Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
“Tautology? As halakha does not generally recognize breaking common laws …”
Dinei mamonus are governed by Halacha rather than by secular law.
AAQ: Muslims are goyim. The difference between them and Christians, is that they are not baalei avoda zora whereas Christians are. You can daven in a mosque but you cannot even enter a church.
AAQ: Muslims are goyim. The difference between them and Christians, is that they are not baalei avoda zora whereas Christians are. You can daven in a mosque but you cannot even enter a church.
There are brand new drugs that treat Covid that were just released to the market by the FDA. As such, why would you even need to consider drugs like Ivermectin?
There are so many basis for warranted and justified attacks on Biden, that it is completely unnecessary to utilize any baseless attack.
farb, those reshoyim abused the word in falsely using it to describe themselves.
farb, those reshoyim abused the word in falsely using it to describe themselves.
**Mod**, you posted the last comment. It seems you didn’t intend to approve it’s pubic visibility
“if those actions are not per se recognized as “ganavah” under halacha and there is no liklihood of being caught so therefore “no chilul hashem”. Or are you saying exactly the opposite which I think is what you meant (i.e. ganevah is ganevah).”
It isn’t geneiva if those actions are not per se recognized as “ganavah” under halacha.
Probably the Zionists putting on a show of how strong they are.
Do we expect more from a Prince?
Or can the king’s son acts no differently than the commoner on the street selling hot dogs on the corner in his stand?
tuna: to the point that we’re not allowed to even drink wine with goyim.
YouTube is known to strictly police copyright violations. If it is on their platform, presumably the artists permit it to be on YouTube.
Health, part of our religion is not to assimilate.
Goldilocks, these days you can become anything you want. 🤣
AAQ: What “contract” did you sign when you bought a book in Barnes & Noble or a CD in your neighborhood supermarket?
Dina Dmalchusa doesn’t necessarily apply to issues between Yidden.
IP in halacha doesn’t have a straightforward answer.
Philosopher, all the same points can be made regarding someone labelled as “austistic” or “asperger’s syndrome”.
The Rama 246:4 rules explicitly that it is absolutely prohibited according to Halachah to engage in a curriculum of secular studies. To read secular studies now and then, is permitted, he says. The source of the Rama is the Yerushalmi Sanhedrin.
YouTube music has heimishe singers?
Some of our most amazing community members, entrepreneurs, askanim, rebbis, menahlim, teachers and talmidei chachamim are also using their autism properly to make the world a better and more interesting place.
huju: What does your comment have to do with the obligations to follow Hashem’s commandments?
Isn’t the same argument presented regarding autism? That autistic children are simply living their own unique individual life, and don’t need to be changed, and should be accepted as is, being their own normal selves.
Some people don’t care if a book is prohibited by Halacha to be read. If they want to read it, then the heck with Halacha.
RE: what water?
Goyishe books are assur because of seforim chitzonim. The Mishna in Sanhedrin 10:1 that says a person loses his Olam Haboa by reading the wrong books since it corrupts his mind.
Amil: I do not recall you ever criticizing the headline writers and so-called “journalists” during the Trump era who multiple times every day for four years repeatedly and constantly blamed Trump for things he had no control over and/or wasn’t his job.
YO: Are you Orthodox?
Biden is senile. He can’t be blamed for anything since he doesn’t know his right hand from his left hand.
Have any of these spaceships loaded and/or the martians come out to greet us earthlings?
“but the reality is that more girls today ARE learning talmud than ever before both in school… but ultimately aren’t going to dissuade a baas yisroel who wants to…”
The reality today is that more people cheat, wear short skirts and watch treif movies. They, too, aren’t going to be dissuaded by lectures, since they “want to.”
Avira, what about lechatchila staying over Shabbos in a place (Japan, Hawaii, etc) that it is a shaila which day is Shabbos?
CS: Welcome to the Internet! In this neck of the woods, going off topic or on a tangent is par for the course.
“Maybe the message is from Above to make aliyah.”
Maybe the message is from Above to daven and learn more and use less entertainment.
CS: Welcome to the Internet! In this neck of the woods, going off topic or on a tangent is par for the course.
Joey Biden lives as if he’s in space.
CA, AAQ’s sarcastic mocking of Chareidim, by implying they believe mathematics is kfira.
Replaced Ultra-Orthodox with Jews and replace Bennett with Abbas, and he’d be widely accused of antisemitism.
Bennett rightfully and correctly deserves the same (accurate) accusation, his microscopic kippa notwithstanding.
There’s no reason to give a hoot about the “Google Doodle”.
CA, even PG and G have pritzus, kefira and worse.
Shteigallday, it is black and white. All movies spit out by Hollywood are chazer treif.
DBS: Many prefer an unromantic marriage to divorced life. And/or prefer living full time with their children to seeing them once a week. Or might not have the financial wherewithal or desire to pay for two homes rather than one. There can be many reasons why a person would not want to divorce. Even if their married like isn’t all a bed of roses. Often a difficult married like is better than a difficult divorced life.
“Are you denying that there are a lot of legitimate claims of abuse?”
No. My only point is, simply, that to adjudicate the claim (to determine whether the abuse allegation is true or untrue or any other claim) Al Pi Halacha ONLY a Beis Din can make that determination and that it is strictly prohibited to litigate that or any issues in non-Jewish courts or to use secular judges or to utilize any laws other than Torah law.
“My question is in THOSE cases. He know the truth. Is he a bad person for keeping her in a chanied marriage. Even if strictly speaking as far as even haezer goes he is not obligated to divorce her?”
If he abused her of course he’s bad. I’m not sure why you need to even ask. In order to correct his behavior he is required to stop abusing her. The Shulchan Aruch says that if Beis Din ascertains that it was proven the husband was beating his wife the Dayanim are required to order him to stop. And that if it is proven he continued beating her after being warned by Beis Din, the Halacha is the Dayanim can force his to divorce even if he doesn’t want to. That’s the Halacha clearly stated in Shulchan Aruch. If you’re asking regarding a case where he’s beating her (which he obviously knows) but the Beis Din has no proof of it, then of course he’s being bad and is required to stop or agree to divorce (even if Beis Din can’t force him since there’s no proof.)
But if there’s no proof we can’t accept the allegation as true. The Halacha in S”A is clear about that.