user176

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 198 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: “Frum” therapist #2053975
    user176
    Participant

    Can�t they have their sessions recorded or at least have a live feed which the secretary can watch but not hear?

    in reply to: What Steps Will the Charedi World Take to Try to Prevent Abuse #2053939
    user176
    Participant

    I actually answered the question directly. Because that is the only answer. When dealing with abusers, they must be penalized. When dealing with accusers, they must be educated about the effects of their accusations. After all, all they did is spread a rumor. It is a grave sin, don�t misunderstand me. But a lav she�en bo maase nonetheless. As per the accused, well, it�s up to the people close to them who love them to give them guidance. I think that is obvious.

    I would like to hear your suggested answer to your question.

    Thank you Syag. Let�s hear what he has to say to answer his own question.

    in reply to: the most delicious food ever #2053793
    user176
    Participant

    Of coarse every action we do must be leshem shamayim. That being said, a person who speaks about a material pleasure should not have to put out a disclaimer every time, �I am a foodie (but only leshem shamayim).� Im a big fan of mussar, but sometimes it�s a bit too much.

    in reply to: What Steps Will the Charedi World Take to Try to Prevent Abuse #2053776
    user176
    Participant

    UJM. Shechiach means common. The issue you presented is uncommon and therefore not being addressed specifically. In plain English.

    The larger issue that you are referring to is lashon hara, which is widely addressed.

    If you want to know what happens after the lashon hara is spoken. Well we need to learn more about lashon hara.

    in reply to: Watching Sports is Dumb?????? #2053721
    user176
    Participant

    Bored. If you find conversing in a ywn chat room amusing imagine what the excitement of a sports game can do. Regardless, in and of itself sports are a waste of time but they can serve a great number of purposes. Especially once we get into the world of �if not this then what?� Sports can be considered a great alternative to a lot of things that men are often involved in. It could be that some men enjoy watching a game or being involved in fantasy football the same way others enjoy eating a steak, simply because it�s enjoyable. Both of those things are problematic. But, I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt and assume they are following sports as an alternative.

    in reply to: What Steps Will the Charedi World Take to Try to Prevent Abuse #2053509
    user176
    Participant

    UJM. False accusations is not nearly as big of a problem as actual abusers. From time to time there may be a story but for a person falsely abused to take such drastic measures? I would not call that shechiach in comparison to the real issue at hand. If you think I am wrong please enlighten me. But, to answer your question, every shiur given on Lashon Hara and Motze Shem Ra is essentially what we do to ensure that does not happen. There are an infiniti number of �accusations� people can �accuse� others of. Falsely accusing someone or talking about someone who was falsely accused are just two examples.

    in reply to: Highschools with Secular Education #2051771
    user176
    Participant

    Math and science, while widely considered �secular� actually are forms of Hochma that bring us closer to bore Olam. These subjects serve as foundations to higher learning and difficult concepts in Torah. History is also very important. Of course there is always pesolet with the ochel, which is ok. But sometimes topics within these subjects are taught that really aren�t shayach at all which could be problematic. People with yirat shamayim should at least be reviewing the curriculum. Saying that �Torah� itself is the only Hochma worth pursuing is not a middle ground hashkafa. People who are against learning subjects like math and science are usually also against learning Hebrew, or learning Torah subjects in Hebrew (as opposed to in English or Yiddish) for that matter, which makes absolutely no sense. My understanding is that the reason for the extremity is twofold, because this method will have a higher likelihood of continuity within Judaism (which of course is something every Jew wants), and secondly because they don�t value (or don�t recognize the value of) these topics as Hochma for the sake of Torah but rather view them as secular. Just my opinion…

    in reply to: What Steps Will the Charedi World Take to Try to Prevent Abuse #2051270
    user176
    Participant

    Besalel- that the abuser is to blame goes without saying. Strange that you are offended that didn�t mention something so obvious.

    I never mentioned blame, I said �responsible�. The point of this post was to explore what can be done moving forward to prevent this from happening. The first and best line of defense to protect children is their own parents. As a side, a Frum therapist should create safeguards for him/herself so as not to fall into this trap.

    in reply to: Rapid testing for flight to Israel #2051269
    user176
    Participant

    My brother in law does testing in Brooklyn. Send your number and I will pass it on.

    in reply to: What Steps Will the Charedi World Take to Try to Prevent Abuse #2050671
    user176
    Participant

    �The charedi community� are the least responsible. The responsibility lies first on the parents of the victims. Any �Frum� therapist with this type of yesser hara should create safeguards for themselves not to run into this mess. My assumption is that guilty Frum therapists don�t want to do these things but they can not avoid the temptation. But my opinion is that the parents really need to know better and not just ship their kids off and hope for the best. We�ve now learned a big lesson that you can never assume your kids �are in good hands� regardless of the therapists reputation. You need to be involved.

    in reply to: Yahrtzeit on January 6th #2048958
    user176
    Participant

    The defense of BLM and the woke initiatives that stem from the BLM mindset is the greatest threat to democracy that exists in this country.

    in reply to: Gut Shabbos vs. Shabbat Shalom #2048096
    user176
    Participant

    Do what your parents did. Or wtvr your rabbi said to do. Or wtvr you want. Anyone who judges your Shabbat greeting is just grumpy.

    As for the question, I prefer Shabbat Shalom.

    in reply to: Short Skirts #2048015
    user176
    Participant

    Musar has a time and place. I very much hope that this post will inspire the encouragement of seniut and at the same type hope that you use your zealousness for a platform that will bear more fruits for your labor.

    in reply to: Short Skirts #2047777
    user176
    Participant

    This topic mostly bothers those who struggle with it most. It�s a given that people need to set their own personal safeguards for whatever they struggle with. In this particular example spreading awareness and education may help in general, but a rant on YWN wont do anything to help. If a true yere shamayim knows the yesser hara is waiting for him at every red light he would avoid red lights. It�s often those who are incredibly makpid and the most concerned about keeping a Halacha that struggle with it the most. If those efforts were focused inwards instead of outwards a lot more would be accomplished.

    in reply to: Kollel life with no parental support #2047579
    user176
    Participant

    While it is always great to have others to speak to who relate to your situation, I think every individual is capable of coping with their nisyonot through limud Torah and mussar. Every Jew struggles with something, the yetzer hara makes sure of it. Some can discuss it with others and others can not. One thing is for sure, Hashem won�t send you a nisyon you can�t handle. �They aren�t going through what I am going through� is a common sentiment, albeit mostly to oneself, that in many circumstances prevents us from accepting that our nisayonot are analogous to almost anyone else�s in its own way. I hope that Hashem sends you someone who can can truly relate to and alleviate that feeling that caused you to post here. But please also know that, if Hashem knows what Hes doing, you already have the tools you need to accomplish just that. Hasslaha raba!

    in reply to: Silence #2046384
    user176
    Participant

    AAQ which is why I prefaced that I don�t know exactly what these cases were. But in terms of the idea of �sending daughters to a male therapist� parents should be in tune with what�s going on, except for certain circumstances which they can�t be.

    Quay- see the new article by zvi Gluck.

    in reply to: “Frum” therapist #2046014
    user176
    Participant

    With any profession comes the potential to transgress Halacha in some way. Every individual is responsible to conduct themselves in accordance with Halacha and set their own personal safeguards in whatever they choose to do.

    in reply to: Silence #2045904
    user176
    Participant

    Therapists are not exempt from the laws of yichud. Without knowing the specifics of these particular cases, I would expect parents of girls going to male therapists or anywhere for that matter to be more aware of what their daughter is/was doing. Certainly someone with this nisayon should avoid being in this situation. The facts of this case seem pretty black and white. Even still it is a sensitive topic and needs to be addressed (when necessary) as such. �Maybe it�s not true� simply will not cut it for those struggling to understand �how could something like this happen?� Whether it be this case or others things like this do happen and effort should be taken to reach out to professionals and understand for yourself and learn how to walk others through this reality.

    in reply to: Silence #2045419
    user176
    Participant

    I don�t see any valid reason why his name would be brought up unless it is something that is really bothering you and you need to discuss it with someone or for hinuch purposes (you know your children are aware of what happened etc). And if it�s just to teach others because it�s important to share the experience no names are necessary. Just bringing it up saying, �hey, did you hear about so and so..� just to talk about it isn�t very productive. Whether to publish it on a news site… I have an opinion but I�m not really sure honestly.

    in reply to: Teachers salaries #2045415
    user176
    Participant

    I agree. My opinion was formed based on my experience with my own children (whose teachers were mostly young btw) who are really moser nefesh for their students. I imagine that teachers usually do not do it for the money…. But some other here feel like some young people just need something to do so they become teachers. I don�t see the draw but who knows..

    in reply to: Teachers salaries #2045345
    user176
    Participant

    Good teachers are not fungible. Many teachers give their lives to their students and work 24/7. The education they give to our children, including the love for Torah and Missvot, is priceless. I can�t say for sure because I don�t really know how much they are paid, but from what I�ve heard it isn�t enough to sustain a decent living standards. Salaries should not be subsidized, but organizations that provide rabbanim and morot with what will help lighten their burden out of sincere appreciation and immense gratitude each and every parent should have are truly doing a huge Chesed to the teachers and the parents who can now show that appreciation by giving to these causes.

    in reply to: Silence #2045333
    user176
    Participant

    The more you talk the more you speak lashon hara. See perush harambam on pirke avot. I have no close if this thread is about something specific. All I know is that talking about people usually means you have too much time on your hands.

    in reply to: Democrats Love Crime #2045073
    user176
    Participant

    The reality is that democrats (�liberals�) believe their ideology is above the law. What makes sense to them is correct regardless it being illegal. They will tell you that openly and call the offenders hero�s publicly. If in fact the percentage of tax evaders are Republicans, they know they are doing something wrong. After getting caught they won�t say, �well taxes are theft� and no republican will publicly come to their defense.

    in reply to: Achdus #2043604
    user176
    Participant

    No, you should never presumably assume the opinion of sadikim, especially on such an issue like this one.

    in reply to: Achdus #2043304
    user176
    Participant

    Not you or me, that�s for sure.

    in reply to: Achdus #2043288
    user176
    Participant

    The line is drawn by the level of adherence to Halacha of the communities Rabbi. If the Rabbi does not keep Halacha properly the people stand no chance. If the Rabbi keeps Halacha properly he will hopefully inspire and educate his congregants in yirat shamayim and Halacha lemaase.

    in reply to: I have COVID #2034386
    user176
    Participant

    For one, the vaccine certainly does not save lives. It lessens the severity of the disease, which is a huge plus but not enough of a benefit to mandate vaccinations. (Who wants to be hospitalized?) Secondly it is obvious that natural antibodies protect a person from getting re-infected, but still, that protection wears off after about a year, depending on the individual. I know many people with antibodies who subjected themselves to sick coronavirus patients to help them, and of coarse they did not get re-infected, and I know people who were re-infected.

    in reply to: Kyle Rittenhouse #2034380
    user176
    Participant

    Him coming out now as a supporter of BLM changes a lot about what we might have assumed were his motives. I haven�t watched any of the trial but my understanding is that this is new information. Maybe he can still claim self defense but it seems these murders were not entirely lishma.

    in reply to: Jewish Celebrities #2034303
    user176
    Participant

    Pride, otherwise know as gaava, is not a quality and Jew should have. We should be happy when we see people defending the Jewish people, supporting us and encouraging others to do so. We should be thankful that Hashem has sent these people who will undoubtedly make a difference in the way people perceive Jews, whether they themselves are Jews or not.

    in reply to: Music…Better? Worse? #2026124
    user176
    Participant

    2 is worse. But in the end only the lyrics matter. If the tune reminds you of the goy version you should get less exposure to that music.

    in reply to: Girls reputation vs boys reputation #2026123
    user176
    Participant

    I�ll admit, I am naive. Though I don�t see colored shirts for men as an issue and don�t see why it would be problematic anywhere or to anyone, in terms of Halacha.

    in reply to: Girls reputation vs boys reputation #2025964
    user176
    Participant

    A man can have more than one wife, and the concept of pilegesh exists. Many religious men drink and enjoy cigars and are often involved in olam hazeh in other ways. Many religious men wake up late, don�t necessarily always go to shul, don�t necessarily learn. The line between on and off the derech can be blurry for men. Women are very forgiving and understanding. The line for on and off the derech for women is clear cut.

    in reply to: Halacha #2022277
    user176
    Participant

    Halacha should be a separate seder. Every Baal Habayit should complete mishna berura. Students in Yeshiva should have a seder in Halacha biyun. If not you are guaranteed to be over on something.

    in reply to: Challenge #2022272
    user176
    Participant

    I was walking home from work yesterday and passed by a voting station. Outside were about 4 Russian men handing out flyers saying to vote for inna vernikov or however it�s spelled. As they were handing them out they said �vote for inna vernikov all of the rabbonim in Flatbush endorse her.� I had just read that article the day before and was surprised to see the sketchy tactics it action myself.

    in reply to: attention #2018763
    user176
    Participant

    Everyone wants attention and to an extent considers how people will react to him in mind before doing or saying anything. Sometimes people do things specifically because they want attention (whether they know it or not) sometimes they are just being themselves. People who brush others off as �wanting attention� are just proud of themselves that they know how to read people. If they really cared they would simply give the person the attention they thought he was seeking.

    in reply to: Shorts #2006970
    user176
    Participant

    Obviously there is nothing assur about wearing shorts. It isn�t a very respectable way to dress. The answer depends on who you are and/or how much you feel you represent Bore Olam

    in reply to: I’m considered an anti Vaccinator #1998668
    user176
    Participant

    Health –

    That article has a few individual stories. Where are the real numbers?

    in reply to: I’m considered an anti Vaccinator #1998409
    user176
    Participant

    All I know is I�ve seen plenty of articles about vaccinated people getting corona. I have yet to see an article about recovered people getting corona…

    in reply to: OOT Kollel #1987692
    user176
    Participant

    If you bothers you you are free to leave 😉

    in reply to: Men wear black and white? #1987689
    user176
    Participant

    I was once buying a suit in a store that sells hats as well and a young boy asked which hats were in style. Whether one wears a uniform or not people who want to will find a way to express themeselves with dress.

    It�s simply a uniform that has become known as �Jewish.�

    Most Rabanim where white shirts because it is plain and respectful. Rabanim are supposed to invest in their appearance as those who represent the Torah. A representative of Torah must dress respectfully at all times. White shirts are the best way to go. I think all grooms where white, it�s simple and elegant, anything else distracts from the wearer.

    No one will tell you Jews must wear white, although al pi kabala there is an inyan to do so.

    Black suits are just neutral. There are Halachot about wearing black on Shabbat.

    in reply to: stuff that don’t have a place #1979191
    user176
    Participant

    Shoebox or the smallest draw in the kitchen. Sukkah light goes with the sukkah

    user176
    Participant

    The birth rate among the frum does not seem to be diminishing. As long as everyone does their best to fulfill their obligation of peru urvu that is enough for Bore Olam.

    in reply to: ben shapiro #1976385
    user176
    Participant

    If they are struggling with the topics that he deals with and their struggle will hinder their connection to Hashem than they should be given permission to listen with the warning that they will experience foul language and other midot that we do not agree with. If you�re listening already yourself just answe their questions yourself.

    in reply to: Democrats: The Party Against Israel #1975349
    user176
    Participant

    I think Biden in at fault, but, his �support�, for Israel, in many ways standing in opposition to his piers, is pretty refreshing. When you see hypocrisy and utter blindness to what�s obvious you know that Hashem has masked those against Israel. May He remove the mask from all those who seek for our destruction just as he (partially) removed Biden�s allowing him to hold back from taking or demand action against Israel

    in reply to: Nice Guys Finish First #1974562
    user176
    Participant

    When you help others finish first you get the credit for �finishing first� where it counts

    in reply to: Confession #1971075
    user176
    Participant

    Everyone has different emotional triggers. Try ignoring the why, it isn�t really relevant. In the end of the day lives of great people were lost. Something that helps me feel the pain is putting myself in the victims shoes. Imagine it was me who perished H�V, how would my family react. Imagine the pain of all those who love you. What if it was my spouse who perished H�V or another loved one. Think for a while, play it out it your head. Think of what their new day to day life will be like. Read their stories and hespedim and substitute yourself for them. Each person is an entire world, with a family just like yours. Think about all the thoughts that pass through your head daily, each of these people had the same amount of thoughts and feelings. Really imagine what it is like for a person to suddenly seize to exist. Think hard and try to cry. Sometimes we need to use our imagination to awaken our true feelings. Hope this helps.

    in reply to: Gadol vs. Rebbi #1968411
    user176
    Participant

    Why does he think you are not ready? Why do you want to start dating? What can you do to be ready? What if you find someone right away, what are the ramifications? Discuss it with the rebbe and understand what is behind his opinion. Things like this are not just about �who do I listen to.� This is a fairly simple question that you can very well understand what is behind the opinions and make a decision. There are some things that you should ask and accept what you are told, not every question is like that. If you sit with your rebbe and explain to him why you think you are ready, and why it makes sense, and is what you really want to do, I am sure he will say ok go ahead.

    in reply to: Gadol vs. Rebbi #1968246
    user176
    Participant

    A good rabbi will clarify for you the sedadim, help you understand the pros and cons, and let you decide on your own. Clearly both are good options. Your question is very vague anyway. We have no idea what this is even regarding.

    in reply to: Are we too welcomimg #1968247
    user176
    Participant

    Just need to follow Halacha. People coming to a new community need to be verified. Especially a kohen. The rabbis of every community undoubtedly know this Halacha.

    in reply to: Only Gitten #1965571
    user176
    Participant

    Terrible idea. A website like this will do more harm than good.

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 198 total)