Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Why just words?
Maybe you have a limited number of swallows and then you die. And blinks. And a limited number of steps. And a limited number of head scratches.
And whenever you hit the limit on any of them, you die. Sounds just as likely.
A .22? What, in case a squirrel comes attacking?
It would have been about as helpful against this guy as a spitball.
Wow. Three good popa posts in one short thread. Bumping for nachas.
I don’t think it’s a bad habit.
But, you do. So I’m letting you know that you are at fault for what I consider good, but you consider bad.
After he is first thrown in jail for 2 years.
PBA – please stop insulting.
MDG: I think it is necessary to point out to everyone that this man knows nothing, and nothing he writes can be relied upon in any manner.
RD – you have a decent amount of knowledge and good analysis skills, but please be careful when you speak. You’re not a posek.
MDG: I also don’t like to put people down, but here it is very necessary. He is maligning the entire minhag ashkenaz as being merely a chumrah or a choice. He is not merely being disrespectful to the acharonim (his usual modus operandi)– he is completely wrong.
I don’t know if he has good analytical skills or not. I do know that he knows less than nothing. Less than nothing, because even what he knows just makes things worse, because he twists and misconstrues it. Thus, less than nothing.
And, in case you are wondering, MDG, I had to say all this to counter what you just said. So maybe if you don’t want to see me need say more about RD, you should just keep out of it.
yay. you found a rema that you think I don’t hold like.
There are myriad rema’s that we don’t hold like. We generally do hold like him, but it isn’t a rule.
You seriously know less than nothing.
The Rema’s shita is a chumra, period. He holds like one rishon, while the Beis Yosef/Mechaber holds like all the other rishonim. Ashkenazic stringency does not equal halakha.
Are you calling the Mechaber incorrect? Do you pasken like the Rema when he says that you can hold a wedding on Shabbat and that it is mutar to drink wine made by goyim in places where that is customary? Stop being foolish now.
Wow. You really know even less than nothing. It really is quite bewildering.
With all due respect, you don’t know anything.
We (ashkenazim) pasken like that rema min hadin. The OU is absolutely not following the mechaber on that for anything.
If you pasken like the sefardim, by all means. But it is beyond ridiculous to present it as a choice or a chumrah.
rd: Being DE is not the same as being pareve, and your story therefore makes no sense. If they are ever labeled “pareve”, they would not be DE. And DE was never a way of telling us the “truth”, because DE is different than pareve.
No, it is under the working assumption that being successful at whatever you are trying to do, is a good thing.
My unscientific observation is that the children of the full tuition paying gvirim, (those young motivated go getters who got where they are because they are very aggressive) have a much higher incidence of ADD.
Which should lead us to conclude, that ADD is not a bad thing.
DaasYochid: Those halachicly required divorces you are referring to are generally speaking, too, an indication of a lack of sholom bayis.
Not where he’s a kohen.
Nah, sometimes it’s just that they were hypnotized accidentally while watching a magic show, and had their memories switched, so that they think they didn’t have shalom bayis, but really they did.
That’s why any competent rav would ask if they have been to a magic show lately before granting a divorce.
I have a third option, but I think all 3 are true.
I’d add that the parents of the “good learners” tend to be happier with the school and the rebbe.
Certainly not. I assume since it has a “D”, that is must be made in milchig keilim which are ben yomo.
I’ll help.
You have no idea what gaava is, and you have no idea what chazal were talking about.
I’m not sure you have any idea about anything.
wikipedia.com
I’m listening. So far he said that they don’t have a DE designation, because they think we will get confused. I find it bewildering that they are more concerned about that, than that we will eat it assuming it is keilim, if they think it is not ok. http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/ou-kashrus-is-not-reliable
Then he talks about reading the ingredients. He says that there may be dairy in the “natural flavors”. That seems true; natural flavors means flavoring derived from things thought of as food. Maybe we should be choshesh when it says “natural flavors”. But many products don’t have natural flavors.
Then he talks about allergy warnings. He says they will require warning if there are 3ppm. But then vaguely says there are times they will not require that, but no examples. I’ll look up the laws.
I don’t believe him; and think if they cared, they would have a DE designation. I think they know you can just look at the allergy warning and they are relying on that. (And I still have no idea how they would not recall a product which they knew was mislabled. DE will cause confusion, but no D on a milchig product won’t cause confusion?)
As far as I know YU doesnt have a best selling author like Williamsburg does
dog bites man. man bites dog.
Although, to be fair, I went back and read the bleach post in question, and I dunno…
Not to give a psak, but if a food has no milk derivatives listed and also has allergy info and doesn’t list milk, I eat it when I’m fleishig.
I’m suing Joseph.
And I’m asking for zabla. I choose Squeak as my Dayan. He may choose any of his alter names. I hope they will choose together a real person, not another alter name.
Well, since this is the thread that drove off Feif, I went back through it to see what I had said, and if I was “a bit over the top”.
I’m proud to say that I am proud of all my posts on this thread, and I don’t think any of them are what drove Feif off.
I am especially proud of this one, which was kind of a joke:
Do people need to be denigraded or their beliefs???
No, but people need to denigrate, and the best targets are people. People should learn to live with it.
I’ve been called worse.
The mods are busy; things slip through.
far east,
I’m sure you agree there are wrong ways to practice Judaism. And we certainly agree there are ways other than our own to practice Judaism. We only disagree on which are which.
So’s I’m not sure what you are trying to argue without reference to specific customs.
lolol
If you had cancer would you only see a same gender doctor?
Why should people who suffer from mental illness be treated any differently
Does the cure for cancer involve the doctor relating to you emotionally?
Look, I’m fine with you thinking that it is ok. But to say there is nothing to talk about and that it is exactly like having an opposite gender cashier at the bakery–that’s a bit much.
To popa bar abba
Do you post something on every Topic?
???? ?? ???? ?????? ????
Also, you should ask that on my thread for asking questions, not on Feif’s.
Also, you should go stick your head in a big bowl of raw latke mix.
squeak: It’s also lashon nekia. ????? ??? ????? ?????
Do you think that just because I never went bungee jumping that I won’t like it? People like it.
That’s too bad. I like feif, even if we often disagreed. I probably did disagree too strongly sometimes, so it probably is partially my fault.
Actually, I probably liked him because we disagreed. It is no fun to talk to people who agree with you, and you don’t learn anything new by doing so either.
There is a website I was basically chased off because I was in the minority position, so I know what its like.