SQUARE_ROOT

Avnei Nezer (the Gadol HaPoskim ZTL ZYA)
clearly disagrees with Sefer VaYoel Moshe:

Avnei Nezer, chelek Yoreh Deah, siman taf nun dalet
from sif katan mem dalet and onwards [pages 287 to 289].
Now for sif katan nun in more detail:

” … and now it is good and not questionable why Rambam
[in his halacha sefer Mishneh Torah] and all poskim DID NOT
bring The Three Oaths LaHalacha, because those oaths
are not LaHalacha, because the person himself,
his body, was not commanded to keep the oaths…”

That is why the poskim DID NOT bring the oaths LaHalacha.
That is why NONE of the widely-accepted halacha sefarim mention The Three Oaths.

It is stupid to claim that The Three Oaths are “undisputed halacha”.

__________________________________________
Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman [ZTL ZYA HYD] made it perfectly clear
that his sharp criticisms were intended only for the original Zionists,
not their descendants.

Avnei Nezer (the Gadol HaPoskim ZTL ZYA) clearly disagrees with Sefer VaYoel Moshe:

Avnei Nezer, chelek Yoreh Deah, siman taf nun dalet from sif katan mem dalet
and onwards [pages 287 to 289]. Now for sif katan nun in more detail:

‘ … and now it is good and not questionable why Rambam
[in his halacha sefer Mishneh Torah] and all poskim DID NOT bring
The Three Oaths LaHalacha, because those oaths are not LaHalacha,
because the person himself, his body, was not commanded to keep the oaths…

That is why the poskim DID NOT bring the oaths LaHalacha.

That is why NONE of the widely-accepted halacha sefarim mention The Three Oaths.

It is stupid to claim that The Three Oaths are “undisputed halacha”.
_________________________________________

Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman [ZTL ZYA HYD] made it perfectly clear
that his sharp criticisms were intended only for the original Zionists,
not their descendants.

ANYONE SURPRISED? House Report Reveals Biden Funded Anti-Israel Protests and Terror-Linked Group

http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/israel-news/2426744/anyone-surprised-house-report-reveals-biden-funded-anti-israel-protests-and-terror-linked-groups.html

The House Judiciary and Foreign Affairs Committees have detailed a sprawling web of U.S. taxpayer-funded grants—disbursed under the Biden-Harris Administration—that may have helped bankroll anti-government protests in Israel and even reached the hands of organizations with alleged ties to terrorism.

The investigation, which began with March letters to six U.S. and Israeli nonprofits, has already uncovered what lawmakers describe as “deeply disturbing” evidence of federal funds being used to influence foreign politics and destabilize a key American ally—Israel. But the findings go further, alleging potential criminal violations of tax law, the misuse of nonprofit status, and financial entanglements with terror-linked groups.

From Washington to Tel Aviv: A Financial Trail of Influence

At the heart of the inquiry is Blue White Future (BWF), an Israeli nonprofit founded to promote a two-state solution but which morphed into a political actor leading the charge against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s judicial reform agenda. Investigators allege that BWF operated as the de facto headquarters of the protest movement, labeling Netanyahu’s elected government a “dictatorship” and coordinating opposition strategy.

BWF reportedly received $4 million from the Middle East Peace Dialogue Network (MEPDN) and a staggering $18 million from the U.S.-based PEF Israel Endowment Funds (PEF)—organizations that, in turn, received money from U.S. government grant recipients, including Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors (RPA).

The memo includes a detailed flowchart outlining how millions in USAID and State Department grants may have been laundered—legally or not—through layers of philanthropic intermediaries before ending up in the hands of politically active Israeli NGOs. Some of these groups are accused of operating outside the legal bounds of nonprofit activity, both in the U.S. and Israel.

Indoctrination in Israeli Schools

One particularly incendiary finding centers on the Movement for Quality Government in Israel (MQG), a radical legal group that has used the Israeli court system to thwart Netanyahu’s government. The Biden administration reportedly gave MQG $42,000 to run a “Civic Activism Training” program for high school students in Jerusalem—teaching teenagers how to protest, report on political corruption, and challenge government authority.

Critics of the program—including Israeli parents and government advisers—compared it to U.S.-style progressive indoctrination, warning that such curricula “gut Israel’s Jewish character” and serve as a foreign-funded pipeline for political agitation.

U.S. Funds Traced to Terror-Linked Groups

Perhaps most alarming is the Committee’s charge that U.S. taxpayer dollars were indirectly funneled to NGOs with ties to terrorist organizations, including Hamas and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP).

The Committee highlighted the Bayader Association in Gaza, which received nearly $1 million in U.S. funding despite hosting joint events with Hamas leaders—including Ismail Haniyeh’s son. The funding reportedly continued just days before the October 7 Hamas massacre in Israel.

Similarly, the Unlimited Friends Association (UFA), another Gaza-based group, received U.S. dollars while openly praising “martyrs” and disseminating antisemitic content calling to “cleanse Al-Aqsa from the impurity of the Jews.”

One U.S.-based group under fire is the Palestine Children’s Relief Fund (PCRF), which allegedly received indirect funding through the Tides Network and Rockefeller Philanthropy, despite a record of erasing Palestinian terrorism and operating from a Gaza hospital that was later discovered to conceal Hamas weapons and hostages.

The Alliance for Global Justice, a radical U.S. nonprofit, is also in the crosshairs for supporting Samidoun, a group the U.S. Treasury recently labeled a sham charity funneling money to the PFLP. Samidoun activists were seen celebrating the October 7 attacks and conducting “Resistance 101” workshops on U.S. college campuses.

The Committees say the investigation is far from over. Additional NGOs—both American and Israeli—are being subpoenaed for records, and lawmakers are pressing Biden-era officials for accountability. Federal agencies including USAID and the State Department are now under intense scrutiny over their grant-vetting processes.

(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)

UJM & SomeJewIKnow & HaKatan are fraudulently dreying a kop.

They claim that its preferable to let 8 million innocent Yehudim DIE,
rather than transgress their corrupt version of irrelevant non-Halachic “3 Oaths”.

For Muslims, religious truths are not decided by logic.

They are decided by military conquest,
when Muslims conquer non-Muslims.

When Muslims suffer military defeats from non-Muslims,
it is not merely a military problem; is is a theological problem,
it is a religious problem, is is a problem of religious faith.

Responding to HaKatan:

Religious Zionism is part of the Torah of Moshe Rabbeinu:

Just look at the first Rashi on Chumash.

Just look at the first mitzvah that G*D gave to Avraham Avinu.

Just look at the many tractates of Mishnah that apply ONLY in Eretz Yisrael.

Just look at the 6th book of Tanach, Sefer Yehoshua.

Just look at the direction we must pray towards every day — Eretz Yisrael.

Just look at the Talmud, which teaches that
“whoever lives outside the Land of Israel,
he is considered as if he has no G*D.:

Since Religious Zionism is part of the Torah, those who
attack Religious Zionism are ignorant wicked heretics.

======================================

HaKatan also said that The Three Oaths are “undisputed halacha”.

Yet they are NEVER MENTIONED in Yad HaChazakah or Shulchan Aruch.

Additionally, the nations of the world approved the creation
of a Jewish state in Eretz Yisrael in 1920 CE and again in 1948 CE.
Therefore, The Three Oaths cannot apply in our times.

======================================

FACT: Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman died in 1941 of the Common Era.

FACT: The State of Israel was founded in year 1948 of the Common Era.

CONCLUSION: Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman NEVER SAW the State of Israel.

He never saw the miraculous victory of the 1967 CE “Six Day War”,
that started a Baal Teshuvah movement that lasted half-a-century.

He never saw the formation of religious units of the Israeli Army,
like the Nachal Chareidi and the newly-formed Chashmonaim Brigade.

======================================

FACT: Sefer VaYoel Moshe was written in the 1950s,
when Israel was still a Socialist state.

FACT: The State of Israel abandoned Socialism around 40 years ago.

======================================

HaKatan’s arguments have been refuted many times.

Yet he never changes his arguments; instead he just repeats
them endlessly, as if they has not been refuted many times.

And he never admits that people who disagree with him have valid logic.

The unrealistic policies that he advocates would certainly
lead the Jewish people towards a Jewish Civil War,
with Jews murdering Jews, followed by massive attacks
on Eretz Yisrael that would cause another Holocaust.

This makes HaKatan an apikuris and a rodaif and a mosair.
And not just once, but 8 million times, for 8 million Jews.

Yankel Berel, what you just said is obviously 100% true.

Only the most brainwashed haters and worst trolls would disagree with what you just said.

UJM said:

“Eretz Yisroel is in Golus. Anyone who claims otherwise is an apikorus.”

_________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:

How many times did the Rabbis of the Mishnah say:
“Anyone who disagrees with me is apikorus”?

How many times did the Rabbis of the Jerusalem Talmud say:
“Anyone who disagrees with me is apikorus”?

How many times did the Rabbis of the Babylonian Talmud say:
“Anyone who disagrees with me is apikorus”?

How many times did the Rabbis of the Midrash say:
“Anyone who disagrees with me is apikorus”?

I believe that the correct answers to these questions is approximately 0.

Rabbi Jonathan Sacks [ZTL ZYA] said this
in his essay titled: “The New Antisemitism”:

“In the past, Jews were hated because they were rich and because they were poor;

because they were capitalists (Marx) and because they were communists (Hitler);

because they kept to themselves and because they infiltrated everywhere;

because they held tenaciously to a superstitious faith (Voltaire)

and because they were rootless cosmopolitans who believed nothing (Stalin).

Antisemitism is NOT an ideology, a coherent set of beliefs.

It is, in fact, an endless stream of contradictions.”

CONCLUSION:
Blaming Jews (including “The Zionists”) for anti-Semitism is unfair, ignorant, and stupid.

PS: I do not know where “SomeJewIKnow” went to.
Maybe he made aliyah and joined the Israeli Army
as part of an elite combat unit?

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of Hamas.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of Hezbollah.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of the Houthis.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of the Taliban.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of the Iranian Ayatollahs.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of genocidal Jew-haters.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of terrorists who shot 36,000 rockets at Jews.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of terrorists who kidnap and murder Jewish children.

Every member of the Neturei Karta is an ALLY of terrorists who murdered 1,200+ Jews on 2023 October 7.

HaKatan & UJM & SomeJewIKnow are allies of the Neturei Karta.

When Joe Biden was President, the USA government
gave tens of millions of dollars to THE NEW YORK TIMES.

In August 2024, the USA government gave $4.1 millions dollars
to THE NEW YORK TIMES, and that was one of many payments.

All of this money came from the unfortunate taxpayers,
without their consent and without their knowledge.

So now we know why the newspapers were always
so eager to attack the Republicans and cover-up
for the Democrats and defend the Democrats.

So now we know why the newspapers always
tell lies and falsehoods to defend the Democrats.

The Religious Zionist Jews are like Yehoshua and Calev,
who wanted to fight to conquer Eretz Yisrael.

The Chareidim are like the meraglim, who wanted to avoid
conquering Eretz Yisrael, so they could study Torah full-time,
without interruptions that would be caused by: fighting wars,
building houses and roads, and planting and harvesting crops.

More comments from Youtube about the Neturei Karta (yemach shemam):

__________________________________________
@Assaf_yosef said this:

“Neturei Karta are not my brothers. There are my enemies!”

__________________________________________
@akivatalansky said this:

“Chilul Hashem.”

__________________________________________
@zvibrunner596 said this:

“These Neturei Karta are a bunch of fakers seeking attention.
They are the Erev Rav.”

__________________________________________
@richardmessina9475 said this:

“Neturei Karta are Palestinians in Jewish clothing!!”

__________________________________________
@Roitblog7 said this:

“Guardians of The Gates of Hell, maybe. NK is not Jewish!”
__________________________________________

Rabbi Avi Shafran, director of public affairs for
Agudath Israel of America, said Neturei Karta’s
trip to Teheran [Iran] was the last straw.

“They have overstayed their welcome in the community.
No one has patience for them,” he said.
“Their actions are beyond the pale.”

SOURCE: by Jerusalem Post staff, 2007 January 28, JPost (dot) com

Rabbi Moshe Sherer joined Agudath Israel as its Executive Vice President
in year 1941 CE and became its President in year 1963 CE.

His official titles included:
Co-Chairman of the Agudath Israel World Organization
and Chairman of Agudath Israel of America.

He held those titles until his death in year 1998 CE.

Agudath Israel traditionally follows the guidance of Chareidi Gedolim.

__________________________________________
The Wikipedia article about Rabbi Moshe Sherer says this exactly:

“Throughout his career Rabbi [Moshe] Sherer strongly
supported the State of Israel and advocated on its behalf.”

In 1975 [CE], after the infamous “Zionism is Racism” United Nations resolution,
[Rabbi Moshe] Sherer, then-President of Agudath Israel of America, wrote that:

“Though the resolution was supposedly aimed only at secular ‘Zionism’…
the slander is an attack on the entire Jewish people.”

Even if the hatred was aimed only at certain Jews, he continued,
“we (Agudath Israel adherents) would feel precisely
the same responsibility to come to the defense of our brethren.

He also said:

While we may have our own quarrel with secular Zionism,
when Jews are libeled, their affiliation does not matter;
our love for our brothers and sisters draws us to their side.”

But what is more, he stressed,
“the U. N. resolution is aimed at ALL Jews,
for it assails the historical Jewish right to Eretz Yisrael.
The Torah bestowed that right, and any attack on it
is an attack on Judaism and the Jewish people.”

__________________________________________
PERSONAL COMMENTS:

This short quote shows that Rabbi Moshe Sherer ZTL ZYA
considered a non-Jewish attack against “secular Zionism”
to be an “attack on the entire Jewish people”.

He also referred to Secular Zionists as “our brothers”,
for whom we have “love”.

He also mentioned “the historical Jewish right to Eretz Yisrael”,
and “The Torah bestowed that right.”
This comment strongly implies that he rejected the belief
that “The Three Oaths” are binding in our times.