), Hashem does not do good through the agency of bad people, as Chazal noted. Same applies to the Rambam you quoted.
Specifically related to this point, as mentioned, the Zionists’ massive and unprecedented rebellion against Hashem is obviously not a catalyst for the redemption. In fact, that idol is pushing off the redemption (hopefully for no longer), and some gedolim have explicitly stated that Mashiach will take control of E”Y not from the Zionists.
HaKatanParticipantFirst of all the mitzva of yishuv E”Y today is, at most, optional, or not in force at all.
Regardless, there were many religious Jews who attempted to NON-politically live there, and the locals had no problems with that – unlike the invading Zionists.Yes, of course the Zionist invasion was exactly that. The religious Jews in E”Y begged them to leave and also told the UN that they were a separate community not under control of the invading Zionists. The Zionists fought against both the British and the Arabs well before 1948 – all against the wishes of the religious Jews there, as mentioned.
Zionism is, of course, an idol and its ideology is, of course, heresy, as per all the gedolim. People prayed for the founding of the “State” and success of this idol. Obviously I did not write that Hashem accepted prayers to idols; He accepted prayers TO HIM for the BENEFIT of that idol.
No gedolim “felt otherwise” against the Brisker Rav.
It’s really not very difficult to comprehend these simple facts, and no debate is necessary.
Please consult with your LOR. Presumably, you could find a real one in Jerusalem of all places.Then again, with this last quote, I wonder if you are even serious:
“”In fact, both the Satmar Rav and Brisker Rav stated that Mashiach (i.e., the redemption) would have come back then – as in for sure would have come – if not for the founding of that “State” happening instead.”
Doesn’t go against Chazal and the Rambam who condemn those who calculate the End?”No, not at all. They simply noted that it would have happened then; not that they “calculated” in advance when it would happen, but rather that it would have happened then.
Please urgently consult with an LOR.
HaKatanParticipant@nevuah:
Every gadol stated that it is idolatry and heresy, both of which are very much against the Torah. Please ask your LOR.
@Chaim87:
There are three possibilities there.
1. You didn’t remotely ask the right question.
2. You didn’t remotely understand his answer.
3. Much less likely, he simply made a mistake.If you would quote precisely the words of your question and the words of his answer then that might indicate which of the above three it is.
It’s that simple. My humble hunch is a combination of #1 and #2, if I had to guess.
@GadolHadofi
Still foaming at the mouth, and accusing falsely. Please stop.HaKatanParticipant@mdd1:
You’re essentially claiming that, for example, Haman would get credit for Hashem saving all the Jews in the Purim story. After all, he was the one who caused them to do teshuva. Clearly, that’s not what migalgilin zechus al yesdei zakai means because, in part, we explicitly curse Haman each year.Same idea with this idol and the redemption.
HaKatanParticipant@Chaim87:
It certainly is halacha, including examples you mentioned (true or otherwise), though proper hashkafa is also a Torah requirement, not just a theoretically nice thing.
Of course, staying far away from Zionist idolatry – as opposed to promoting it with nebulous stories from 70 years ago – is pretty basic Torah, but that’s besides the point.HaKatanParticipant@DaMoshe:
Interesting. You are claiming that the Holocaust was, or at least could have been, a necessary prerequisite of the redemption – with zero Torah authority to back that up – while claiming that it is I who have “hate-filled beliefs”. You are accusing falsely, as others have done in the past.To the point:
Hashem is a Rachum viChanun and wants to do only good. And His ways are darchei noam. And we know that Hashem runs Klal Yisrael in general on sichar viOnesh. So, for those and many other reasons, it makes zero sense that He would design the redemption to require that horror. Ask an Orthodox LOR before assuming something that tragic was required “just because” – that’s obviously not possibly true. The question then becomes why that horror did happen, and the gedolim have given answers for that – answers that idolaters happen not to like for various reasons.And even if one wanted to ignore all that and claim that there is no possible known “reason” for the Holocaust, it would still be absurd to claim that the Holocaust was just another checklist item for redemption.
And if one were honest, even if one might have made that mistake (of thinking that the Holocaust was “required”) close to a century ago, one would acknowledge that it is clearly illogical to make that mistake now a century later. By that “logic”, you could also claim that all the pogroms and inquisition and all that were also requirements of redemption. Once you’re going back a century, what’s another few centuries?
So, to restate your own advice – to yourself, please don’t make things up, especially when that contradicts the Torah.
HaKatanParticipant@nevuah
Not at all.First of all, by that logic, the Holocaust, with all its horrors, was also “necessary” for the redemption. Obviously, it was not.
Hashem had other reasons for that happening (and gedolim predicted that terrible things were going to happen then), but, to enable Mashiach coming, Hashem certainly didn’t need to bring a Holocaust, with all its horrors.As well, the reason the “State” did actually come into being is, as the gedolim (including the Brisker Rav and Satmar Rav) noted: that people back then were fooled (by the satan) into praying for this idol “State” to happen instead of praying for Mashiach. Hashem’s response to those prayers was to accept them and to give them what they requested: the idol “State”.
HaKatanParticipantChaim87:
Why not ask your LOR instead?
HaKatanParticipant“RightJew” wrote:
“But one could say that the very dangerous and necessary first step in the geulah process, i.e. conquest of Eretz Yisrael, was accomplished by these secular Zionists with the help of Hashem. ”No, one cannot say that, because, in part, migalgilin zechus al yedai zakai… not via heretics who perpetrated a massive historical rebellion against G-d (and destruction of Judaism never seen before and still ongoing R”L L”A). The Brisker Rav stated that the “State” they have managed to achieve is the greatest triumph of the satan since the golden calf. Obviously, no, that founding was not the “first step” in the redemption.
Of course, there were religious Jews who preceded the Zionists’ invasion, and those Jews came to the holy land for purely non-political reasons and not at all rebelling against G-d. Those could possibly have been a helpful backdrop, so to speak. In fact, both the Satmar Rav and Brisker Rav stated that Mashiach (i.e., the redemption) would have come back then – as in for sure would have come – if not for the founding of that “State” happening instead.
HaKatanParticipantAAQ:
It is the idolater that are dishonest. No, there is no dissenting rabbinical opinion, certainly not on the level of Rav Elchonon, the Brisker Rav, the Chazon Ish, the Imrei Emes and the rest.Only an idolater could try to claim there is any rabbinical permit to that (or any other) idol which has as its goal the destruction of the Torah and replacement of Judaism with Zionism. That should be obvious even in theory, but is all the more obvious if you simply follow the news and the cataclysmic damage the heretics have done to Judaism and Jews.
HaKatanParticipant@SQUARE_ROOT
With all due respect, it is the Zionist idolaters, including those who quote nebulous Artscroll quotes from 70 years ago, that are “disconnected from reality”.Zionist shmad is very real, and it is idolatry and heresy, as all the gedolim noted.
As you quoted, “You can ignore reality, but you cannot ignore the consequences of ignoring reality.”HaKatanParticipant@qwerty613:
It is you and your idol that are the definition of “sonei yisrael”. The Torah is the life-force of Jews, and your idol has been trying to destroy the Torah for over a century.The Brisker Rav stated that he (and everyone) prays thrice daily for the (peaceful) elimination of the idol, which is the viLaMalshinim prayer in 18. If you have a problem with that, you can take it up with him.
Your “examination” and calling others “nazis” is beyond absurd (and perhaps somewhat of a projection, but only Hashem knows).
Just drop the idol already and stop falsely accusing people and writing nonsense. Just acknowledge that the only power is Hashem and that He does not need anything to help Him and His children, not even your idol.
April 27, 2026 11:11 am at 11:11 am in reply to: Little by little the State of Israel is embracing Torah values. #2540887HaKatanParticipantRav Chaim Brisker noted decades before the Zionists achieved their “State” that the reason the Zionists needed a State is in order to shmad, not that the reason they were shmading pre-“State” was in order to get a “State”.
History has shown how clearly right he (and the Satmar Rav) and all the others were about that.
HaKatanParticipant@Always_Ask_Questions:
“Not sure what this means”
You do. It’s not very complicated. The Jews lived peacefully with the Arabs both under Arab rule and in the holy land (yes, there was the occasional disturbance every couple of decades or so; no, it wasn’t gan eden, but it was far better than under Christian rule at the time and incomparably better than under the heretics now).Rabbi Dr. Soloveichik noted the obvious reality that the rise in Arab hatred towards Jews (mistakenly considering them all Zionists) since the advent of Zionism around a century ago was due to….wait for it….Zionism (particularly their “State”). Wow. What a concept.
HaKatanParticipant“two ideas:
1) it is entirely possible that two things hold true: 1.1) foundation of Israel is a great thing…”In the Jewish religion, that isn’t at all possible. The founding of the “State” was a violation of the entire Torah (as per the Brisker Rav) and obviously of the Oaths (which the idolaters have obviously never managed to explain away). It also has shmaded untold numbers of Jews and on and on and on. It also prevented (and is preventing, according to some) Mashiach from coming. And on and on.
HaKatanParticipantSince then, the disaster for Jews that is that idol has grown infinitely worse.
For example, back then, the yeshiva students at least had some legal framework to remain Jews and learn in yeshiva, unlike now.
Since then, the heretics have shmaded multiple generations of Jews, probably numbering in the millions.But you know all this and, unlike your projection accusation (false as always), you wish to worship the idol.
HaKatanParticipant@qwerty613:
However G-d chooses to handle putting an end to the nightmare of that idol without the loss of any Jewish life at all.
@simcha613:
People also believe in trees and cows. They are worshiping idols. Same here.
It was very much non-miraculous, and monumental in only the opposite way: as in the greatest triumph of the satan since the sin of the golden calf, as per the Brisker Rav.Again, as Rav Elchonon and the others put it, Zionism is idolatry and “Religious Zionism” is idolatry and religion together. That is the reality. Should we pity a brainwashed “Religious Zionist” due to that brainwashing and not hate them? Of course; nobody suggested otherwise. But the Torah cannot be adulterated.
In case it still isn’t clear, what would your reaction be if someone tried to claim that the reason that Easter Sunday falls out on Pesach is whatever? The answer is that Easter Sunday is not relevant to my religion, so the question simply doesn’t start. Same here.
HaKatanParticipant@DaMoshe:
“HaKatan asks if there would be anti-semitism if Israel didn’t exist…It’s a halacha that Esav sonei es Yaakov. Anti-semitism will always exist, until Mashiach comes. It has nothing to do with Israel, or anything else…”That’s obviously absurd. Of course it has everything to do with the idol.
The root cause of antisemitism is assimilation, which is just as “yadua” as “ESL”.
Zionism and its “State” is the ultimate assimilation.
So that’s on a Torah/reality level.Practically, we have seen endless news reports of Jews worldwide being hurt ch”V in response to some military or other action taken by the idol. Even Rabbi Dr. Soloveichik, way back, admitted that the Arab hate was due to the “State”.
Of course ESL very much has to do with the idol.
But we all know that your idolatry, “Religious Zionism” is idolatry and heresy according to all the gedolim. So your little projection is sad. Repent and leave the idol!
HaKatanParticipant@simcha613:
The Zionists – even “religious” ones – celebrate and party on that invented “holiday” despite it falling out during sefirah.
The Chazon Ish stated that the day should really be a Tish’ah BiAv.
@qwerty613:
No frum Jews – not even NK – have ever advocated for the death of the Jews in the Zionist paradise. Your comment is disgraceful.HaKatanParticipant“If there was an israel in 1939 there would not have been a Holocaust.”
Have you read any actual literature, including from gedolim and tzaddikim like Rav MB Weissmandl?“With the horrible antisemitism getting worse day-by-day, be thankful that there is an Israel to go to today just in case…”
Did it occur to you that there would not have been that antisemitism?For example, there was a story today about some British savage who harassed an innocent Jew at work asking the Jew if he killed babies in Gaza. That is an obvious association of that Jew with Israel.
And on and on.
April 23, 2026 1:10 pm at 1:10 pm in reply to: State of Israel Stands Up In Defense of Yushka Pundrik #2539447HaKatanParticipantThis quote from RSFM is obviously motzi shem ra against RSFM because we are not “commanded to keep far away from hatred of our fellow Jews” if those Jews are not biChlal amisecha.
Regardless, Artscroll biographies are not a source of daas Torah, though they do have some nice material, B”H.
HaKatanParticipantArtscroll biographies are very nice, but not exactly a source of daas Torah.
The bottom line (whether or not they should have also known this 75 years ago) is that the “State” has caused tremendous damage to Jews and Judaism.HaKatanParticipantThis is YWN, not “Religious Zionist”/idolater news.
Why would you post such an offensive question here?1. As the Brisker Rav put it, “the “State” they have managed to achieve is the greatest triumph of the satan since the cheit haEiegel”, and explicitly wrote that Mashiach would have come had people prayed for that instead of for this “State”. That’s obviously cause for great celebration.
2. Observing sefirah mourning as per chazal rather than trampling it like the idolaters do.
3. People have work to do.April 21, 2026 9:13 pm at 9:13 pm in reply to: Little by little the State of Israel is embracing Torah values. #2538664HaKatanParticipant“…it is the Torah Jews in Israel who refuse to vote and the Torah Jews of the world who refuse to move to Israel and vote who are responsible for the continued secular rule in the state of Israel. ”
That’s a very interesting “blame the victim” approach you have. Jews are at fault for the hurt against Jews by anti-Jewish heretics claiming to be Jewish because those Jews didn’t move to what is statistically the least safest place on the planet for Jews to attempt to politically influence the policies. Of course, you won’t blame the heretics for hurting Jews even as they claim to represent Jews and won’t acknowledge that there is no way the heretics would allow their ideology to be replaced by Judaism because that is their entire ideology: Zionism is intended to replace Judaism.
This is the idolatry of Zionism. Idolatry is not rational, and this is unfortunately yet another example of how irrational idolatry is.
April 21, 2026 9:13 pm at 9:13 pm in reply to: Little by little the State of Israel is embracing Torah values. #2538663HaKatanParticipant@chaim_baruch:
Hashem certainly has His own time-table, but as all the gedolim wrote, a century of shmad of His children was definitely not in His plans. In fact, both the Brisker and Satmar Rabbanim stated that Moshiach would have – not could have, but would have – come in 1948 had people not instead prayed for that idol “State”.It is also absurd to suggest that they somehow “found religion” when their entire ideology is to replace Judaism with their Nationalism, and that they have made illegitimate every single Torah learner subject to their army draft, and have been taking those boys from their beds in the middle of the night, and on and on and on.
@besalel:
He was entirely right, that the shmad the Zionists unleashed on Klal Yisrael is unimaginable. The Brisker Rav published, and the Gerrer Rebbe and others signed on that the “Religious Zionist” education is “a sea of heresy mixed in with a drop of Torah”. And the “Religious” ones are the most fanatical Zionists. The massive spreading world-wide of Zionist heresy and idolatry – from little bits of it to large oceans of it – has unfortunately indeed happened.HaKatanParticipant@The little I know:
וַתְּכַ�–ֵ֨שׁ שָׂרָ֧�” ׀ לֵאמֹ֛ר לֹ֥א צָ�–ַ�-קְתִּי כִּ֣י ׀ יָרֵ�’אָ�” וַיֹּ֥אמֶֽר ׀ לֹ�-א כִּ֥י צָ�–ָֽקְתְּ׃The Bechor Shor states explicitly that the latter statement there was spoken by Avraham, as @LuckyStrike noted.
HaKatanParticipant“�”�’יע �”�-מן ש�’כל פעם שמ�-כירים �–יילם ישראליים י�-כירו את לומ�”י �”תור�””
One has nothing to do with the other, of course.The Torah learners are the ones upon whom the entire world rests. LiHavdil, that army’s soldiers (like everyone else other than Torah learners and secondarily those who follow G-d and do mitzvos) are, at best, “cogs in the wheel”. The Torah learners are the engine powering that “wheel”.
The Brisker Rav pointed out that the only thing that benefits Klal Yisrael is Torah and mitzvos. If their soldiers in that army are made to sin in any way, but especially in big ways, then that hurts Jews, no matter how mighty are the soldiers’ weapons.
@sensibleyid
It’s not very sensible to think you know better than every gadol (including Rav Steinman) over the past century. Being inducted into that army means being shmaded, including all three of the gimmel chamuros and more.April 7, 2026 3:04 pm at 3:04 pm in reply to: The Problem in calling everyone “Antisemetic” #2533717HaKatanParticipant@Kuvult:
The antidote to antisemitism is not assimilating.
Being normal could certainly prevent non-antisemitic hate or annoyance, though.The big difference between a menorah and liHavdil that tree is that the menorah is simply a lantern that happens to be used on Chanukah, while that tree has inherent religious (idolatrous) symbolism.
So, regarding your story, from a secular perspective (which is what you mentioned), there is nothing wrong with giving out a menorah to color. If giving out to the class sheets of color-in menorah would have made the student feel welcome in their class, then that’s a theoretically reasonable idea on the mother’s part. But that does not extent to crying antisemitism if the teacher or school decline that, as there could be many perfectly valid reasons for them to decline that.
From a religious perspective, meaning the truth, though, a Jew does not belong as a student in a class of gentiles. That’s the real problem. Second to that, the Jew should not be “making waves”, even if the idea is “normal”.
March 31, 2026 5:04 pm at 5:04 pm in reply to: The Problem in calling everyone “Antisemetic” #2532437HaKatanParticipant“Your Local Misnagid”:
No, it is not exaggerated despite your alleged few friends that are allegedly still religious.
And no real “talmidei chachamim” ever supported it, of course, including Rav Steinman.First of all, the numbers are what they are, and, more importantly, the intentional shmad of that army is what it is.
Second, you don’t know what damage to their emunah was done to them in that army even if they still appear outwardly frum.
Emunah must be 100%, not tainted by nationalism or any other idolatryHaKatanParticipant@rescue
“Hakatan. _reality_ determines morality as it is the fabric of creation. Whether God looked into the Torah and created the world doesn’t contradict that morality is still the fabric of reality. The Torah and reality are a complement of the other not a contradiction”No. Not in Judaism, anyways.
G-d created the world based on what the Torah requires. In other words, the relevant portions of the Torah are the “blueprint” of creation.
But that obviously doesn’t mean that the world (or “reality”, as you put it) therefore contains everything in the Torah. Therefore, it also does not mean that Torah and reality are a complement of each other. Reality is a reflection of the relevant portions of the Torah.Morality, like all else, is derived from the Torah, not from the world.
March 30, 2026 2:18 pm at 2:18 pm in reply to: The Problem in calling everyone “Antisemetic” #2531535HaKatanParticipant“If I wasn’t Jewish, I’d also have a problem with the fact that many Jews in America vote strictly out of self-interest for “Jews first.” There’s a loyalty to Israel and the tribe that often comes before America, and let’s be honest, that is un-American. I never even recognized this in myself before because I was taught that anyone saying it was just a bigot. I thought that line of thinking was “prohibited.” But why is it hateful? It’s not. It’s a reasonable observation.”
Not even a century ago, Jews were murdered by the millions. Therefore, Jews are very concerned with doing what they can do in the voting booth to prevent a recurrence of that mass-murder and anything remotely like it. That is not at all “un-American”. Jews are among the most loyal citizens of any country in which they reside because, in part, they have a religious imperative (in Jeremiah) to seek out the peace of the land in which they reside. Every gentile can read this in, liHavdil, their bible, too. Especially in this country, which Rav Moshe called a medinah shel chessed, Jews are very grateful to the government for the ability to live our lives as Torah Jews.
————
“Look at the Chareidim in Israel. The status quo there is low employment, and the excuse is always “religious reasons.” But if you call that out, you’re branded as “anti-religion” or a “Tzioni”. The truth is, that “religious” excuse is a lie. It’s not a requirement to be unemployed.”
Yes, it is a requirement there, because the wicked Zionists insist the chareidim be shmaded in their army before allowing the chareidim to work. That’s why the chareidim cannot work – because the wicked Zionists impoverish them in an attempt to shmad them in their army to convert them from Jew to Zionist.
HaKatanParticipant@rescue
“Morality is defined by _reality_ . The Torah just codifies it. That’s why it’s very important to filter all beliefs systems with what exists in reality cuz if reality shows it’s not true then the belief system isn’t true either. The two are connected cuz they are a mirror of each other. Not the other way around ”You have it backwards.
G-d looked at the Torah (which He wrote, of course) and then created the world based on what’s in the Torah.
Morality, like everything else, is determined by the Torah.——
“Not to make us into complete copy robots of one another and take away our individuality”
This happens to be true, because we each have different social setups in this world, so, for example, a kiruv rabbi’s job will be different than that of a college student.HaKatanParticipant@rescue
“That means I can think for myself and make choices based off my own thinking and make choices outside any control system _i_ choose cuz that’s a god given right”Your free will does not in any way change what is right and wrong. That has nothing to do with a strait-jacket and any state of fear and “control system” and whatever else you wrote there. Your G-d-given “right”, as you put it, is to make your best assessment as to what G-d wants – not what you want – and also to G-d forbid violate His will if you choose to do that. But G-d did not give anyone the right to create their own Torah.
Pirkei Avos tells us “asei licha rav” – find for yourself a Torah authority who can properly guide and advise you. In your case, that might be a rebbetzin, if the writing style, etc. are what they seem to be. No strait-jackets. Just your well-advised best efforts to do G-d’s will.
HaKatanParticipantVayidomAharon:
Those heretics stole that name – Tzion – from our Torah.
The gentiles happen to also know of that word from their “Bible”.None of that disqualifies a Jew from using that word. Tzion is part of G-d’s holy language, meaning that it is for Jews.
The implication of your post, though, is backwards. The Nazis got at least some of their propaganda from the early Zionists. For example, look up the origins of “A Jew’s life is a dog’s life” and the offensive and antisemitic and patently false canard “Jews cannot be loyal citizens of their host countries” and much more. That last one is a real doozy, especially from a movement that claims to be all about protecting Jews (regardless of the merit or lack thereof of that assertion).
So, regardless of the merits of your claims against either gentile you mentioned, it’s actually the other way around, as noted.
HaKatanParticipantChas viShalom!
“Mizrachi” means “Religious Zionist”, NOT general Sephardic Jewry.The greatest Torah sages of the past century have clearly ruled that “Religious Zionism” is idolatry and heresy, including Rav Elchonon Wasserman, the Brisker Rav and more. You’re welcome to disagree with them, but that is out of place on a site with the name “Yeshiva”.
That must be the source of your quote, which otherwise doesn’t sound familiar.
While on the topic, though, you still haven’t apologized for cursing Jews.
HaKatanParticipantOnce again, @SQUARE_ROOT nauseatingly spouts his love of the Zionist idol and criticizes G-d-fearing Jews (NK) because they publicly deny his idol and also misses the point despite the multiple posts by ujm and others explaining. Amazing how idolatry destroys rationality.
English would have been an excellent choice, especially because that was the language of the Mandate there at the time, and already was an international language. The only reason the heretics bastardized and denigrated our holy language with their creation of “Modern Hebrew” is for heretical nationalist purposes.
It is the Zionists, not anti-Zionists, that were rodfim, as they have amply written and shown throughout their odious history going back over a century.
It is also the Zionists, not anti-Zionists, who have amply proven their VERY LOW opinion of Sephardic Jews, like Yaldei Teiman and all the rest.Kol HaPosel biMumo Posel.
The point is to keep the holy tongue exactly that: holy, and to use a different language for mundane day-to-day speech. Yiddish could work for that, of course, though a yeshivish English would probably be the modern equivalent and also not have the baggage of speaking a similar language to that which the Nazi murderers spoke.
HaKatanParticipantLet’s rewrite @SQUARE_ROOT’s Zionist heresy to be more in line with reality.
Every member of the Neturei Karta
is to be praised for at least attempting to save Jews from persistent, long-term anti-Semitism caused by Zionism.NK is attempting to save Jews from the anti-Semitism caused by Zionism, including Hamas and Hezbollah and the Ayatollahs of Iran,
who want to commit GENOCIDE against ALL JEWS, including children and babies!HaKatanParticipant@rescue:
The only cause of antisemitism is assimilation, not when one is honest in all one’s dealings – including getting on welfare if one qualifies for that, may Hashem please help them.The greatest specific cause of antisemitism – by far – wasn’t at all mentioned in your post, but it can remain unmentioned.
-
AuthorPosts