Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
kingdavidParticipant
Beautiful question. I’ll share my perspective as someone whose life has been deeply shaped by Chassidus.
Without the Ba’al Shem Tov, my Yiddishkeit would likely be much more about performance and much less about connection. The revolution he started wasn’t just new practices – it was democratizing access to Hashem. Before him, deep spiritual connection often felt reserved for the greatest talmidei chachamim. He taught that a simple Jew davening with kavanah or saying Tehillim with a broken heart can reach incredible heights. That changes everything about how I approach avodas Hashem daily.What being a Chassid means to me: It means believing that Hashem wants my heart more than my perfection. It means that when I struggle – whether with learning, davening, or yes, even with the yetzer hara – the struggle itself has value when done with sincerity. It means seeing every moment, every interaction, every challenge as an opportunity for dveikus. The Chassidishe approach taught me that falling and getting back up with renewed determination is sometimes greater than never falling at all.
It also means having a derech in avodas Hashem – the specific teachings, niggunim, and approach of my Rebbe and his Rebbe before him. There’s something powerful about being part of a chain going back generations, each link adding depth and understanding.
Practically: Without Chassidus, I don’t know if I would have survived my own struggles. The emphasis on joy in serving Hashem, on the preciousness of every Yid regardless of their level, on the power of a good resolution even after falling – these ideas literally saved my Yiddishkeit during dark times.kingdavidParticipantI appreciate that you’re thinking this through carefully – your concern comes from genuine ahavas Yisrael.
You’re right there’s similar logic, but crucial differences in application:
Attraction to the opposite gender is universal – literally every teenager experiences it as part of development toward marriage. So we need proactive, age-appropriate education before feelings emerge, teaching boundaries and kedusha for their future. We’re giving tools for what they’re already experiencing.
The other feelings you mentioned affect far fewer children and aren’t part of typical development. For these, we don’t need classroom discussions that introduce new categories. Instead we need what you suggested – trained rebbes and teachers ready to respond with compassion when a specific struggling child comes forward, so they know they can speak up, won’t be destroyed, and will receive Torah-rooted support.
The goal isn’t introducing ideas – it’s being prepared to respond with rachmonus when any yid is struggling, while proactively educating about universal experiences that lead to marriage and building batim ne’emanim.
Does this distinction make sense?
kingdavidParticipant@flamingOTD,
I hear your genuine concern. Let me be clear about the distinction:
Attraction between boys and girls is explicitly discussed throughout our mesorah – Chazal, mussar sefarim, Shulchan Aruch all address the yetzer hara in this area because it’s meant to lead to marriage and building a bayis ne’eman. Every gadol acknowledges this exists and needs to be channeled toward kedusha.
The other issues you mentioned are fundamentally different with their own separate halachic considerations.
What I’m saying: A girl with normal feelings of attraction should know she’s not terrible, understand boundaries and kedusha, and have safe adults to guide her – not be left alone until she acts out and gets threatened with expulsion.
What I’m NOT saying: That every feeling needs validation or that we adopt modern therapeutic approaches that contradict Torah.
The reality: Right now our kids are learning about these topics anyway – from phones, friends, the street – just not from us and not with Torah values. Age-appropriate chinuch rooted in mesorah isn’t the slippery slope. Silence that leaves them confused and ashamed is what’s actually failing them.
There’s a difference between acknowledging the yetzer hara the Gemara discusses and the modern ideologies you’re worried about. I’m advocating for the former, not the latter.
Does this help clarify?kingdavidParticipant@flamingOTD,
I understand your concern – it comes from caring about our youth.
But with respect, I don’t think you’re aware of what teenagers are actually facing today. These feelings of attraction aren’t created by talking about them – they already exist whether we acknowledge them or not. That’s how Hashem created human beings, and our entire mesorah discusses the yetzer hara in this area.
Silence doesn’t protect kids – it just leaves them struggling alone without guidance. When a girl has normal feelings and thinks she’s terrible for having them, that’s when real problems develop.
There’s a huge difference between acknowledging natural teenage attraction (which every rov knows is real) and the other issues you mentioned. I’m not normalizing everything – but pretending these feelings don’t exist doesn’t work.
This girl was threatened with expulsion for something natural, without ever being given tools or support. Is that really the Torah way?
Our mesorah teaches us about the yetzer hara – we don’t ignore it, we teach how to channel it. Right now we’re doing neither.kingdavidParticipantCommonsaychal,
You’re absolutely right that these struggles are normal and common, but the way schools handle them makes things way harder. Here’s why:
Fear and lack of knowledge: Most schools genuinely don’t know how to talk about this stuff. They’re scared that discussing it will “put ideas in girls’ heads,” so they choose silence, thinking that protects you. It doesn’t.
Cultural shame: There’s deep shame around anything related to attraction or physical feelings. The adults were raised the same way and don’t know how to break the cycle.
“Protecting innocence”: Schools think staying silent preserves innocence. But silence doesn’t equal innocence – it just leaves girls confused and alone with normal feelings.
The backwards result: You struggle with completely normal teenage feelings, have no guidance or safe person to talk to, and then get threatened with expulsion when caught. It’s the opposite of helpful.
What you actually deserved was education that these feelings are normal, guidance on healthy boundaries, safe people to talk to, and support – not threats.
You’re not broken or bad. You’re a normal teenage girl navigating complex feelings without the education you should have had. I’m really glad you found people helping you improve.
Does this help clarify things?March 6, 2024 10:18 am at 10:18 am in reply to: The End Game for Medinas Yisroel and the Decline of American Power #2266635kingdavidParticipantאנחנו מאמינים בני מאמינים ואין לנו על מי להישען אלא על אבינו שבשמים
wonderful response!
kingdavidParticipantyou can reach out to https://guardyoureyes .com/ – they have great resources to help with these struggles
kingdavidParticipantFor filters here are some recommendations:
For Windows: GenTech, Meshimer, Techloq, Netspark and or the following accountability programs Webchaver or Truple.
For Android: GenTech, Meshimer, Netspark and or the following accountability programs Webchaver or Truple.
For iPhone / iPad: GenTech, Meshimer. Accountability programs like Webchaver or Truple are also an option but they unfortunately have their limitations due to apple’s rules. (or iPhone restrictions if done properly)
Chromebooks are not recommended to be used, due to the lack of good filtering options the best option at this stage will be Truple or Blocksi.net
kingdavidParticipanttomato dip
kingdavidParticipantהביאני אל בית היין ודגלו עלי אהבה
אל תיקרי ודלגו אלא ודילוגו עלי אהבה
When there is Ahavas Hashem, the dikduk is not so important…By the way, is it Dikduk or dikDuk ?
kingdavidParticipantTypically, human monkeypox spreads through very close, intimate contact, and it also can be spread through droplets.
kingdavidParticipantAt this time it’s probably “smarter” not to get a smart phone.
Much info out there is wrong anyway and we need to rely on Hashem and do as much things as we can to have more zechusim.kingdavidParticipantIs this internet nisyonos related? If yes, please reach out to GYE (GuardYourEyes)
kingdavidParticipantTry chavrusamatch.com or torahmates.org
kingdavidParticipantThe 12 steps were not designed to replace religion and of course, a Jew is always expected to fulfill all requirements in Halacha. For example, although the mitzvah of teshuva is supposed to be done in a very specific manner as defined in halacha, this still does not make step seven “wrong” in any way by not requiring amendments to be done in this manner-one is not exclusive of the other. Similarly, if our Torah requires daily Torah study, this still does not make the 12 steps wrong by not requiring it as one of the 12 steps. Don’t forget-only Jews are required to observe Halacha, while non-Jews are expected to observe only the 7 mitzvos of Bnei Noach. There is no reason why the 12 step program should require Torah study. In fact, if they did require Torah study, it would be a problem in Halacha!
Here’s the bottom line: If the AA founders told people to abandon their religions of origin and exclusively
observe the 12 steps, the critics would have a point-but the exact opposite is true. The AA literature exhorts its members to still observe their religion of origin & consult with their Rabbis.kingdavidParticipantThere’s no such thing as a shidduch crisis. Know how I know? Because we believe in something called hashgacha pratis. It’s one of the key components of emunah. It means that Hashem has a unique, very individualized plan for every member of Klal Yisrael, and He watches over each person and orchestrates events so that His plan will unfold for that person exactly as He intended, at the time He intended. That means that nothing and no one can stop Hashem from doing exactly as He plans for each person. That means that no human on earth can tell you the path your life will take.
April 16, 2019 3:14 pm at 3:14 pm in reply to: How much did you pay for your hand shmura matza? #1715563kingdavidParticipantAmazon Price: $25.99 per pound. But it has bad reviews: “baked in the Ukraine – came broken into tiny pieces”
kingdavidParticipantI once sent a letter to Rav Chaim Kanievsky asking about changing to a shul where I can daven better but the original shul I davened by might be upset and it can create machlokes.
He Replied:
” It’s definitely important to daven in a shul where you fell you’ll daven better, but it needs to be thought through very carefully if it pays to create machlokes becuase of this”September 20, 2017 9:58 am at 9:58 am in reply to: Why is hashem punishing the Caribbean islands? #1367776kingdavidParticipantהוא שכתוב בתורה והלכתם עמי בקרי והלכתי גם אני עמכם בחמת קרי, כלומר כשאביא צרה כדי שתשובו אם תאמרו שהיא קרי אוסיף לכם חמת אותו קרי
September 19, 2017 11:27 am at 11:27 am in reply to: Why is hashem punishing the Caribbean islands? #1366818kingdavidParticipantSo the time of year, and the strength and multiples are mere coincidence?
kingdavidParticipantPeople have been predicting moshiach’s arrival for centuries but nobody knows. Maybe they want it to happen so much that they make silly calculations about it and convince themselves that its true. Some people become so absorbed in these calculations and moshiachs arrival date, they dont live like they should. We should not focus on these things. Live a good life, helping people and doing the right thing. It is very possible that moshiach will come very soon but its also very possible that he will not.
kingdavidParticipantThere is an amazing insight in “Ohev Yisroel” this week. He explains that the ONLY way to protect small children who do not have yet enough of their own abilities for protection is when the parents do mitzvos with kedusha, it creates a holy angel that protects the children.. so we do have some control on our children’s decisions by doing the right things ourselves
kingdavidParticipantSome researchers believe that tryptophan can have a positive effect on stress because this amino acid helps your brain produce feel-good chemicals. … You will find tryptophan in a variety of foods: turkey, chicken, bananas, milk, oats, cheese, soy, nuts, peanut butter, and sesame seeds.
kingdavidParticipantIt’s a good idea to eat some peanut butter on Purim too. There is a study about peanut butter helping some people feel a little better during their depression
kingdavidParticipanttry:
Peanut Butter PC
Forget about sandwiches stuck in your VCR or crayons melting in your car… Today’s children have access to the center of your digital life. Just think of all the work and memories you have socked away on your computer’s hard drive. Now picture your kids (and their friends) playing bongo on the keyboard, or summarily executing your Word files with the swoop of a mouse. It’s not just possible… it’s probable.
Peanut Butter PC works to protect your electronic valuables by creating a fun and friendly desktop environment. One which provides access to only the programs and websites you choose. Best of all, your kids can’t break out of their desktop. Peanut Butter PC works from Startup to Shutdown providing the perfect learning environment while giving you peace of mind. And when you need to take control back, just enter a special key combination, and your back in Windows (with your files just as you left them).
kingdavidParticipantit’s actually a “Tekunei Zohar” which compares the two.
I heard one interesting point about this, the name PURIM mean “casted lots”
On yom kipur there were the casted lots of the 2 goats…
kingdavidParticipantUPDATED PURIM WEATHER FOR NYC:
Partly cloudy. High 32F. Winds NW at 10 to 15 mph.
kingdavidParticipantNYC weather
kingdavidParticipantThis year the Purim weather will also be quite interesting to start watching.
We have one day 75F then drops to 35F …
So far, this is the forecast for Purim “Rain showers early with some sunshine later in the day. High 56F. Winds W at 5 to 10 mph. Chance of rain 40%.”
kingdavidParticipantRav Wolfson said: A yid that believes that hashem can give him Parnassah is 6 days , does not need to have his online business running for 7 days…
kingdavidParticipantMaybe the CR should have a Rabbi on staff, or some volunteer rabbis to answer questions in halacha…
kingdavidParticipanthow does that explain why Sunday might still be 3 inches of snow?
kingdavidParticipantdo you work for the IRS?
kingdavidParticipantI asked my 3 year daughter, “what did hashem put all around Har-Sinai?” she replied “STICKERS!”
(she made for arts-n-crafts the ‘har sinai’ and decorated it with flower shape stickers.)
kingdavidParticipant??? ??? ?????
kingdavidParticipantSome hold that on Shabbos teshuvah you should not say any mussar, because we don’t want to say bad things about yidden in those days, so they say the mussar by the shabbos hagadol drasha
kingdavidParticipant1) Emunah. Believe that hashem runs the show and everything he does is good for us.
2) Know that when we have happiness, we have hashem with us and when we are depressed hashem leaves us
THE CITY OF HAPPINESS IS IN THE STATE OF MIND
kingdavidParticipantJust in case you don’t know the history of sushi… In 1966, a man named Noritoshi Kanai and his Jewish business partner, Harry Wolff, opened Kawafuku Restaurant in Little Tokyo. Kawafuku was the first to offer traditional sushi to Americans.
Some people say that gefilte fish is the Jewish sushi, or Japanese sushi is just a version of gefilte fish.
March 7, 2013 7:54 pm at 7:54 pm in reply to: Everything is great, but I'm not sure if there is chemistry! #953678kingdavidParticipantkingdavidParticipantTime will heal the pain.
But remember that it was not that person that did it. It was Hashem that sent him as a messenger.. that should help the healing process.
kingdavidParticipantWhatever Israel does here , they lose.
For every so called Hamas leader they kill , 10 new leaders arise.
Hamas has full backing from Iran and the whole Muslim world, and ALL other countries at that!
The world hates us and they always will.
kingdavidParticipantThere is no such thing as coincidence. The answer is it’s because of many things but that can be a factor too. Hashem takes cares of many issues at same time.
October 18, 2012 9:37 pm at 9:37 pm in reply to: How should one protest against shmoozers during davening? #901842kingdavidParticipantREPLY TO
“I learned somewhere that davening very loud makes one m’k’tanei ha’amana. As if HKB”H can’t hear unless he yells.”
THAT ONLY APPLIES TO SHEMONEH ESREI
kingdavidParticipantthere are a few medrashim that islam will rule before moshiach comes, and that iran will distroy part of the world…
September 27, 2012 5:17 pm at 5:17 pm in reply to: What's the going rate for a lulav and esrog in NY? #897912kingdavidParticipantsomeone asked me what is the esrog really worth…
I replied, whatever you pay for it, that becomes the value of it (the mitzvah is worth more if you pay more for it – so paying $5 a set the last minute is not recommended)
kingdavidParticipantThe kids are ages: 14, 12, 11, 9, 8, 6, 4, 2 … so it’s complicated to have one structure for all…
I agree to popa_bar_abba to a certain extent that we need to let them go their way when it’s boring for them, but when they ARE at the table (and cry/fight/scream etc) that’s when we need some ideas…
kingdavidParticipant(1) He has a nice voice (very important when all you do is talk);
(2) He’s likeable (unless you are in the crosshairs of one of his drone attacks);
(3) He’ll tax the rich and make those selfish people pay their fair share (until he runs out of other people’s money)
(4) He needs four more years to…put it all together (because he messed up so badly during the first four years–during his practice round as President).
kingdavidParticipantDriving is like constantly taking an exam. You may feel like the teacher isn’t looking and cheat a little, but she sees you, and you get an F. Like the teacher, someone is always watching. Your name is attached to your driver’s license — and with all the monitoring devices on the road, you can only imagine bending the rules leads to something a little worse than detention.
kingdavidParticipantBesides the mitzvah of “to be fruitful and multiply” it is also a chesed that hashem did with the person that he gave him a spouse so he can realize his faults and correct them. Hashem called it “lo tov heyos headam levado… eizer kenegdo”
kingdavidParticipantif you would be able to see all the laundry you’ll be doing in your lifetime, you would never start!
-
AuthorPosts