Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
commonsaychelParticipant
get a life
commonsaychelParticipant@always ask
“>> ROFL China started this whole mess
mi hu haham? halomed mikol adam …”
Right and what did I learn, don’t trust China, because they could have contained this on the onsetcommonsaychelParticipant@Always ask,
> “That’s not a choice you get to make without a ravI quoted already multiple opinions about being careful. And also opinions about one kaddish being sufficient. Maybe you can verbalize what exactly makes you so uncomfortable.”
Bottom line, did you just read some opinions and made a decision or did you ask a rov “rochel bitcha hakatan” a/k/a your exact situation, huge difference.
This would be the equivalent of operating the grey area of the law by reading a law book and not consulting a lawyer, people ended in prison for that.commonsaychelParticipant@Ct Lawyer, I have full respect for how you saw fit to run your life, can you, Huju, Amil, Charlie etc. say the same about how I decided to run my life?
commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, ROFL China started this whole mess
commonsaychelParticipantCuomo’s lame apology was about as genuine as Trump’s condemnation of the Capitol takeover.
commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, I love the story myself, I heard it when I was a child and it stayed with me.
“On a simple level, shtika k’mode. Rabbi and gabbi heard me and did not correct. And they are quite capable of!”
That may mean the they are doing it lman sholam, not that its the way to do things, I always ask a shaila in regards to Yiddishkiet and I don’t always like the answer but I do it anywaycommonsaychelParticipantStory from Ksav sofer:
There was a woman who immediately upon her husband’s passing, as she had no sons, she asked the rosh yeshivah to arrange for Torah scholars to say kaddish for her husband for the entire eleven months, and also each successive year on the yahrzeit. She also requested that a second kaddish be said each day, having in mind all those souls who have no one saying kaddish for them. This went on for nearly ten years.
In time the window lost all her money but she continued to pay to say Kaddish, she asked Ksav Sofer if the kaddishes were still being said, and he comforted her that they were.
Suddenly the door opened. A distinguished-looking older man entered, turned to the widow, and asked her why she was crying. He told her that he knew of her desperate situation and that he was prepared to help. He then requested of the rosh yeshivah that they all go into his office, and that two scholars of the yeshivah join them. The rosh yeshivah acceded, and summoned two of his five great disciples present that year: his son, Rabbi Shimon Sofer, and Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld.
When they were all assembled, the mysterious guest said, “I know you have five daughters of marriageable age. Let’s figure. Each one needs a thousand kroner for dowry money, and another thousand kroner each for the expenses of the wedding and for buying furniture and setting up a household. So, that is two thousand for each of the five, or ten thousand altogether. Plus, to put your business back on its feet, you need another ten thousand kroner, so that makes twenty thousand altogether.
“All right, then,” he said, “I’ll write you a check.” Whereupon he took a checkbook out of his pocket, tore off a check, wrote the woman’s name on it, inscribed it for twenty thousand kroner and signed it! Before handing it to her, however, he asked the two young scholars to sign on the back as witnesses to the transaction. He also asked them to take out their personal notebooks so he could sign in each a sample of his signature, in case the signature on the check would be challenged. Turning back to the woman, he told her that she should present the check at the government bank when it opened at nine o’clock, and they would honor it. Then he left as suddenly as he had come.
At nine the next morning, the widow was at the bank. The guard at the door directed her to one of the tellers, to whom she showed the check. He looked up the records and told her there was sufficient funds in the account to cover the check, but for such a huge sum he has to first get permission from the manager. He asked her to wait, and went to the administrative section. There he presented the check to the head of the bank, who took one look at it and fainted!
The doctor that was summoned quickly revived the bank manager. As soon as he gained consciousness, the manager asked that the woman who had brought the check be shown in to him. When told she had been locked up by security, he said that he must go to her; a great mistake had been made, to lock up such a righteous woman. He went quickly and, after apologizing, invited her to accompany her into his office.
“Tell me, please,” he opened, after they were seated, “how did you get this check?”
She told him of her difficulties and the sudden appearance of her unknown benefactor. She explained about her deceased husband and his practice of daily maaser, and of the kaddishes she had arranged through the yeshivah for him and for those souls who had no one to say kaddish for them.
He asked her: if she would see her benefactor again, or his picture, would she recognize him? She said yes. She added that two rabbis from the yeshivah were official witnesses to the whole episode, and that their signatures are on the back of the check, and that the man had also signed in their personal notebooks. The manager was excited to hear this, and after looking at their signatures, contacted the yeshivah to ask that Rabbi Sonnenfeld and Rabbi Shimon Sofer come to his office.
They came and confirmed all that the woman had said. The bank manager then told the three of them that he would personally honor the check, as it was drawn on his own family account, but that his wife had to endorse it too. He then sent for his wife with the message that she should come quickly, because people were waiting for her, but first she should collect all the family photographs in the house and bring them with her.
Although the bank manager was a Jew, his wife was not. When she arrived, he asked the widow and the two rabbis to wait in a different room. He told his wife what was going on, and said, “Let’s see if the woman can identify the man who signed the check from among these photographs.” She declared that if it all turned out to be true, she would convert to be Jewish.
The manager then spread out all of the photos on his desk. He asked each of the three to enter separately and see if the man who gave the check appeared in any of them. Each one confidently picked out the same person.
The bank manager called everyone in. “Do you know who is this man who gave the check?” he asked. “It is my father, the manager of the bank before me. But he has been dead for ten years!
“I must confess,” he told them, “that I never said kaddish for him. Last night he appeared to me in a dream. He said that he had been saved from Gehinnom by the kaddishes that she had arranged for the yeshivah scholars to say for those souls for whom kaddish was not being said, and now that she was in difficulty we must help her. He said that he would give her a check for twenty thousand kroner, and that if I didn’t pay it, he would strangle me in my sleep.
When the check was shown to me at the bank, I fainted.
“I woke up, frightened. In the morning I told my wife the dream, and she was disturbed too. When the check was shown to me at the bank, I fainted. I knew then that the dream was true.“I will pay the twenty thousand my father promised, for it is certainly a deserving cause. Not only that,” he added, turning to the woman, “I will add another twenty thousand of my own, because you fulfilled my obligation for me, and helped my deceased father’s soul with the kaddish-saying you arranged.”
He addressed the three of them again. “I fully regret my lapse from Judaism. I see now that our G‑d is the one true G‑d, and He gives to all their just reward. I resolve that from now on I will fulfill His commandments as revealed in our Torah. My wife, too, has reaffirmed her promise to convert and to live in accordance with Jewish law. Please guide us to understand what we have to do.”
commonsaychelParticipant@ always ask “How would this issue be resolved? I thought it is already resolved – someone admitted that they were covering deaths to avoid federal prosecutors.”
Wrong she backpaddled like crazy when the stuff hit the fan, Cuomo is not man enough to admit he messed up.commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, I assume this was done after consultation with a leading posek? or was this done on your own volition?
commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, If the item has a hecksher it come to my house otherwise it does not, no grey area.
Same with a minyan, some shuls restrict to members only and I respect those rules otherwise not a issue.commonsaychelParticipant@always ask questions, your opinion and $2.75 get you on the subway [if your brave enough]
commonsaychelParticipant@Charliehall, that is the textbook definition, you deflect the bad by pointing out something else.
and the PPE fiasco was the worst in NYS, 1 BILLION spent on supplies that were awarded to shell companies with no real inventory, and this jerk of a Governor is not man enough to admit he messed up.commonsaychelParticipant@CT Lawyer, I am proud to say I did not miss a minyan since Covid, In the beginning I davened outdoors then as things abated in May I went indoors, regardless of where I was I followed that particular shuls rules, this past week I was out of state and the shul I daven in had three rules, 1, masks must be worn in the shul [kiddish was outdoors with no masks], 2, Cell phones must be turned off in the shul [weekdays of course, zero tolerance for chillul shabbos] 3, absolutely no talking during davening, the sign in shul said that chazen will stop davening until the talking stops.
commonsaychelParticipant@OrechDin, The insane and false claims you made about were already answered by made alyiah, as to supply chain I am much more upset that NYS squandered a Billon dollars on supplies that were never delivered much more so then Jared hiring college kids.
What is interesting is why the city of New York would wire eight-point-something million dollars to a company that had never sold a ventilator before and had only been incorporated for two weeks.I don’t live in Fl. Ga. or Tx. so what Desantis, Kemp and Abott did does not annoy me as much as Cuomo’s shenanigan’s because I have to clean up his mess with my tax dollars
commonsaychelParticipant#ujm, of for that matter does he know anything about anything besides coming up idea?
commonsaychelParticipant@CharlieHall, “Ron De Santis is getting away with it.”, the best defense is a good offense, I noticed whenever there is bad new about a Democrat you will always pivot to know a Republican, we are talking about what Cuomo admitted he did and you have to mix in others, like when we were talking about Yang hiring a Jewish operative and you had to mix in Jared Kushner
commonsaychelParticipant@CTlawyer, No Jared went to work for his schver in a time honored Jewish tradition
commonsaychelParticipant@Reb Eliezer, It does not mean he likes Jews it means he found a Jewish flunky to put on his payroll
commonsaychelParticipantMordechai Gifter was born in Portsmouth, Virginia to Yisrael and Matla (May) Gifter. He was raised in Baltimore, Maryland, where his father owned a grocery He attended the Baltimore City Public Schools, at the time being known as Max, and received his religious education in after-school programs. He had a younger brother and sister, and both predeceased him.
commonsaychelParticipantThe man is such a jerk he makes Deblaz look normal
commonsaychelParticipant@wolf, so start a new thread with that topic
commonsaychelParticipantRav Moshe Zvi Aryeh Bick (1911-1990). Born in Medzbosz (Mezhbizh), Ukraine, but grew up in New York, he is recognized as one of the first gedolim to be raised on American soil. He studied under R’ Moshe Soloveitchik at the Yeshiva Rabbeinu Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor and attended New York City public schools at night.
February 11, 2021 1:51 pm at 1:51 pm in reply to: Judge issues Permanente Injunction against NYS to enforce on Shuls #1947312commonsaychelParticipant@charliehall, there are a lot of idiotic, irrational and illegal rules that were promulgated in the name of public safety and health and this will go down in the history books as one of them.
Just as I would not go up to some random person smoking cigarettes or pot and tell him not to smoke it, I would not have the temerity to tell someone how to daven.
This shabbos I was out of the Tri State area and the shul I davened in had a full mask policy, they also had a no cell phone use policy during weekday davening [it was a yeshivish place so shabbos was obvious].
My regular shul has no official policy in regard to covid so some wear and some don’t and we all get along with each other.
I fully complied with both rules [covid and cell use] and didn’t have the chutzpa to tell others what to do and that is what I expect anyone davening in our shul to do the same.commonsaychelParticipant@Kollelman:
Rabbi Avigdor Miller was born Victor Miller in Baltimore, Maryland. He was a kohen. Although he attended public school, only Yiddish was spoken at home. After school, he went to learn in an afternoon Talmud Torah.
At age 14, Rabbi Miller went to New York City to attend Yeshivas Rabbenu Yitzchok Elchonon, at the time the only American high school offering high-level Jewish learning.commonsaychelParticipant@ujm, the public schools from the 1880s-1960s whole focus was the melting pot to blending in as Americans not the “gorgeous mosaic” or multiculturalism, not just for the Jews but all groups.
@always ask questions, the topic of this thread is the Gedolim who attended public schools and went on to torah greatness not to push for your agenda of education.commonsaychelParticipant@yseribus
Shlomo (Wilhelm) Wolbe was born in Berlin to Eugen and Rosa Wolbe. He was raised in a secular Jewish home and received his education at the University of Berlin (1930–1933). During his university studies he became a baal teshuva through the efforts of the Orthodox Students Union V.A.D. (Vereinigung jüdischer Akademiker in Deutschland). After university he attended the Hildesheimer Rabbinical Seminary. He continued to study at Rabbi Boczko’s yeshiva in Montreux, Switzerland. He then attended the Mir yeshiva in Poland, where he became a student of the mashgiach ruchani, Rabbi Yeruchom Levovitz, and, to a lesser extent of Rabbi Yechezkel Levenstein.commonsaychelParticipant@trybe, The Boyaner Rebbe father was was a College Professor with a PhD and his brother is a Rocket scientist for NASA but they we are talking about public school not college.
commonsaychelParticipant@the little I know:
Rav Finkel grew up as a “typical American Jewish boy” who enjoyed playing basketball and baseball. He was known as Nathan in school and Natie to his friends. He was one of the first students of the Central Park Hebrew Day School (later renamed Arie Crown Day School) and received after-school tutoring in Torah studies from Rabbi Yehoshua Levinson.commonsaychelParticipantThose who know dont say and those who say dont know.
commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, I dont want to make this I said vs you said, read what I wrote:
“so your Rabbi and your encyclopedia can take the slow boat to China and no one will notice any difference”
Meaning the fact that both feel there is is not such a thing as daas torah makes them completely irrelevant.commonsaychelParticipant@always ask, the Jewish people always had a “moreh derech” since time kabolas hatorah, call it dass torah or other names it not relevant as to what it is called it is our mesorah, I know this does not match your or the OP agenda but that is the fact.
In Oz Yosher we say “vaymeanu behashem ubMoshe avod, first mishna in avos is moshe kebul torah msinai and it lists out the line of succession, the more recent histroy we had the GRA, Talmiday Bal Shem ZTL etc. in the recent past you had the Chofetz Chaim, Reb Chaim Brisker, Sanzer Rebbe ZTL
recently we had Reb Moshe, Rav Elyashiv, Satmar Rebbe ZTL, so your Rabbi and your encyclopedia can take the slow boat to China and no one will notice any differencecommonsaychelParticipant@always ask questions, if that’s the case you have a lot bigger issues then how to do the mitzvas of purim, one of the basic tenants of Frumkiet is “asay lechoh rav”
commonsaychelParticipantHow about everyone should ask the own daas torah and follow what they say,
commonsaychelParticipantThey did such a great job that NYS will lose 2 congressional seat due to population loss, anyone who can leave is doing so
commonsaychelParticipant@Syag, I dont “advocate” for anything in regards to Covid, I ask my daas torah what I should do and I follow his advice, I certainly dont have the chutzpah to tell a godol what to say
commonsaychelParticipant@gadolhatar, each of the Rabbonim who where nifter were well into the 90s the malah havovis has his own bag of tricks, the people who pasken can manage without your input
commonsaychelParticipantAccording to my records your at .008 so you opinion does not matter
commonsaychelParticipant@ godalthorah when you archive 1 half of 1 % of Rav Chaim knowledge I will value your opinion
commonsaychelParticipantPirkei Avos (Ethics of the Fathers) mishna 5:7 outlines 7 signs of the wise anda golem:
“7 [indications] of the golem and 7 of the wise:
1) The wise person does not speak prior to someone greater in wisdom or in years
The opposite is a golem.PS all your topic are very Trollish
January 28, 2021 5:56 pm at 5:56 pm in reply to: Discussion on age of three at maximum age at which an uncle can touch a niece #1943483commonsaychelParticipant@ty I welcome new members, but when the first time he joined the discussion he is posting a trollish topic you can safety assume he is a troll.
January 27, 2021 10:23 pm at 10:23 pm in reply to: Discussion on age of three at maximum age at which an uncle can touch a niece #1943224commonsaychelParticipant@aoish3x3: In Internet slang, a troll is a person who starts flame wars or intentionally upsets people on the Internet. Typically they do this by posting inflammatory and digressive,[1] extraneous, or off-topic messages in an online community (such as a newsgroup, forum, chat room, or blog), with the intent of provoking readers into displaying emotional responses[2] and normalizing tangential discussion.[3] This is typically for the troll’s amusement, or to achieve a specific result such as disrupting a rival’s online activities or manipulating a political process.
a/k/a a bored yeshiva bucherJanuary 27, 2021 3:44 pm at 3:44 pm in reply to: United States – No Unity after an Insurrection #1943018commonsaychelParticipant@jackk, its fine because you have a 50/50 senate and 60 votes to get anything done, so you are forced to compromise
commonsaychelParticipant@ Reb E, its does not address how widespread the minhag of gimmel bshalach is
commonsaychelParticipant@Abba: do people like driving at 55 mph on a wide empty road? no but they do so when they see a police car, the problem is that in Israel everything is kolo politics down to the color of the toilet paper you buy.
In Israel you never see a Chardi and a Choloni doing business together because they are too busy arguing whose derech is right.January 25, 2021 7:42 pm at 7:42 pm in reply to: Is being “eco-friendly” a value that means something to you? #1942423commonsaychelParticipant@Reb Eliezer, firstly use spell check its Ozone layer, second Hashem can repair the hole without our help
commonsaychelParticipant@UJM, the clips showed 97% of the protesters were charedim, and I guarantee that if the outsiders would have said something against Peleg or Rav Aurbach ZTL, they would have been set on fire
commonsaychelParticipant@ujm torching buses, overturning police cars, and shooting out windows are hardly peaceful protests
January 25, 2021 10:37 am at 10:37 am in reply to: Is being “eco-friendly” a value that means something to you? #1942238commonsaychelParticipantI just leased a hybrid car, the reason I got it was because the lease was cheapest if the gas guzzler would have been cheaper I would have gotten that. The fact that I spend less on gas is a plus, the environment had zero effect on my decision.
PS worshiping mother earth is avodah zorah plain and simple much to the dismay of the MO tikun haolam crowd.commonsaychelParticipant@trybepolite, its the cookies you dropped when you went to the inappropriate sights, now go back to yeshiva
-
AuthorPosts