Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
RightJew said this on 2025 December 31:
“שהכל מעלין לא”י ואין הכל מוציאין משם הכל מעלין לירושלים ואין הכל מוציאין
Anyone may initiate ascent to Eretz Yisrael,
and no one may compel departure;
anyone may initiate ascent to Jerusalem,
and no one may compel departure. ”(Shulchan Aruch, chelek Even HaEzer 75:4)
__________________________________________
MY PERSONAL COMMENT:RightJew: Thank you very much for this beautiful
and relevant quote from the Shulchan Aruch.Notice that this quote DOES NOT mention
ANY upper limit for the number of Jews
who may make aliyah to The Land of Israel.On the contrary, the Shulchan Aruch that “HaCol” (הכל) =
ALL JEWS [100%] may make aliyah to The Land of Israel
(שהכל מעלין), meaning that there is NO UPPER LIMIT
for the number of Jews who may
make aliyah to The Land of Israel.This means that 100% of the world’s Jews
may make aliyah to The Land of Israel,
even those Jews who do not eat kosher.This means that the Shulchan Aruch does not merely
passively omit The Three Oaths; this means that
the Shulchan Aruch actively REJECTS The Three Oaths,
and those people who hold by The Three Oaths
are contradicting the Shulchan Aruch!! WOW!!Proud Sefaradi said this about Chabad on 2025/12/29:
…you see them on every corner trying to be some
missionary for Judaism and Chabad and convincing everyone
that there is no way except for the rebbe’s way
and think that they are greater than every other Jew…__________________________________________
Proud Sefaradi said this about Chabad on 2025/12/29:…there are goyim that hate Jews now because
they see signs [made by Chabad] all over the world that say:
“the messiah is here” and this is the biggest Hillul HaShem.The rebbe is crying right now in shamayim for what is being done to his name…
__________________________________________
PERSONAL COMMENT:Proud Sefaradi’s comments are true and valid.
But Chabad will NEVER LISTEN,
because they are completely brainwashed.Several weeks ago, UJM told us that he wants to dismantle
The State of Israel and give the land to the USA.But if you listen to The Neturei Karta,
they want to give the land to the so-called “Palestinians”.You know— the Phoney-stinians — the people who killed Jewish athletes
at the Munich Olympic games, and hijacked many airplanes,
and started a civil war in Jordan, and destroyed Lebanon,
and want to KILL ALL [100%] JEWS.This Neturei Karta “plan” would cause ANOTHER HOLOCAUST,
with 8,000,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael being mercilessly massacred,
including millions of Jewish children and babies.Even if UJM was being honest when he said that,
his statement is still somewhat misleading because
it is a minority opinion among radical anti-Zionists.There is also a Halachic prohibition against giving non-Jews ownership of Eretz Yisrael.
Most American politicians — even Donald Trump, who is very pro Jewish —
would strongly oppose using American soldiers to protect Eretz Yisrael’s Jews
from relentless never-ending attacks from Muslim terrorists.Several weeks ago, UJM told us that he wants to dismantle
The State of Israel and give the land to the USA.But if you listen to The Neturei Karta,
they want to give the land to the so-called “Palestinians”.You know— the Phoney-stinians — the people who killed Jewish athletes
at the Munich Olympic games, and hijacked many airplanes,
and started a civil war in Jordan, and destroyed Lebanon,
and want to KILL ALL [100%] JEWS.This Neturei Karta “plan” would cause ANOTHER HOLOCAUST,
with 8,000,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael being mercilessly massacred,
including millions of Jewish children and babies.Even if UJM was being honest when he said that,
his statement is still somewhat misleading because
it is a minority opinion among radical anti-Zionists.There is also a Halachic prohibition against giving non-Jews ownership of Eretz Yisrael.
Most American politicians — even Donald Trump, who is very pro Jewish —
would strongly oppose using American soldiers to protect Eretz Yisrael’s Jews
from relentless never-ending attacks from Muslim terrorists.Several weeks ago, UJM told us that he wants to dismantle
The State of Israel and give the land to the USA.But if you listen to The Neturei Karta,
they want to give the land to the so-called “Palestinians”.You know— the Phoney-stinians — the people who killed Jewish athletes
at the Munich Olympic games, and hijacked many airplanes,
and started a civil war in Jordan, and destroyed Lebanon,
and want to KILL ALL [100%] JEWS.This Neturei Karta “plan” would cause ANOTHER HOLOCAUST,
with 8,000,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael being mercilessly massacred,
including millions of Jewish children and babies.Even if UJM was being honest when he said that,
his statement is still somewhat misleading because
it is a minority opinion among radical anti-Zionists.There is also a Halachic prohibition against giving non-Jews ownership of Eretz Yisrael.
Most American politicians — even Donald Trump, who is very pro Jewish —
would strongly oppose using American soldiers to protect Eretz Yisrael’s Jews
from relentless never-ending attacks from Muslim terrorists.Several weeks ago, UJM told us that he wants to dismantle
The State of Israel and give the land to the USA.But if you listen to The Neturei Karta,
they want to give the land to the so-called “Palestinians”.You know— the Phoney-stinians — the people who killed Jewish athletes
at the Munich Olympic games, and hijacked many airplanes,
and started a civil war in Jordan, and destroyed Lebanon,
and want to KILL ALL [100%] JEWS.This Neturei Karta “plan” would cause ANOTHER HOLOCAUST,
with 8,000,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael being mercilessly massacred,
including millions of Jewish children and babies.Even if UJM was being honest when he said that,
his statement is still somewhat misleading because
it is a minority opinion among radical anti-Zionists.There is also a Halachic prohibition against giving non-Jews ownership of Eretz Yisrael.
Most American politicians — even Donald Trump, who is very pro Jewish —
would strongly oppose using American soldiers to protect Eretz Yisrael’s Jews
from relentless never-ending attacks from Muslim terrorists.On Sunday, 2024 January 14, around 60 Neturei Karta members
protested AGAINST the freeing of Jewish hostages in Gaza,
who were taken hostage by Hamas terrorists.This anti-Torah protest happened outside the Monsey Municipal Building.
SOURCE: Monsey Scoop and article titled: “REVOLTING: Neturei Karta
Protests After Ramapo Town Supervisor Calls For Hostages’ Release”
2024 January 15, www (dot) TheYeshivaWorld (dot) com__________________________________________
When Rabbi Shteinmann ZTL ZYA came to Monsey,
the Neturei Karta spit on his face.When will we Jews get SERIOUS about stopping this very dangerous evil?
__________________________________________
According to an article by Yerachmiel HaLevi on 2023 November 10
on Quora dot com, the Neturei Karta “RAISE MONEY”
for Hamas and Hezbollah and Iran.When will we get SERIOUS about stopping the Neturei Karta?
On Sunday, 2024 January 14, around 60 Neturei Karta members
protested AGAINST the freeing of Jewish hostages in Gaza,
who were taken hostage by Hamas terrorists.This anti-Torah protest happened outside the Monsey Municipal Building.
SOURCE: Monsey Scoop and article titled: “REVOLTING: Neturei Karta
Protests After Ramapo Town Supervisor Calls For Hostages’ Release”
2024 January 15, www (dot) TheYeshivaWorld (dot) com__________________________________________
When Rabbi Shteinmann ZTL ZYA came to Monsey,
the Neturei Karta spit on his face.When will we Jews get SERIOUS about stopping this very dangerous evil?
__________________________________________
According to an article by Yerachmiel HaLevi on 2023 November 10
on Quora dot com, the Neturei Karta “RAISE MONEY”
for Hamas and Hezbollah and Iran.When will we get SERIOUS about stopping the Neturei Karta?
On Sunday, 2024 January 14, around 60 Neturei Karta members
protested AGAINST the freeing of Jewish hostages in Gaza,
who were taken hostage by Hamas terrorists.This anti-Torah protest happened outside the Monsey Municipal Building.
SOURCE: Monsey Scoop and article titled: “REVOLTING: Neturei Karta
Protests After Ramapo Town Supervisor Calls For Hostages’ Release”
2024 January 15, www (dot) TheYeshivaWorld (dot) com__________________________________________
When Rabbi Shteinmann ZTL ZYA came to Monsey,
the Neturei Karta spit on his face.When will we Jews get SERIOUS about stopping this very dangerous evil?
__________________________________________
According to an article by Yerachmiel HaLevi on 2023 November 10
on Quora dot com, the Neturei Karta “RAISE MONEY”
for Hamas and Hezbollah and Iran.When will we get SERIOUS about stopping the Neturei Karta?
On Sunday, 2024 January 14, around 60 Neturei Karta members
protested AGAINST the freeing of Jewish hostages in Gaza,
who were taken hostage by Hamas terrorists.This anti-Torah protest happened outside the Monsey Municipal Building.
SOURCE: Monsey Scoop and article titled: “REVOLTING: Neturei Karta
Protests After Ramapo Town Supervisor Calls For Hostages’ Release”
2024 January 15, www (dot) TheYeshivaWorld (dot) comWhen Rabbi Shteinmann ZTL ZYA came to Monsey, the Neturei Karta spit on his face.
When will we Jews get SERIOUS about stopping this very dangerous evil?
Coffee Addict:
Do not accuse me of hating the Chareidi Rabbis, because it is not true.
I respect them greatly. May HASHEM grant them good health and happiness.
But all humans have flaws, and all Chareidi Rabbis are humans.
I do not hate the Chareidi Rabbis; I am simply aware of their flaws.
I wish you a safe and warm winter.
Chaim_Baruch, thank you for speaking this truth:
“To all those NK [Neturei Karta] Kapos voicing
their outrage at Zionist settler violence against the bloodthirsty Muslims:
Do Tshuva now before it’s too late!You are in great danger of losing your place in Olam Haba if you haven’t already.
The Moshiah is coming very soon and when he does, he will ask you all:Why did you forsake your brothers
and side with the [genocidal] enemies of Klal Yisrael?And when you have no words because of your shame,
you will go the way of Korach and his band of rebels.”__________________________________________
PERSONAL COMMENT:The Neturei Karta are much worse than “Korach and his band of rebels”,
because Korach challenged the leadership of Moshe Rabbeinu ZTL ZYA,
but Korach NEVER wanted to kill even one Jew.The Neturei Karta pursue evil policies that
are designed to cause GENOCIDE against ALL JEWS.Therefore, the Neturei Karta are much worse than “Korach and his band of rebels”.
__________________________________________
PERSONAL COMMENT:Anti-Zionists who quote the Satmar Rebbe of the 1940s and 1950s
are the spiritual equivalents of running a PC
with MS-DOS from 1992 or Windows 95 from 1995.The Satmar Rebbe was a severely over-rated and out-dated fanatic
with a minority opinion that was motivated by hate
so powerful that he unable to think straight.He was NOT a kadosh; he was a phoney and a hypocrite with Jewish blood on his hands.
DovidBT:
Where is that written? Please give us an exact source. Thank you.
I admit that I am not a Rabbi or Halachic expert,
so I will not attempt to make a Halachic ruling.But I can say this, based on more than 40 years of experience
with the world of Orthodox Judaism:Even if building a snowman on Shabbos were 100% permitted,
and did not violate ANY laws, I guarantee you that some
Rabbi will say: “it is best not to” or “it is not Shabbos-dik”.Even if building a snowman on Shabbos were 100% permitted,
the Rabbis will still tell you that you should be studying Torah
on Shabbos, not building a snowman.
(And they are probably right about that!)Therefore, even if it were 100% permitted according to Halachah,
you still would never be permitted to do it by Rabbis.The best answer that you could possibly hope for from Rabbis is:
“It is really permitted, but don’t tell anyone I said that,
because it might ruin the shidduch chances
of my children or grandchildren.”When it comes to Shabbos, Kashrus and Tznius,
no amount of chumrahs is ever too much for the Chareidi Rabbis
because no amount of chumrahs is ever enough for the Chareidi Rabbis.So far as they are concerned, the more chumrahs, the better.
And you are NEVER allowed to disagree with them,
no matter how good your logic is.
Their word is final, even when they
prohibit things that are really permitted.Your logic, no matter how valid, means nothing to them.
The only that matters what Rabbi X said.Please do not try to tell me that I am wrong.
I have been experiencing the world of Orthodox Judaism
and watching it for more than 40 years,
I know exactly what I am talking about.HaKatan, your false claims have been refuted and exposed
as false more than 200 times over the past two years.Yet you never correct your numerous false statements.
Instead, you just repeat the same lies endlessly,
like a brainwashed mindless moron who gets paid by Qatar.Over the past two years, the only thing that HaKatan and UJM
have proven is the they stubbornly refuse to listen to facts and logic.When I compare this message from “Happy new year”
to comments by UJM, they seem so similar that
I suspect that they may be the same person (or maybe not).Yankel Berel has mentioned an important idea:
The fanatical anti-Zionists are endlessly obsessed with ideas that are:
inaccurate, or irrelevant, or unverifiable conjectures, or outdated minority opinions.Their thinking is clumsy and filled with mistakes.
Can a moderator please ban HaKatan already???
Yankel Berel, I thank you for speaking THE TRUTH about UJM.
UJM should LISTEN to Yankel Berel, because Yankel Berel is SMARTER than UJM.
UJM is NOT INTELLIGENT — he just has a big mouth, a very big mouth.
Even if the only thing that UJM did wrong in his entire life
was to start this evil discussion, that alone is more-than-enough
for him to go down to Gehinom and NEVER come up, FOREVER!!!This evil discussion is a super-massive MOTZI SHEM RA
against millions of Jews, most of which are good people.This evil discussion is also a super-massive CHILLUL HASHEM.
This is in addition to UJM being a super-RODAIF and super-MOSAIR.
Last but not least, the moderators who approved his
MOTZI SHEM RA messages will also be punished.HaKatan said:
“…Islamic “nationalism” in then-Palestine also would not have happened if not for Zionism…“
__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE (from the WikiPedia article about “Arab Nationalism”):“Rooted in the 19th-century Nahda under Ottoman rule,
Arab nationalism emerged in the early 20th century as
an opposition movement in the Arab provinces of the Ottoman Empire,
later evolving into the overwhelmingly dominant ideological force
in the Arab world.[4] Initially focused on resisting Ottoman control,
it later opposed Western imperialism after World War I due to
the undesirable outcome of the Arab Revolt — in successfully achieving
their primary goal of dissolving the Ottoman Empire, “__________________________________________
That article does mention that the creation of The State of Israel
increased the cause of Arab Nationalism, but Israel WAS NOT
the initial cause of the Arab Nationalism movement.Therefore, the Arab Nationalism movement would have existed
even without The State of Israel,
contrary to what HaKatan has incorrectly stated.
__________________________________________
Fanatical Jew-haters blame Jews for EVERY PROBLEM.HaKatan and UJM blame Jewish Zionists for EVERY PROBLEM.
Do you notice the similarity?
__________________________________________FlamingOTD:
No offense intended, but with all due respect,
people do not listen to you because
you are wrong, wrong and WRONG!!You do NOT know what you are talking about.
Your “facts” are distorted and incomplete.
You CANNOT get the truth about Israel or Islam
from the Mainstream News Media (MSM).__________________________________________
Eric Starkman (a Los Angeles-based writer and journalist) said:“The mainstream media has abandoned all pretense of objectivity.
Whereas in the past journalists viewed themselves as
unbiased chroniclers of the news, their focus today is
on manufacturing it and dominating the ensuing conversations.A journalist’s influence today isn’t determined by the quality
or accuracy of their reporting, but rather the size of their
Twitter following and the frequency of their television appearances.”SOURCE: “Why Crown Heights Hate Crimes Aren’t Newsworthy”
by Eric Starkman, 2019 February 17, in The Algemeiner__________________________________________
Indeed, Palestinians rarely make an appearance in The [Washington] Post,
unless it’s to serve as the perennial victim — and this too
is contingent on portraying Israel, and ONLY Israel, as the oppressor.When Palestinians suffer at the hands of their [own] leaders,
The [Washington] Post is nowhere to be found.”SOURCE: article by Sean Durns, 2019 March 6 www dot algemeiner dot com
“The Media Only Cares about Palestinians If Israel Can Be Blamed”__________________________________________
Mr. Stephen M. Flatow said:“Despite the constant refrain from the J Street and the international
news media about the so-called ‘Israeli occupation of the Palestinians,’
the reality is that 98 percent [98%] of the Palestinian Arabs live under Palestinian rule.”SOURCE: “Looking for Jews to kill” by Stephen M. Flatow, 2019 March 6, www JNS org
FlamingOTD:
No offense intended, but with all due respect,
people do not listen to you because
you are wrong, wrong and WRONG!!You do NOT know what you are talking about.
Your facts are distorted and incomplete.
You CANNOT get the truth about Israel or Islam
from the Mainstream News Media (MSM).__________________________________________
Mr. Eric Starkman
(a Los Angeles-based writer and journalist) said:“The mainstream media has abandoned all pretense of objectivity.
Whereas in the past journalists viewed themselves
as unbiased chroniclers of the news, their focus today
is on manufacturing it and dominating the ensuing conversations.A journalist’s influence today isn’t determined by
the quality or accuracy of their reporting,
but rather the size of their Twitter following and
the frequency of their television appearances.”SOURCE: “Why Crown Heights Hate Crimes Aren’t Newsworthy”
by Eric Starkman, 2019 February 17, in The Algemeiner__________________________________________
Indeed, Palestinians rarely make an appearance in
The [Washington] Post, unless it’s to serve as
the perennial victim — and this too is contingent on
portraying Israel, and ONLY Israel, as the oppressor.When Palestinians suffer at the hands of their [own] leaders,
The [Washington] Post is nowhere to be found.”SOURCE: article by Sean Durns, 2019 March 6 www dot algemeiner dot com
“The Media Only Cares about Palestinians If Israel Can Be Blamed”__________________________________________
Mr. Stephen M. Flatow said:“Despite the constant refrain from the J Street and
the international news media about the so-called
‘Israeli occupation of the Palestinians,’ the reality is
that 98 percent [98%] of the Palestinian Arabs
live under Palestinian rule.”SOURCE: “Looking for Jews to kill”
by Stephen M. Flatow, 2019 March 6, www JNS orgYankel Berel, thank you for your valuable quote from the Penei Yehoshua ZTL ZYA.
I wish you a happy Chanukah and a safe and warm winter.
Baalei Teshuvah are Real Moser Nefesh and the Yeshiva world does not appreciate them enough.
Yaakov Yosef A said:
“It isn’t a Chiddush to anyone that Agudath Israel is mildly pro-Israel.
Therefore what exactly?”
__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:The Agudath Israel follows the Gedolim.
Therefore, anyone who says that the Gedolim
agree with dismantling The State of Israel is a LIAR.The Gedolim DO NOT AGREE with dismantling The State of Israel!
This means that UJM and HaKatan are LIARS
who wickedly misrepresent the position of the Gedolim.And they misrepresent the position of the Gedolim intentionally
and with deadly malice towards millions of Jews,
including millions of Jewish children who live in Eretz Yisrael.They are just as bad as the worst neo-Nazis.
They are just as bad as the worst Hamas terrorists.UJM is a RODAIF and a MOSAIR and so is HaKatan.
__________________________________________
The Satan rejoices every time UJM or HaKatan misuse
this Coffee Room to increase hate between Jews.
__________________________________________
Last but not least, Agudath Israel is more than mildly pro-Israel.RightJew, thank you for quoting Rambam’s Hilchos Melachim 5:11.
84% of Generation Z women voted for Zohran Mamdani.
As of 2025, members of Generation Z are between 13 and 28 years old.
The only demographic to vote against him was white men.
__________________________________________
From the book “1984” by Mr. George Orwell:“It was always the women, and above all the young ones,
who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party,
the swallowers of slogans,
the amateur spies and nosers-out of unorthodoxy.”KGN said this in the YWN Coffee Room on 2025 January 10:
“Some Jews have a hatred against Medinat Yisrael that is so great
that they have no other focus other than this.
Thus, some Jews have dedicated their lives to dismantling of Medinat Yisrael,
even at the expense of the lives of millions of Jews….”KGN said this in the YWN Coffee Room on 2025 January 10:
“Some Jews have a hatred against Medinat Yisrael that is so great
that they have no other focus other than this.
Thus, some Jews have dedicated their lives to dismantling of Medinat Yisrael,
even at the expense of the lives of millions of Jews….”Rabbi Uri Pilichowski (“a self-declared Brisker”) said:
“The existence of anti-Zionist Jews troubles the Zionist community
for numerous reasons, but most of all because they provide support
for the anti-Semites of the world who mask their Jew-hatred
with the ‘legitimate’ veneer of anti-Zionism.”SOURCE: article titled: “Who are the anti-Zionist Jews?”
by Rabbi Uri Pilichowski, 2024 August 18, Jewish News Syndicate: www (dot) JNS (dot) org__________________________________________
TRANSLATION:The anti-Zionist Jews make it much easier for all Jews-haters
to propagandize against Israel directly and ALL JEWS indirectly.The anti-Zionist Jews are a Public Relations (PR) disaster for ALL JEWS,
and they make the propaganda of the Jews-haters UNSTOPPABLE!KGN, I sympathize with your desire to see an answer to that question.
But I feel obligated to warn you:
The answer to that question could be Lashon HaRa (G*D forbid).UJM said:
Like earlier mentioned, there are virtually no “misnagdim” today;
and this has been the case for the last 100+ years.
__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:There are also no [or very few] Zionists today.
Even in the early 1990s, the Jewish newspapers mentioned many times
that we are now living in “the post-Zionist era”, meaning that
most Secular Jews in Israel were no longer Zionists, even in the early 1990s.The Chareidi Gedolim condemned the Zionists of the 1930s to 1950s,
not their grandchildren and great-grandchildren who are alive today.When will you stop living in the 1950s?
UJM said:
Zionist Judge Halevi, in the Kastner Trial,
condemned Kastner for “having sold his soul to the Devil”.
__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:You just contradicted yourself!
You have said or implied many times, that the ONLY people
we should listen to are the Chareidi Gedolim, and everyone else
should be completely ignored, especially the Zionists.Yet you just asked as to believe Judge Halevi,
even though he is [or was] a “Zionist”!Why should we believe a Zionist like Judge Halevi,
after you told us NOT to listen to Zionists?
__________________________________________On a different topic, your comments in this YWN Coffee Room
have done more to make Jews HATE EACH OTHER
than anything else that I have seen in many years.You constantly work to make Jews HATE EACH OTHER,
and YWN is also guilty, because they approve your
hate-filled hate-causing comments.If YWN truly desires to promote Jewish unity
and help Jews be zocheh to the Melech HaMashiach,
then they should delete all of your comments and ban you completely.In Olam HaBa, the hate between Jews that you caused many times
will outweigh all of your good deeds, and drag you down to Gehinom.
You laugh at me now, but you won’t be laughing in Gehinom.And YWN Moderators will join you in Gehinom,
because they approved your sinful comments.After the Balfour Declaration, in HaTekufah HaGedolah, page 174 to 175,
Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk (born in 1843 CE & died in 1926 CE)
wrote that “the fear of The [Three] Oaths has departed.”He expressed his approval of Religious Zionism
in Sare HaMeah, Volume 6, pages 233 to 234.After the Balfour Declaration, in HaTekufah HaGedolah, page 174 to 175,
Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk (born in 1843 CE & died in 1926 CE)
wrote that “the fear of The [Three] Oaths has departed.”He expressed his approval of Religious Zionism
in Sare HaMeah, Volume 6, pages 233 to 234.RightJew said:
“(In March 627 [CE]) the Messenger of God [Mohammed]
breakfasted at the market and gave instructions for a furrow
to be dug there in which to bury those to be killed…The Messenger of God [Mohammed] sat
with the distinguished among his companions.He called for the men of the (Jewish tribe of) Banu Qurayza,
and they came out at a leisurely pace, and their heads were cut off.”__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:Thank you for publicizing this relevant but little-known historic incident.
Please allow me to add 3 details that you did not mention:
[1] In the massacre described above,
more than 800 Jewish men had their head chopped off.[2] In the massacre described above, ALL widows and orphans
of more than 800 Jewish men were made into SLAVES.[3] Muslims are required, by their religion, to believe that
this incident describes the most correct and most righteous behavior,
for all Muslims, in all generations, forever.__________________________________________
Radical anti-Zionist fanatics want all Jews to believe that
“Jews and Muslims were at peace with each other,
before the Zionists ruined everything”.That statement is the opposite of the truth,
and it can only be believed by people who know nothing about
the History of Islam and nothing about History of Jews in Muslim lands.