Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 19, 2011 6:27 pm at 6:27 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909423Dr. PepperParticipant
Abe Cohen-
Thanks for answering.
DaasYochid-
If he wants to maintain his anonymity on this website that’s fine with me. My issue is the style of his posts which are meant to imply that they are not the same person. That, in my opinion, is dishonest.
July 19, 2011 5:24 pm at 5:24 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909417Dr. PepperParticipantAZ-
So let’s take this slowly,
Are you R’ Moshe Pogrow?
Were you the one who removed the website yesterday?
Both are “Yes” or “No” questions.
Dr. PepperParticipantcoffee addict-
I’m sorry you feel that way about NY, did you come here to visit for a few days before before spending so much money to move here?
Without knowing anything about you I don’t know how much I can help you.
Here’s an idea regarding the recycling issue you seem to be having. A friend of mine offered me a ride but said I have to sit in the front (and hold his seforim/ books) because the back of his car was piled high with trash- and that was an understatement!
He explained that he has a date in Baltimore the next week and ever since he agreed to go out with her his father insisted on throwing all the trash into the back of his car instead of sorting it. He told him to throw the garbage into the cans by the girls house before knocking on the door.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
Let Me explain, If u are a real freind u should be heavily involoved in Shidduchim, if not, then let the Shadcahnim run the show!!!!
Hold on a second there- before giving shadchanim the green light to run the show, let’s set down a list of rules for them to follow:
(This is in now way an all inclusive list, it is strictly my opinion and copied from a different thread.)
1. Don’t lie- If someone asks a question it usually means that it’s important to them. It’s not up to you to decide what’s important or not.
2. Don’t stalk- I found it creepy when Shadchannim found out who I previously dated and who I was currently dating. It’s none of your business and if you “happened” to have found out somehow you are not allowed to share this information!
3. Don’t give my name out without my permission- If I never asked you to put my name on your list but you got it from my yeshiva please ask me before distributing it. It’s not fair to my friends, neighbors, Rabbeim and relatives to get numerous calls about me when I can’t possibly date all of them anyway. It’s also not fair to me to get a reputation as a guy who says “no” to everyone.
4. Don’t use excessive pressure- If it’s a “no” then it’s “no”, if I need more information then I’ll let you know.
It’s a shame these even have to be mentioned, it’s all common sense to me.
Dr. PepperParticipantDo a Google search for “learn yiddish vidlit”.
There is a beginner video there.
Sorry but I don’t think we’re allowed to post external links. 🙁
July 19, 2011 3:36 pm at 3:36 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909410Dr. PepperParticipantI didn’t speak with him personally, I heard from someone else that he was approached and asked to sign but he refused. I honestly have no idea why he didn’t sign and it wouldn’t be fair to speculate.
July 19, 2011 2:09 pm at 2:09 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909407Dr. PepperParticipantAZ-
As in the past- the more answers I get the more questions I have.
The website was fully active (including all links) as of last week, I find it very suspicious that once I mentioned it it disappeared.
Can you please explain why whatever was written on the 1,000 letters sent out is too private to post on the website for the benefit of everyone who didn’t receive the mailing?
The time and costs for maintaining a website that small is minimal compared to the costs of a mass mailing (and is dwarfed next to the $100,000+ that was given out)- can you explain how they had the time and money for the mailing, which only reached a small subset of the frum population, while they didn’t have the time to keep the website current (which could reach the entire frum population with Internet access)?
From what I saw I definitely can insinuate that someone is hiding behind a cloak on anonymity. I read frum magazines and frequent frum websites and I have never seen the name of a single human being associated with the organization (aside from the same name that came up four times when I did some investigation). How am I supposed to know what you send to mothers of boys in Lakewood when I never was one or will be one? Beside, the e-mail address “[email protected]” does nothing to identify a human.
To answer your question- I don’t know what my R”Y thinks about NASI or anything they stand for. I asked if he signed it and was told that he didn’t (he wasn’t there at the time but a talmid told me he was present when the NASI representative stopped by and the R”Y refused to sign).
Dr. PepperParticipantshlishi-
Did you used to go by the name “volvie”?
Dr. PepperParticipantshlishi-
I agree, but there were times that I was told that if I agree to go out with a girl- since she is flying out to meet me I have to commit to two dates. Saying “no” after just one would have been dishonest and highly offensive.
Also going out for a fourth time when one is not interested when compared to two weeks of non-stop harassment may be the lesser of two evils.
Imagine how much more prevalent these torture tactics will become once the shadchanim know that they will be receiving compensation.
July 18, 2011 6:33 pm at 6:33 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909385Dr. PepperParticipantAZ-
I’m not the mother of a single boy in Lakewood and I didn’t get the letter, therefore I don’t know what it says. I was going by the ads I saw in the Yaated and the text from the website which was there until last week but has since disappeared. The lack of any human being mentioned in the ads or website is what I based my statement on.
As apushatayid mentioned
“The letter” that keeps getting mentioned has signatures of R”Y who encourage closer in age shidduchim, nothing more, nothing less.
Nothing in the letter says anything about sending $50 to a mystery address. In my opinion, asking people to send $50 to an address without a name is hiding behind a cloak of anonymity. I wouldn’t consider it
discontinued after a a few tries. That was a few years ago.
when it was still there last week.
I have no interest in contacting Pac – Man, I know how my R”Y feels about the project and that’s all I that matters to me.
For all those who weren’t able to see the nasiproject.com website before it went down over the weekend- here is the text of what was there (sorry but I didn’t save the links):
Welcome
The NASI Project
760 Close In Age Shidduchim and Counting.
In under 2 years we have B”H accomplished much.
With more help from the community we could accomplish much more.
We ask all families with children in shidduchim to contribute $50 to the NASI Project.
USA:
YSH – NASI
8448 118th Street
Kew Gardens, NY 11415
Canada:
VMM
6887 Wilderton Avenue
Montreal, Quebec H3S2M3
For additional information, please contact us:
The NASI Project IS working. Proven 760x already.
? Help us help YOU ?
CLOSE THE AGE GAP – SOLVE THE CRISIS
The NASI Project is endorsed by Ziknei Roshei Yeshiva Shlita,
and under the direct daily auspices of leading Roshei Yeshiva.
Our overhead is practically zero. The small handful of individuals involved in the project,
are all volunteers. Every penny goes towards facilitating more close in age shidduchim.
July 18, 2011 3:06 pm at 3:06 pm in reply to: Sleepaway Camps taking advantage of their staff. #787301Dr. PepperParticipantcherrybim-
I agree 100%.
No one is forcing them to take the job.
You can also look it at another way-
How much would you pay to have full time supervision of your teenage child? Being in a structured environment with three tefilos a day (for your son), learning, three nutritious meals, while surrounded by their peers and given responsibilities that help them mature into adults.
Now to think that not only do you not have to pay for this but they also earn some spending money- I think it’s a great deal.
Dr. PepperParticipantAZ-
We probably agree on many more things, if you would have had the decency to read my posts from beginning to end instead of just shouting back “You’re totally ridiculous” the second you saw something that challenged your position, you would have seen this.
As far as what the compensation should be for a shadchan, I never thought about this seriously. My first thought would be to have it the way it is where I work- no compensation until after the contracts are signed and the account is opened. True, this may mean that through no fault of the agent the client backed out at the last second, but that’s business.
Also, if the account is closed within a year the agent has to return the comission. If this happens too many times the agent gets audited to see what is going on. (In extreme cases agents have been let go, lost their license or even arrested when illegal activities were uncovered.)
At times, especially when one of the two parties flies in for a date, the two of them could rack up 3 dates without getting serious. If the shadchan knows that after one more date he/ she will receive compensation regardless of the outcome… I’ll let you figure out on your own what will happen.
Dr. PepperParticipantI once almost got busted, my quick wit saved me.
Someone told me that on a website called “theyeshivaworld” there is someone impersonating me. The poster uses my name and posts riddles that I like asking. She suggested that I check it out.
I told her that I don’t have time for such things and she should tell the person to “get a life”.
July 18, 2011 2:01 pm at 2:01 pm in reply to: A third of Litvish families I know, have one or more single daughters 25 and up #909380Dr. PepperParticipantshlishi-
AZ tries to hide behind a cloak on anonymity, you may have noticed that on the NASI website or any of the ads they take out there is no mention of name of any human (aside from the 70 R”Y who signed the letter he doesn’t stop talking about). You’ll see an address where he wants people to send $50 but there is no name associated with the address in the ad.
When I first heard of NASI and tried to take the organization seriously, my first goal was to identify the person behind the curtain. I used 4 different methods, came up with the same name each time and am confident that I know the name of AZ (I don’t know him in real life, just his name and where he lives.)
There were some inconsistencies along the way though. Before he published the names of the 70 R”Y I had just assumed that my R”Y was one of them. He wasn’t there when I went to speak with him so I asked a close talmud if anyone from NASI spoke to the R”Y about signing the letter. The name he gave me was the name I associated with AZ. AZ denies being the one to go around to the R”Y.
For the record my R”Y did not sign the letter and is not one of the two R”Y that AZ knows of that did not sign.
Dr. PepperParticipantbinahyeseira-
100% correct, I was just speaking from my point of view.
Dr. PepperParticipantEnglishman-
He’s just a colleague of mine.
Dr. PepperParticipantStudies have shown that the best time to inform employees is Friday afternoon.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
On the same note, shadchanim should be having in mind what’s for both the guy and the girl.
This means no twisting the guys hands or turning up the heat because the girl says that this is the guy that she’s looking for when this is not what he’s looking for.
Dr. PepperParticipantam yisrael chai-
I’m sorry if anything I wrote hurt you. Let me try to explain things one at a time.
Firstly- I didn’t answer your question in the Shabbos Lock thread because I thought the mods wouldn’t let it through. I had asked what I thought was an innocent question and didn’t receive a response. If I was interested in hiding the post I would not have posted what number it is.
Secondly- I read very few threads on this forum and didn’t know about your tragedies until I read it here. One post of yours that I did read reminded me of a poster I came across on a different site. Being that this poster has a different SN than yours I left a hint that would let you know what I was talking about without mentioning the SN. (It was not the bragging that reminded me of the other poster.) I was only trying to find out if it was you so I can send you a private message on the other site with a link to the discussion you wanted to view.
Thirdly- I only asked the question here because I assumed that you missed it on the other thread as I didn’t see any posts from you afterwards.
If you were offended by anything I wrote please accept my sincerest apologies and believe me that I never intended to hurt you.
Please also accept my deepest sympathy for the tragedies you experienced.
Dr. PepperParticipantI didn’t think the mods would let it go through and I suspected that I know you from a different site. I was hoping you’d tell me it was you so I could send you a PM on the other site letting you know where to look.
When you didn’t respond I thought I was on to something.
Anyway- so how did I meet my wife?
After my mother told all professional shadchanim to never call again (unless they had a guy for one of my sisters) there was this eerie silence. Then the phone rang. My mother just assumed it was someone violating the do not call policy doubting that a shadchan had someone for any of my sisters.
Turns out it was a neighbor and close friend who wanted to suggest the daughter of a high school classmate that she was close with. You could figure out the rest.
Unfortunately after we got engaged she proclaimed herself a professional shadchan and sent her husband to yeshiva to interview some guys. The guys didn’t believe that she was honest since she considered herself a professional and didn’t want to talk to her husband. She gave up on being a shadchan.
Dr. PepperParticipantam yisrael chai-
I’ll answer that if you first answer my question from the Shabbos Lock thread;
Did we meet each other on a different site?
(The person I’m thinking of brags to have started the thread with the most replies and views.)
Dr. PepperParticipantbut why did you have so many stories?
It’s not just me, many of my friends had these same issues and blacklisted most, if not all, professional shadchanim.
Dr. PepperParticipantHere’s one that really ticked me off (without the shadchan actually giving me a hard time).
One Purim a guy came to her house stone drunk to give her Mishloach Manos. While she was preparing one for him he couldn’t resist the urge to go to her computer and copy her “shadchan” folder onto a floppy drive, which he later posted on the internet.
When he sobered up and realized that what he did was wrong, he removed the files but not before I downloaded them. There were three files in the folder, Bochurim.doc, Girls.doc and Outcome.xls all of which were time stamped recently.
Let’s take a break for a second- I am not blaming the shadchan for what happened so far, the guy admitted he was totally wrong and I hope everyone agrees. I opened up the two Word files and the information I knew about the guys matched as well as the information about the girls that she tried setting me up with (there were some names on the list that I never heard of though). I never opened the Outcome file, as tempting as it was, nor did I ever share these files with anyone.
So someone made an anonymous call to a Rov about this incident, asking if the Rov could call the shadchan to take measures to insure this incident could never happens again.
The shadchan denied the whole incident. She claimed that she has a different computer in a different room that is password protected and she is the only one with the password. She also NEVER lets any of her kids (or anyone else for that matter) use her computer.
Dr. PepperParticipantadorable-
Both.
Some posters have said, “What’s the big deal? if the girl isn’t what you are looking for, just say ‘no’ and it’s over with”. Nothing could be further than the truth.
I’m not sure if this is the proper thread for Shadchanim horror stories but if no one minds I’ll post some of them here.
Dr. PepperParticipantPac-Man-
The next time we went we checked and on the menu it says in small letters that 18% gratuity is added. Since we were expecting it we watched the incompetence of the staff and got a kick out of it.
Please don’t get sidetracked though, the main point of what I was saying was that people will work harder when there is competition and their compensation depends on performance. Not when customers are throwing money in their direction.
Dr. PepperParticipantDroid-
I could never tell. I probably laughed at some serious stuff that he said.
real-brisker-
He didn’t just save that receipt, he saved everything, and in an organized manner. It was fascinating looking back at all the stuff from 70 to 80 years ago that most people wouldn’t have bothered saving.
The hardware store was around the corner and looked like it was there for many years. I can’t guarantee that it was the same company (I didn’t look) but it looked like a standard switch.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
Just because people are paid more doesn’t mean they do a better job. Look at union employees for starters.
My wife and I went out to eat once. After taking our order we never saw the waitress again. One of us had to go to the kitchen to get the food, keep refilling our glasses with water, clean up, get a waiter to ask for the dessert menu and get our bill. “At least we don’t have to leave a tip”, my wife joked. But they were one step ahead of us, the 18% gratuity was automatically included.
According to your theory the waitress should have done a wonderful job since she was getting 18% right?
(When I asked where she was so I can thank her I was told that she went home 90 minutes earlier.)
Dr. PepperParticipantPac-Man-
You call this getting nasty? You should hear what I have to say about them when I’m not worried about my posts getting deleted!
Dr. PepperParticipantBased on a joke from the Readers Digest some years ago.
Telemarketer calls shadchan: Hello, this is a telephone poll…
Shadchan: Do I know the perfect traffic light for you…
Dr. PepperParticipantDroid-
He kept everything not just that reciept.
He always made sure to never waste anything but I still don’t know if he was joking or not since he always kept a straight face.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
I’m also.
I’ll repeat this again for the benefit of those who haven’t read it in other threads.
I always tell my wife that even if the only thing she ever did for me was rescue me from those nasty shadchanim I’d still be forever indebted to her.
Dr. PepperParticipantreal-brisker-
Do what I do, go to the Customer Service desk and be honest.
Here’s a funny story that happened with my grandparents.
I went to visit them while I was a teenager and my grandfather mentioned to me that the light switch in his study didn’t work. He gave me a $1 bill and asked to get another one from the hardware store around the corner. I brought home the new one and my grandfather noticed that the box said it had a 20 year warranty. He then went to get the receipt from the broken one (which was 19 years and 9 months old) and asked if I could get a refund.
I refused to return an $.85 object that was older than me!
Dr. PepperParticipantNot that I have any details in what is going on-
But…
When I would be harassed by nasty shadchanim I’d tell them that everything has to go through my mother. She did great as a firewall.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
Why don’t you just leave them alone?
You’ll be doing yourself a favor as well as the guy and his mother.
Dr. PepperParticipantHow about writing a nice poem on a card.
From my experience, presents that take time yet have a minimal cost are more valuable than expensive gifts.
May you and your wife be zoche to have many more happy years together.
(And may the two of you enjoy reading this poem out loud at your 50th anniversary.)
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
I’d like to agree with you but from my personal experience common sense and shadchonim are mutually exclusive.
Droid- Thanks for agreeing.
Dr. PepperParticipantIUseBrains-
Please don’t take offense, but you seem like the kind of shadchan that my friends and I had to blacklist.
When a shadchan gives a girls name to a guy it is up to him (and his parents) what to do from there. My mother told one shadchan to never call her back after she said “you think you’re being farfrumpted, well you’re being farcrumped. You have to tell me why you’re saying ‘no’. I’m a professional shadchan and therefore the issur of Loshon Hora doesn’t apply to me. Stop being a chanyukkel on someone elses cheshbon.”
(My mother worked with this girl and had wonderful things to say about her (including that there was nothing wrong with her) but she knew her well enough to know that she wasn’t for me.)
Who are you to decide what is unjustified? What is important to one person may be a non-issue to someone else and vice versa.
The shadchanim need to learn to be civilized or they are ruining the chances for many girls who otherwise may have no access to guys in yeshiva.
(If the guy and his mother are harrassing you non-stop to find him a shidduch and this is how they are acting then I see where you are coming from.)
Dr. PepperParticipantHey Doc,
We missed you at the department meeting today. Is everything OK?
Dr. PepperParticipantHe was talking about the president who fired him.
Dr. PepperParticipantBezalel-
I wrote it, Moderator-80 edited it about 90 seconds after approving it.
Dr. PepperParticipantPost your questions here.
Many of us would love to help you.
Dr. PepperParticipantShrek-
You unlocked a can of worms.
Dr. PepperParticipantHeard this from a non-reliable source who claimed it was true but I don’t believe it.
Here is goes.
An ex-Rabbi is speaking by his good bye party after being fired by the president of the shul for being too Frum:
There were three things that complained to Hashem that they were being sidelined;
1. Asher Yotzar,
2. Aleinu and
3. Mamzeirim.
Asher Yotzar complained that it is such an important brocha but people rush through it every morning while half asleep. Hashem decreed that from then on, everyone will say the brocha a few times a day.
Aleinu complained that people rush through saying it while on their way out of shul and no one has the proper concentration. Hashem decreed that from then on Aleinu will play a major role in the Yomim Noraim davening.
Mamzeirim complained that they didn’t do anything wrong yet they are punished for life. They can’t marry anyone but another mamzer and they have to carry the shame with them where ever they go. Therefore Hashem decreed that a mamzer should be the president of this very congregation…
Dr. PepperParticipantI can’t give you too much information, but let me suggest that you don’t join the FBI.
Ames is a female, she made it quite clear when her daughter was born 11 months ago.
There are a handful of posts from her that were written after the incident and are still there.
Dr. PepperParticipanton the ball-
There are a few reasons why we decided to donate anonymously (although it’s not set in stone).
#1. When I was in Kollel I was asked to put in a full page ad for a family member being honored. I explained that I was in Kollel and couldn’t afford a full page ad. The dinner chairman told me to give what I want and he’ll give me a full page ad. (Thinking back, I don’t think it was fair that someone who paid full price should only get the same recognition as someone who paid a small fraction.)
#2. A Rebbe I was close with was being honored and I had lots of Hakaras Hatov for the special attention he gave me as well as the kesher he kept up for 20+ years. I decided to put in a full page “thank you” at $500. I later found out that a younger grade was having a hard time scraping together $25 a piece from the 20 classmates and I felt it was arrogant to have a full page ad next to theirs and I asked the journal committee not to publish it. (They sent the Rebbe a copy of the ad and an explanation as to why I requested that it not be published.)
#3. A shy neighbor (who has helped us with the kids in the past) asked us to put in an ad for her yearbook. The school warned that anyone who didn’t raise a few hundred dollars for the yearbook cost would have a picture of an elephant in the yearbook instead of theirs and she thought it may hurt her shidduch prospects. I was willing to put in an ad but my wife said it will be offensive to her parents if someone else places a larger ad than they were able to afford. My wife gave her the full amount (so that she wouldn’t have to ask others who may insist on placing an ad).
Dr. PepperParticipantPac-Man-
Moshe is my younger brother. Instead of putting my name they put “anonymous” but it was put where my name would have gone alphabetically so it defeated the purpose.
Dr. PepperParticipantam yisrael chai-
Did we meet each other on a different site?
(The person I’m thinking of brags to have started the thread with the most replies and views.)
Dr. PepperParticipantYW Moderator-42-
I don’t know of any in that thread that were deleted, although there may be some from when my wife shared this SN with me. (Too lazy to check.)
There is one that I see has been removed although I don’t know why or by who. Some time ago I asked someone if their SN had anything to do with a bungalow colony. I’m not sure what was inappropriate or offensive with that comment, unless a moderator thought it would blow the persons identity?
Dr. PepperParticipantDroid-
That I can’t answer.
I can answer what happened to me in a similar case.
This same R”Y told me about working Tisha B’av before chatzos, “you won’t see any mazal in the work done”.
Sure enough, the work I did was all wrong and not only did I have to do it again, but I also had to notify all those who relied on my work that the data is bad.
(That is the only time I recall making the error I made that morning.)
Dr. PepperParticipantoomis1105-
That’s correct. We always ask for our names not to be mentioned. One organization that lists all their donors and their amounts had the following…
…
Anonymous- $???
Moshe Pepper- $???
…
I’m sure no one figured out who it was.
-
AuthorPosts