Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
akupermaParticipant
Not the end of the world. For frum men working outside our community, it will be a problem getting to minyan in the morning (possible solution, have more “downtown” minyanim, closer to the places of employment). But those working for Jewish organizations or businesses, or teleworking, can adjust hours. And of course, women won’t be affected.
It will give people more time to get home on Friday afternoon, and more time to finish Shabbos preparations in the winter.
March 16, 2022 11:09 am at 11:09 am in reply to: Russia will ban Western companies from exiting investments as BP and others dash #2069735akupermaParticipantBuying enemy bonds in war time is unpatriotic. You end up with having to file a claim with the Alien Property Custodian. And you may have a long wait to get paid (note that claims from the Mexican War, fought almost 200 years ago, or still being litigated).
March 15, 2022 12:26 pm at 12:26 pm in reply to: Russia will ban Western companies from exiting investments as BP and others dash #2069437akupermaParticipantTypically when countries go to war, the seize each other’s assets (and round up each others citizens). In the past, the Swiss arranged for transportation home for the people, and after the war the lawyers take care of the assets (note that the litigation from World War II is not over). So if you are stuck on the wrong side of the line when you become an “enemy alien”, it is hardly the end of the world, if you are a lawyer for someone whose property is in the wrong country there is light at the end of the tunnel, and if your property is on the wrong side you might get something back after the war if your team wins and your lawyers are clever.
March 11, 2022 8:34 am at 8:34 am in reply to: Do you think you would be a good politician? #2068350akupermaParticipantI would never make it as a politician. Same problem I had when I wanted to be a lawyer. Same problem when I tried to play poker. When I lie, it is too obvious. And being a politician involves a great deal of lying, bluffing, distorting truth, etc.
Just as someone who has an inclination to spill blood should consider a career as a Shochet, someone who has an inclination to lie and cheat should but those traits to good use, and become a politician.
akupermaParticipantDuring World War II (when the US was neutral), American firms made plans for the British, and then transported them to the Canadian border, and British (which back then included Canadian) workers walked them over the border. If they had been flown from the US to British controlled territory it would have been an act of war, and the US was trying to be neutral. This might be a problem now since even if the planes could be driven (using their wheels, not flying) over the border, the moment the entered Ukraine they could be attacked.
At this point, Putin is failing miserably at his objectives, and might feel the only way to salvage the situation is to use nuclear weapons. The question is whether Biden (and the American people) would be willing to fight a nuclear war, with fatalities perhaps in the billions, in response to Russia blowing up Warsaw or Bucharest or Vilna. As it is, most Democrats believe that America’s days of greatness lay in the past, and remembering Vietnam and more recently Afghanistan, don’t believe there is any will of the American people to go to war. Trump’s views are not all that different that Biden’s, but whereas Trump is challenged within his party by the “old fashioned” Republicans of the Reaganesque style, the “Progressive” Democrats are super-doves and Biden feels he can’t risk antagonizing them.
akupermaParticipant1. High gas prices is seen by Democrats as a “feature”, not a “bug”. He is accomplishing his goal. Most of what went wrong with Carter was in spite of his policies (i.e. his policies didn’t work).
2. Comparing Afghanistan to Ukraine (and rejecting the idea that the difference is that the Afganis are “off-white” Muslims), it appears the Biden is capable of learning from his mistakes. Most politicians tend to feel if something doesn’t work, they need just to keep trying. We should note that Carter’s stance of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, which continued under Reagan, was a major factor in destroying the “evil empire”.
3. So far, Biden has managed to get Ukraine to tie up Russia in knots without starting World War III. This all might fall apart, but so far it hasn’t. Failure (for Biden) would, on one extreme, mean that within a few hours Putin had installed a puppet government in Kiev and effectively annexed Ukraine (back) into Russia – or on the other hand, started a full scale war (in which case, we would all be Olam ha-Ba).
March 7, 2022 1:30 pm at 1:30 pm in reply to: Clarity: Ukraine, bloody Nazi past and the current innocent #2066935akupermaParticipantAn excellent argument all Jews refusing to live in Europe or American, or frankly in any Christian country. The reality is that in almost all European countries, a considerable number of people went out of their way to help the Nazis, and that doesn’t include Germans who “were following orders”. While the government (or others) executed many collaborators after the war, for the good of peace most Europeans decided on deliberate amnesia.
Many Ukrainians fought for the Allies, and some collaborated with the Germans. There is no hiddush here. And that is true almost everywhere in Europe.
How far back should we be mad? Should we boycott anything to do with Spain (including Latin America) since we’re mad over 1492? Should we have support the majority in view in America in 1939 that the US should not get involved since we were mad at England for the expulsion of Jews? Should we refuse to have anything to do with the United States and Britain since their elected leaders, with full knowledge of the Holocaust (in close to real time, as we now know from the declassified Engima decryptions) did nothing to facilitate Jews escaping from Europe. Should we support the Iranians since they are the ones who facilitated the building of Bayis Sheini?
It is one thing to say that those who forget history get to do it over again. It’s another thing to be so lost in the past that you cease to be able to function in the present.
March 7, 2022 1:29 pm at 1:29 pm in reply to: Putin recruiting Arabs from Syria to attack Ukrainians #2066929akupermaParticipantThus he is drawing Syria (and its distinct conflicts with both Turkey and Israel) into the European War, which will get Iran involved. Given that the Syrians whom Russia is allied with in Syria (where Russia has a significant military presence) tend to be the most friendly towards Christians, it doesn’t seem to be a “look, we’ve recruited savages” thing. It may be part of a desire of Russia to represent itself as the champion of Eastern Christianity (heck, if they can say Ukraine is run by a Nazi, why not claim Putin is defending Christianity).
Russia has many IOU’s from Syria and probably wants non-Russians for canon fodder. How use soldiers with no experience in a European climate and geographic conditions would be is questionable. The real danger is that this will make it more likely for Turkey to decide its a wonderful time to invade Syria. While the Israelis aren’t involved, having a war in your neighborhood can be problematic.
akupermaParticipantOne would need to check ancestry back to the the Russian Revolution (that would be his great-grandmother) and probably back to beginning of the “Haskalah” in the Russian Empire (another few generations earlier) which was in the mid-19th century. Unless someone is frum (meaning many hazakahs/presumption about yichus apply), or at least remembers when his family was frum, one should probably assume there is a safek, i.e. rescue him on Shabbos, don’t buy hametz from him after Pesach BUT don’t let him handle non-mevushal wine and don’t marry (with doing more research).
akupermaParticipantBut the conservatives (Republicans) and liberals (Democrats) and splitting. While it won’t be clear until the State of the Union, it appears that the centrist wing of the Democrats (Biden) is turning back to the ideals of John Kennedy and Franklin Roosevelt (post 1939, after he gave up on being an isolationist) and preparing for a new (and perhaps, somewhat warmer) cold war, while the Progressives (socialists) are reluctant to give up their domestic agenda and embrace national security. The Republicans appear to be splitting, though the Trump branch (with an “America First” isolationism) doesn’t appear to have made up its mind yet and may end up rejoining the Reaganesque mainstream in support a muscular “freedom agenda”.
In response to YungermanS: if we acted as you said then Messiach would come and we would have to come with millions of unemployed pundits, politician wannabees and self-proclaimed social media stars who would have nothing to do and would be quite annoyed with us.
akupermaParticipantRussia objects to Ukraine being independent. It has object to Ukrainian membership in the EU, and has insisted it be a “satellite” state, and object to free elections in Ukraine. And to make it clear, the have invaded the country several times.
Non-interference and non-use of military force has been the based of European relations and has brought peace to a region that had been wracked by warfare. By breaking treaties guaranteeing Ukrainian independence and starting a war, Russia serious told the European to either submit to Russian domination, or be prepared to fight for your independence. Much to Putin’s horror, the Ukrainians and the Europeans are willing to fight.
Biden definitely misled Putin by surrendering in Afghanistan, and Putin thought that the US had sent a message that it would not object to tyrants conquering their neighbor.
akupermaParticipantTo the original “question” – probably because they are incredible nobodies. Unlike the Democratic anti-semites, who dominate a major wing of the Democratic party, Republican anti-semites are marginalized.
February 22, 2022 4:36 pm at 4:36 pm in reply to: Remember why Trump was impeached the first time? #2063018akupermaParticipantCharliehall: Your OBAMA is the one who got us into the mess when he dishonored the treaty with Ukraine the required us to protect the borders (a treaty they paid for by giving up nuclear weapons). Obama and the Democrats stabbed the Ukrainians in the back when Crimea was invaded. And Obama and Biden were always looking for ways to cut the defense budget, meaning that unless the US wants to start full scale mobilization there is no way the US can do anything other the meaningless sanctions (consider what the world would be like if in 1939 the British announce that if Hitler invaded he Poland he wouldn’t be allowed to have a London bank account). And by Biden having surrendered in Afghanistan, he sent Putin a message that the US will no longer support democracies against would be conquerors, and Biden was too stupid realize that announcing the US would never again honor promises to defend others (how MAGA of him) he would set off people like Putin.
akupermaParticipantPatience. This is more like the conquests of Manchuria, Ethiopia and Czechoslovokia (for WWII examples). If the British and French had responded to the invasion of Poland with sanctions, and telling Hitler he couldn’t have a bank account in London, or go sightseeing in Paris, imagine how that would have turned out?
February 22, 2022 9:45 am at 9:45 am in reply to: Remember why Trump was impeached the first time? #2062794akupermaParticipantAnd it turns out now that the Ukrainians are fighting the Russians with the weapons that Trump sent them, and the Obama had refused to send after Russia first started invading Ukraine, and arguably under the treaty signed by President Clinton (but never submitted for ratification) the US is obligated to defend Ukraine if attacked.
Biden had firmly told the Russians that invading Ukraine is very naughty. He hasn’t responded in a meaningful manner such as by applying the trading with the enemy act (banning all trade with Russia), deporting non-immigrants Russians (other than refugees seeking asylum) from the United States, calling up Reserves and National Guard, sending serious reinforcements to Europe or asking Congress for a significant increase in the Defense budget.
Trump armed the Ukraine, and built up the military. The Democrats owe him an apology for defaming him. The real traitor was Obama who gave blessed the Russian invasion on Ukraine and broke the American promise to protect the Ukraine.
akupermaParticipantworst: gunpowder, nuclear energy, alcohol, social media
best: antibiotics, printing, writing, anesthesia, alcoholakupermaParticipantIf you go bowling regularly, you will probably buy your own bowling shoes since they fit better and are much cheaper than renting.
February 17, 2022 11:43 am at 11:43 am in reply to: Is Israel heading to the 7 day workweek? #2061396akupermaParticipantDavidf: As illustrated by whom they elected, the secular Israelis hate frum Yidden, no more and no less than they did 100+ years ago. The core belief of zionism is in having a secular Jewish state (a people free from the yoke of Torah of Mitsvos), and the continued existence of the frum community is incompatible with that. Note that Lieberman’s chief enablers are religious zionists, not the socialists or Arabs.
akupermaParticipantFrom the point of view of the zionists, anything that would enable them to marginalize frum Jews and encourage them to emigrate is a fulfillment of a dream going back to Herzl. In golus, frum Jews can usually pick a career that allows taking off Shabbos, even if that precludes a majority of jobs. It is unlikely the zionists could manage a seven day work week, but they probably want one that includes Shabbos as a workday. A trend that has benefited Yidden in golus is the shrinking work week that a century ago was uniformly six day a week with Sunday as a mandatory day off, and for many jobs is moving towards a four day work week.
February 16, 2022 12:44 pm at 12:44 pm in reply to: question for competent lawyers and anyone else who knows law #2061014akupermaParticipantThere is nothing to prevent you from sneaking over the border when no one is looking (and you would probably be in a lot less trouble than aliens trying the same thing, though you can be certain that if they caught you they would assume you were up to no good).
If an alien (with or without the proper papers for entry) shows up at the airport or dock or land crossing, they are subject to the same rules as a citizen except that unlike a citizen they can be denied entrance to the United States. Under well established rules, the public health service can quarantine anyone entering the country whom they suspect is carrying a dangerous disease (n.b. I’m not discuss whether Covid is “dangerous” – that’s a different matter).
The Federal government has statutory rights to make health regulations for common carriers engaged in interstate travel. If you cross a state boundary on foot or in a car, it is up to the state government to decide what to do (Biden and Trump were told that by the courts). If you insist on flying between states without a mask, you are free to rent an airplane.
One can make an “arbitrary and capricious” argument against the Covid rules, but as both parties (i.e. Trump and Biden) have agreed that Covid justifies emergency rules (I suspect future historians will be more skeptical), it would be hard to argue that anti-Covid rules are legally valid. Note the from a legal perspective, whether a regulation is wise is not relevant – what is wise is the for politicians to decide.
akupermaParticipantThe creation of the United States. Without it, the Third Reich would still control all of Europe, and probably the Middle East.
akupermaParticipantHe won because he got more votes. That happened since Trump ran an amazingly inept campaign that caused many Republicans to avoid voting for president (that’s why the Republicans did well, while Trump lost). And Trump actively suppressed the Republican vote be discouraging use of postal ballots.
Why does Ha-Shem make politicians stupid? That’s like asking why Ha-Shem makes fools foolish, or villians evil?
akupermaParticipantThere’s a sucker born every minute, and many of them are: 1) working for the government which “buys” the tests and/or requires people to buy them; 2) in deathly fear of COVID since they confuse it with smallpox or plague
akupermaParticipantIf the fire pan is too hot, feel free to jump into the fire.
akupermaParticipantIf you accept as a fact, as our enemies assert, that Jews have no claims to Eretz Yisrael, that the Jews today have no relationship to the Jews referred to in the Bible and/or that Taanach is merely a collection of myths with no basis in reality – then their assertions are rationale (and that the Jewish people have no right to live anywhere, which does explain why the continued existence of unassimilated Jews is an offense against political correctness and a challenge to the WOKE political advocates).
Bigots tend never to let facts and logic get away from what they want to believe. While on can argue with bigots, as demonstrated by the successful manner in which the Americans won their argues with the Nazis.
February 7, 2022 7:52 am at 7:52 am in reply to: RNC Censures Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger #2058145akupermaParticipantCircular firing squad. Trump lost (or won, whichever is irrelevant) by a minuscule margin. To win in 2024 he needs more votes, not fewer. The Republicans should be working on fence building and reconciliation, rather than passing a resolution designed to encourage people who would otherwise vote Republican to instead support Joe Biden (or worse) in 2024.
akupermaParticipantStill. Many troops from other countries are also getting ready to rumble, though no one, and that includes Russia and Ukraine, have started a full scale mobilization of reserves.
Remember this is like a chess game, which only gets to be a problem if someone tips over the board. Think of August 1914 or September 1939 for what board tipping over looks like.
akupermaParticipantIt has been happening since Theodore Roosevelt was president (stopped a little for Harding and Coolidge, but that’s it). This is one thing both parties are equally guilty of. There has also been a major shift of power away from state and local governments and to the Federal government. It has probably been very destabilizing, and to a certain extent explains the current radical polarization. I suspect if you brought some politicians from the 19th century to visit, they would being saying “I told you so”.
A president who rules by decree reduces the utility of any politics other than the election of the president. Switching power to the Federal government means that which group of states has control allows them to go after policies that are absurd to the rest of the country. It means if the Feds oppose gas-powered cars, people in areas where electric cars aren’t practical are angry. Most of the “culture war” issues become “hot” since by definition a federal solution is being imposed on all states whereas in the past states had more options.
February 2, 2022 3:06 pm at 3:06 pm in reply to: Why Whoopi Goldberg’s asserion was hurtful #2057153akupermaParticipantThe truth is the most Americans regard the word “race” (in reference to a group of humans) as referring exclusively to skin color. By this definition the Nazis were not racist (they had no problem with recruiting dark skinned Aryans for India who were anxious to fight the Brits). In the WOKE world, it is a point of faith the skin color is what matters, and aspects such as culture, ethnicity, community, ancestry, or language are irrelevant except to the extent they correlate with skin color. And to the WOKE, facts are automatically ignored when they clash with their dogmas of political correctness.
And like many WOKE personalities, she got confused when having to deal with facts that contradict political correctness.
February 2, 2022 10:01 am at 10:01 am in reply to: President Biden’s Supreme Court nomination #2057028akupermaParticipantEthnicity and religion have always been factors in judicial nominees, along with politics. However Biden is the first president, ever, to announce that gender and race are the ONLY factors he’ll consider. All the other presidents claimed that all their nominations were based on the the qualifications of the person nominated (and what a surprise, it turns out to be the candidate supported by the person I owe a favor to, wink wink). This suggest that Biden is perhaps a bit mentally challenged, or (to be dan le-kaf zechus) he has decided that in his old age, he can afford to be honest about such matters.
akupermaParticipantarguably, Cholent is a type of Hamim
February 1, 2022 9:23 am at 9:23 am in reply to: Re forced draft on Haredim passed by Seculars (& Arabs) #2056586akupermaParticipantThe anti-zionist hareidim (who don’t depend on government funding) can engage in open resistance, and possibly do great damage to Israel’s image abroad (for example, having frum Jews complaining to international human rights groups, or requesting asylum as refugees from anti-Jewish persecution).
The more “establishment” hareidim (who happen to have been accepting money from the zionists, and would have real problems without that funding) have a real problem. They have been supporting the medinah for over a generation. It will be a real loss of face to for them to start resisting the zionists.
If this isn’t reversed, the big winners will be Neturei Karta, the Eidos Hareidos (Badats) and Satmar, since they will have been vindicated in their anti-zionism. If the zionists attempt to conscript members of groups that have always opposed the medinah, they will be liable to be violating international human rights norms on conscientious objection (which would not be the case of those hareidim who have been supported by the government).
akupermaParticipanteither will do.
As with all languages, vowels frequently shift between dialects, and some Yiddish dialects said “oo” (as in “boo” or “moo”) and some said “oh” (as in “go” or “so”).
January 28, 2022 8:15 am at 8:15 am in reply to: Six-Day-War Major-general “There was a Siyata diShmaya” #2055686akupermaParticipantHaving dumb and incompetent enemies is definitely a bracha min ha-Shamayim.
akupermaParticipantUkraine has a Jewish president. At this point it would be hard to argue that either Russia or Ukraine is more, or less, anti-semitic. Suggesting that foreign policy is based on something that happened in the Cossack rebellion 350 years is ridiculous. From a Jewish perspective, we should be strongly be encouraging a peaceful resolution of the conflict.
From an American perspective, if the US (which guaranteed Ukraine’s territorial integrity in return for their giving up nuclear weapons, a promise made under Clinton, and dishonored under Obama) tolerates Russian conquest of Ukraine,they will be inviting Russian attempts to take over other countries in Eastern Europe. As was shown in the 1930s, appeasing bullies just encourages them.
Given that the US under Biden is cutting back its military resources, the US will have less and less influence, which will be bad for Jews since over the century, it has been the Americans who have been critical in defeating anti-Jewish forces (the Nazis, the Communists, and now the more radical Muslims). A situation in which the United States is militarily weak, and no longer committed to support freedom abroad, will be “bad for the Jews”.
January 27, 2022 11:04 am at 11:04 am in reply to: Question for Frum Jews who are anti Trump #2055396akupermaParticipantBiden is worse than Trump. By this, I am not praising Biden. Note that I am basically a neo-con on national security, a tea-partier on economic policy and a libertarian on civil liberties.
1. Trump’s isolationism. Surrendering in Afghanistan was his idea, and Biden was more than happy to follow through. What made America great was its willingness to defend freedom and democracy abroad. An interesting comment was that the Mexican War was the last time the United States fought overseas for its own economic interests. Like it or not, the non-cons are right. The Democrats “big lie” is that the United States has never fought for the freedom of others, and the best thing the US can do is not to meddle in the affairs of other. If we has a president who wanted to make America great again, we would never have stabbed Afghanistan in the back, and wouldn’t be stabbing Ukraine in the back (and in the long run, such policies failed, since tolerating tyranny encourages more tyranny and the longer we wait, the bigger the mess will be).
2. Trump supports “big government” and has always been fiscally irresponsible. Biden’s worse. At this point the Democrats appear to be intoxicated, and the Republican inebriated.
3. The United States needs immigration. The “boomers” (frum Yidden, and their children, excepted) failed miserably at producing children. Either we shrink our economy (i.e. get poorer) to match our labor force, or we need to import labor. We should not be chasing away Hispanic (meaning primarily indigenous Americans with a touch of Spanish ancestry) immigrants who are intending to be hard working and law abiding Americans. We need them. The supply chain disruptions are due to a shrinking workforce.
akupermaParticipantThe Chinese persecution of both the Uyghurs and other Chinese minorities (particularly the Tibetian) is widely discussed, and along with public outrage over China’s opposition to democracy in both Hong Kong and Taiwan, are major reasons why the US appears to be drifting towards hostilities with China.
This is a good time for business that rely on Chinese imports to find new sources, and for investors to move their investments out of China before they end waiting for compensation from the alien property custodian.
akupermaParticipantThe Senate has done the job they were intended to do. To block stupid and unconstitutional and anti-democratic (small “d”) legislation. Unless unlimited postal voting were combined with voter ID (e.g. you have to mail the ballot in a post office and have your ID verified), the Biden proposal would for all purposed prevent fair elections in the future. The Republicans have save American democracy.
akupermaParticipantHow about staying home and spending more time on Torah and Mitsvos. For most of our history, Yidden got along quite fine without going away on vacations.
akupermaParticipant1. Does adequate mean adequate to pass the GED, which opens up applying for jobs (among the goyim) which require a high school diploma, or does adequate mean being able to apply to elite universities which de facto means completing multiple AP exams along with excellent scores on the SAT (while some schools aren’t asking for the SAT, that is to enable them to reject “deplorables”, which probably includes religious fanatics who dress funny, with high SATs in favor of those deemed worthy by WOKE standards). If you mean adequate to hold down a job within the frum community, the answer is that the yeshivos do that very well.
2. How do you take into account the possibility of a student (presumably with parental support) studying on their own (or using online resources) to take the GED, CLEP or AP exams on their own?
3. Do you realize that if you were attempting to match the level of studies in a good yeshiva as well as the level of attainment in a good secular school, e.g. a prep school or a good public high school, the student would probably need to work in excess of 24/7. This is why when the goyim, when adopting the “modern” school curriculum roughly 150 years ago, gave up their “classical” curriculum (faced with the same choice, most frum Jews try to do both, i.e, provide a traditional Torah education as well as a modern secular education).
January 13, 2022 10:27 am at 10:27 am in reply to: Danger of Deer In Monsey – Traffic Accidents #2050952akupermaParticipantPossible solutions:
1. The government can hire hunters to kill the deer, and donate the venison to soup kitchens (as is done elsewhere). Allowing amateur hunters to hunt in suburbs would be unwise
2. The frum community can get permission to capture the deer, leading to a kosher venison industry
3. Based on common law, the crown owned the deer and those rights went to the states, so the deer are owned by the state. And, New York is an infamous “nanny state” known for rather ridiculous projects to waste taxpayer money. So the state can round up the deer, force them to listen to road safety lectures. and release them wear yellow safety vests. This idea might appeal to someone such as De Blasio if he manages to get elected governor.
akupermaParticipantA unicorn is a privately held start-up business worth over a billion. They are quite rare.
The English word “unicorn” refers to a horse with one horn and is often associated with various activities involving non-Jewish mysticism and witchcraft., so Jews should probably stay clear of them. Given the level of natural science in the middle ages, it is possible rabbanim identified them incorrectly with the tachash.
If one mutilates a horned animal, e.g. a goat, one can create a creature with one horn. Halacha prohibits us from doing so.
akupermaParticipantIf commercial custom is that renting over a holiday period gives you more days than a usual rental, why is there a problem, especially as the firm making the rental seems to have closed (though they really should specify the day they wanted the rented moveable returned).
akupermaParticipantPeople yelling at each about how to run the government is actually a good thing. If you want a place where everyone acts respectful to the government, try North Korea. If you think its bad now, look at the past (a hundred years ago, most good Jews were open to Jews, as long as they worked Shabbos, changed their names and were baptized – when a frei Jews was appointed to a major office, it was considered very radical – serious Torah education for an American usually involved a trip, often taking weeks, to a yeshiva in Europe – openly anti-Semitic groups were considered to be politically respectable in the US), and stop whining.
akupermaParticipantIn the original accounts, he was usually invisible and worked by stealth. By definition, this would leave no trace, and its existence can be neither proved, not disproved.
The “modern” version of a “frankenstein” type creature who beats up goyim with brute force is reflective of the “haskalah”, and while reflected in the modern superhero genre (largely invented by frei Jews, probably based on non-frum Jews misunderstandings of the “golem”), has no real basis in Jewish tradition, and clearly never exist.
December 30, 2021 11:35 am at 11:35 am in reply to: The world should take action on Israel’s treatment of charedim #2046552akupermaParticipant“inquisitive girl”- Kal ve’homer, if they didn’t object to hareidim getting killed and tortured, why would they object to hareidim being beaten or harassed. Also, the reason the Nazis got in trouble was not they they were killing and torturing Yidden in Germany, but they were doing that to a lot of other people and invading all their neighbors.
December 30, 2021 11:34 am at 11:34 am in reply to: The world should take action on Israel’s treatment of charedim #2046555akupermaParticipantduvidf: The government benefits limited to those hareidim who support zionism. Many would argue that a hareidi who supports zionism, even if only to get the money, is not really hareidi. The complaints against the government are from the anti-zionist hareidim.
December 30, 2021 9:26 am at 9:26 am in reply to: The world should take action on Israel’s treatment of charedim #2046485akupermaParticipantThe world didn’t object to the holocaust (unless they had an ulterior motive to do so), so why should they object now?
akupermaParticipanta person is a monster only to those who oppose him politically
if you agree with his motives, the person is at worst a bit “overenthusiastic”
virtually no one ever does something that they regard as evil
which is why we need to be wary of those whose idea of being evil does NOT include killing people like us
akupermaParticipantFreud gave much of the intellectual support for the changes in how physical relations are regarded in the secular world (from do the mitsvah of having children, to a type of recreation). While there has always been much perversion among the goyim (and OTD Jews, in all eras), Freud introduced the revolutionary idea that such perversion other than wrongful behavior.
The universe stands based on Torah, Mitsvos and Gemilas Hasadim, and when Jews go OTD and abandon our responsibilities, the universe is placed in jeopardy.
edited
-
AuthorPosts