Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Vhu yimshol Bach. She must go to him
People who defend monsters should be jailed with them
“I also just finished putting up the meatballs for meatballs and spaghetti for tonight.”
Meatballs and spaghetti are not Shabbas foods.
The gedolim said it’s assur for a woman to learn Gemara. End of story.
Ask a gadol then
Look at what the gedolim did and do the same.
I’m sorry if your so desensitized to kedusha that you can have treif cookbooks in your house. I can’t eat some where where there is such a lack of kedusha
Yes. The mishna says bfairush that learning Torah is more important than biker cholim and kibbud av veim. Talmud Torah kneged kulam.
Talmud Torah kneged kulam. It’s more important than bikur cholim. You should have been at the shiur, except that the rov said that you’re not welcome there anymore.
Wolf,
I asked my Rav about sneezing. He said it’s not a problem. Now you ask about whether or not your allowed to stay with your wife because you started the relationship in such a tumahdik way.
“Wolf, do you know mosherose IRL? (Just because his posts are almost always in response to you)”
I know who wolf is. I dont think he knows who I am.
“I spoke with the rav and he said that if this person is stealing from the shul then he is not welcome to come back to the shul for the shiurim the dinners or even davening.
Well, then, it’s a good thing he’s not stealing from the shul, so he’s welcome to come.”
He himself admitted above that it’s stealing.
I spoke with the rav and he said that if this person is stealing from the shul then he is not welcome to come back to the shul for the shiurim the dinners or even davening.
No joke. If he has treif recipes in his home, I have to wonder if his wife ever made any of them. I can’t speak a out you but in general a yid should not have treif recipes like pork and basar bchalav in his home.
I had a similar case regarding kashrus not shabbos. I was in a friends house where I used to eat until I saw a cookbook with treif recipes in it. After that, I feel that I can’t trust his kashrus anymore and I don’t eat there.
Wolf if your afraid to ask a shaila then it’s only because your afraid of what the answer will be. A true Ben Torah is never afraid to ask a shaila.
Who gave you the right to take the shul’s food and shiurim if you think it’s leeching off of them.
Perhaps you’re right (for once). Perhaps I should stop “stealing” their services.
The Wolf
If you truly feel that way I’ll speak to the rav of the shul (Rav S.) about keeping you out of the shul so you don’t “steal” their services anymore.
“So, then, you have no problem with me making statements such as that everyone must dress up in bumblebee costumes because my Rav said so?”
I don’t believe any rov ever gave such a psak. Why are you spreading false halachos?
If you think yur leeching off the shul then maybe you shouldn’t go to that shul for a shiur or any minyanim? Who gave you the right to take the shul’s food and shiurim if you think it’s leeching off of them. Perhaps Burech Bendit (the person from the shul who posted above) should tell you that your not welcome until you stop leeching and support the shul.
If possible lay off frum yidden last.
Normal people dont take little girls into mens bathrooms no matter how young
Men have no busness being where there will be bunches of teenage girls. Thats how terrible things happen. Back in the old days you never had men going to womens graduations.
They did the right thing since its assur becuz of tznius to have pictures of women anyway.
“All shirts are okay, t-shirts included.”
Arent most tshirts short sleeve? How can they be okay in a frum camp?
“Peter Phillips is the Queen’s oldest grandson. He’s not a prince because he’s the son of the Queens daughter and, according to the Letters Patent issued by George V, only children of the Sovereign’s sons are styled as Princes and Princesses.”
Baloney. If he was the queens grandson hed be a prince like William and harry. This only proves that you made it up.
Whatever my mother makes for me.
“So, you’re saying then that they kept Shabbos in Mitzrayim, with all the Halachos? If so, then what was given at Marah?”
Yur still arguing on a midrash? Do you think you know what happened in mitzrayim better than chazal?
Someone who gets bkaas is like he worshiped avoda zara. Dont do it.
“Guy does something chivalrous for girl. (Holds open the door, walks her to the door, carrys her packages…)”
Thats the sort of thing that shows that goyish culture has crept into the Torah wurld. Men shouldnot be acting chilvirous for women. chivalry is not the Torah way.
I would definitely be more scared of chametz on pesach. How can anyone NOT be afraid of chametz on pesach. Hashem will save me from radition, but not from teh aveira of having chametz on pesach. Anyone who sez differntly is showing his true values.
“I hope to God that I’ve raised my daughter with enough sense to realize that if she’s seeing a guy whose going to decide whether or not to marry her based on any amount of money that I “must” give, then she’s obviously seeing the wrong guy.”
In other words youve already decided that your daughter cant marry a learning guy. Shows how much you value torah learning.
“I do not believe the request is unreasonable. Had it been me (I do have secular magazines around the house) and I had guests over, I would have understood the request to put such magazines out of sight*, even if I don’t mind having them around the house.”
So its okay if the gests keep halachah in yur house. Very nice of you.
“because you think pictures of women are untznius”
Pictures of women ARE untznius.
“Yes. I won a megillah will a large silver case that I never use”
Why dont you use the megillah you won? I know that if I won a megillah Id be sure to use it every year.
“2. You forgot Peter Philips’ marriage to Autumn Kelly.”
Who is Peter Philips? If he was really a prince hed be Prince Peter. Dont make up stuff.
Goyish famous marriages never last. Just look at Hollywood where everyone gets divorced about three weeks after getting married.
“That may have been the first time they stopped working for a day en masse, but they certainly didn’t keep the halachos of Shabbos en masse. Shabbos, as you are well aware, is not merely the ceasing of labor. There’s no reason to expect that absent a specific command to do so (which did not exist) that no one wrote a single word, or engaged in borer or even cooked a meal.”
If the midrash sez they kept shabbas, then tehy kept shabbas. Who do you think you are to argue against a midrash?
If someones a rasha why would you want to help his nesahama anyway. Let him rot in gehenim.
“I’ll also add my usual R. Falk disclaimer that that book is not accepted as Halacha by most of the male “Yeshivish” Olam (as opposed to the sems) or Charaidim in EY, and certainly not by the chassidim (all of which have their own mesorah). Ask your own LOR for actual practice. “
Everythng Rav Falk says is 100% HALACHAH! He gives youthe sources for everything he says.
Whats the question. Everyone nose that TV is assur and anyone who says anythign else is lying.
“No more happy for almost a whole year. “
Are you only happy during Adar?
“Nonetheless, her claim is borne out by the facts of her particular case.”
Ill believe Chazal and the meforshim over any “facts” anyday. i dont believe she lived past 122. I bet its all a scam or misstake.
“OK, I think we all agree that married kids don’t have the right (and it is not proper for them) to demand payment/support from their parents/in-laws, correct?”
I disagree. A nadin has been important part of halachah for a long time. As part of a nadin you get to demand things from yur kallahs parents. Are you saying that the nadin isnt Torah?
“Heh. Now that you bring it up, I’m always amused at the fact that we are called Orthodox Jews when we are, in fact, most assuredly not Orthodox.”
Does this mean that your admitting that your not frum becuz yur saying that yur not orthodox?
Rav Moshe and Rav Belsky both paskened that the eruv in brooklyn is assur. What else is thier to talk about?
I want to give a yasher koach to the modorators for protecting us from shmutz.
“By many Bnei Torah, a husband will not call his wife by her first name if non immediate family is around. “
And many more wont use her first name at all even if their alone in private.
“Is it OK if my cousin sometimes calls me by my first name? He usually just says like “uh excuse me..””
If hes going to talk to you at all he shuld call you Miss or Mrs. whatever yur last name is.
Also I dont know if a mixed Purim seuda is a good idea eether.
I was nice it was a fair question. There was no attack just a question.
No, it was an attack by implication.
“I noticed twice yesterday that guys were calling girls by their first name in public”
No man shuld EVER call a woman by her first name in public unless its his daugter or granddaugter.
Please. Be nice.
(Also, I thought you might get the hint after you were deleted 3 times.)