rational

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 151 through 200 (of 369 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Commemoration of the 20th of Sivan #1868522
    rational
    Participant

    I think the expression was פולניה as in פה לן קה

    in reply to: How was Daf Yomi studied originally? #1868005
    rational
    Participant

    When the Netziv was Rosh Yeshiva in Volozhin, the policy was that the yeshiva learned a daf a day.

    in reply to: Suppression of Looters and Rioters #1867415
    rational
    Participant

    From the comments above, it appears that the violence and looting have not affected the Jewish community. All the comments are opinions from the outside looking in. Is my impression correct?

    in reply to: יום המיוחס #1865664
    rational
    Participant

    That’s interesting, no mention was made of the “plethora of Torah shiurim” on Memorial Day.
    I assume that since working people had the day off, they spent the day of Yom Hameyuchas learning Torah. I assume they do the same every Sunday, which is also a day off. I wasn’t aware that every Sunday there is an upsurge in Torah Learning. But if there is, that’s wonderful. God Bless America.

    in reply to: יום המיוחס #1864343
    rational
    Participant

    Dear 147
    I live in Israel, where the second day of Sivan is simply יום המיוחס , the second day of Sivan. I didn’t know that HKBH rules the world according to the national holidays of the United States of America.

    My son was in America for a while, and a prominent Rav asked him when Tu B’shvat comes out this year. My son answered “on Tu B’shvat, what do you mean?” How sad that Jews in America have become more Jewish Americans than Jews in America.

    in reply to: Post Corona: The New Frum Community #1862687
    rational
    Participant

    As takahmamash implied, come to live in Israel. It’s God’s country.

    in reply to: Reader Responds to Seminary Woes #1859102
    rational
    Participant

    Jews from all over the world have the opportunity to visit, study and even live in the Land that God watches over and has given to the Jewish people as a Morashah. To see and walk on the same roads as Avraham Avinu. To see the lands that Yehoshua conquered, that the shvatim shared, the land of Gidon, Shmuel, Dvora. The land that we are all about and that is the single major topic in all Kitvei Hakodesh.

    How sad that one reads here that it is a trivial and unnecessary parcel of land. No need to visit, no need to have it as part of our lives. We’ve done without it for so long, who needs it now. Afra L’pumayih.

    in reply to: I used to be really funny #1857072
    rational
    Participant

    self-deprecating

    in reply to: English tips. #1856693
    rational
    Participant

    Dear huju,

    I applaud your efforts. It’s unfortunate that you cannot read an Israeli menu or understand the labels. Perhaps there should be more information or comments on the correct use of Hebrew. I am fluent in English and modern Israeli Hebrew and will be happy to assist.

    I respectfully disagree with ubiquitin. Poor use of any language fails to accurately convey the message. Due to the online nature of the Coffee Room, the written word is all we have. We lack intonation, body language, sound-based emphasis and all the other cues that help us understand each other. Often I read a post and have no idea what the writer means. Furthermore, mistakes such as here-hear, their-they’re and others force cause English speakers to pause and spend time “figuring it out”.

    On a Torah level, the ability to write clearly and concisely often separates the scholars whose (not who’s) written works are studied from those whose works are ignored. Without names, compare some Teshuvos of certain Acharonim with the clarity of someone like the Noda B’yehudah. One reads a Noda B’yehudah and knows what he wants to say. That cannot be said of all.

    in reply to: Refund For Seminaries Due To COVID-19 #1855794
    rational
    Participant

    Dear 147
    Absolutely.
    Furthermore, tuition can be considered ma’aser money.
    Three, most major poskim (including Rav Shlomo Zalman zt”l, Rav Elyashiv zt”l and Rav Ovadiah zt”l (and others) held that ma’aser b’zman hazeh is a minhag only. Important, but only a minhag.

    in reply to: Just a thought #1855745
    rational
    Participant

    My family in Lakewood says there is no need for updates from the goyishe press or radio, let alone the treife internet. Whatever we need to know, HKBH will make sure we find out.

    rational
    Participant

    I and a painfully few others have been advocating a change in the “system” for years. I don’t see it happening. Covid-19 probably caused a temporary setback, but the system will survive. Entitlement, social status, living well, good single malt for kiddush, and all the other trappings of yeshivish life will most likely continue.
    It may take a while, but I will continue to see young women with thousands of dollars of other women’s hair on their head strolling through Ramat Eshkol in the most expensive clothing and pushing the most expensive stroller while their husbands are being “moser nefesh” for Torah.

    As an aside, when I hear a kollel boy is being “moser nefesh” in Yeshiva, I feel ill. Talk to my boy who spent five years in yeshiva and almost had his head blown off as a paratrooper fighting in a war about the term “moser nefesh”. And he was lucky. The soldier two feet in front of him was not. You’ll change the way you use the term quickly.

    in reply to: Vishnitz philosophy #1854304
    rational
    Participant

    Unfortunately, the teacher knows little about Vishnitz, otherwise, she would not have asked you to write who the current Rebbe is.
    Chassiduyot have two manners of continuing their dynasty. One is that there is always only one Rebbe, and that position is passed from father to son or closest relative. This is typical of Belz, Lubavitch, Gur (Ger), and others.
    The second is for every son to take on the name of a town (not always the town they live in, and not always a European town) and start their own Rebbeship. This system is typical of Vishnitz, Nadvorna, and many others, especially the tree of the Rachmastrivka and Rozhin dynasties.

    There are now two primary Vishnitz Rebbes in Israel, both in Bnei Brak, brothers Yisrael, and Mendel. The Vishnitz Rebbe in Monsey pased away a year or two ago, and he had seven or so sons, each of whom is now a Vishnitz Rebbe (Monsey, Yerushalayim, Boro Park, Bet Shemesh, Kiamesha Lake and a few others).

    There is also a branch called Seret Visnitz, a branch called Shotz-Vishnitz, and others

    I suggest opening up Wikipedia in Hebrew and writing in ויז’ניץ, that will give you all the information you are looking for, including philosophy, tefillot, learning, history, etc….
    Hatzlachah.

    If it interests you, the Vishnitzer Rebbe of Bet Shemesh was hospitalized yesterday with Coronavirus.

    in reply to: Corona is another step in our long Golus. A nisayon, not a rejection. #1851814
    rational
    Participant

    Unommin: “We have some real problems to deal with, and could use some rational thinking …”

    Sorry sir, rational thinking is usually belittled here. You can read it from time to time in minute amounts, but on the whole, it’s drowned out by creative and clever gibberish, such as you commented on.

    in reply to: life insurance #1851816
    rational
    Participant

    As some have hinted here, life insurance is not a new invention, and should be a no-brainer for any family.
    On the other side, torah migna u’matzla, and one need only study Torah, and not waste time over trivialities like working, education, or life insurance. Besides, HKBH decides everything, and all income has already been determined on Rosh Hashanah, so what we do on earth has no influence on what already has been decided.

    Some people are adept at playing each side, all depending on who the adversary is. The excuses to explain both sides simultaneously are all quite creative, but are nonsense.

    in reply to: Lack of kovid hatorah. #1851283
    rational
    Participant

    Enlighten me.
    Is there a shortage of people who use the internet and bash rabbonim? Why the commotion? Is he “going online” on a frum site or yeshivish blog? If not, who cares? If someone doesn’t like his opinion, they shouldn’t read his stuff. Stay on YWN where the exposure is limited to Da’as Torah.

    in reply to: Wild Animals Take Over #1850462
    rational
    Participant

    “we’ve been told that there will be a return of the 10 makos before moshiach comes,

    Where and when were we told that?”

    I second the query. I suspect that the answer will be “an adam chashuv”
    No rest for the weary of these nonsensical predictions. When they don’t pan out, no one is home to take the heat.

    in reply to: Moshiach is coming this year! #1849941
    rational
    Participant

    I admit, my dear Chabadnik, that I didn’t take that particular spelling into account. I am sure Chazal spelled it your way, I just forgot the source. Please send it to us.
    But I’ll give you a few weeks as I promised.
    It must be wonderful to live in a cherry-picking fool’s paradise.
    Also, please send me some more fool-proof gematrias. How about these?
    משיח=358=בארק אובאמה
    or…
    כאבים ברגלים=358
    ליברפול=358

    rational
    Participant

    “Not only that, it may not even be a Yiddishe minhag”

    Ouch. Shaking hands is quite Jewish and is as old as the earliest Rishonim and possibly the Gemara. See the Rosh’s quotation of Rabeinu Hananel on BM 74a. We mention it in hatarat nedarim. It is a symbol of agreement and often has far-reaching contractual obligations associated with it. As a Jewish social gesture, it affirms religious solidarity. It would be quite unfortunate if it becomes extinct.

    וגם הנעשה בתקיעת כף

    in reply to: Contingency Plans for Extended School Closings #1848781
    rational
    Participant

    I don’t have to explain why all people should be using the internet. If I do explain, it will be heavily edited.
    However, people run their own lives, and if they choose to live without internet, it’s their choice and their consequences.

    One thing is certain. If one starts using the internet, there’s no turning back. If the yeshivas feel that the dangers of the internet are too great, it makes sense for them to use an inferior means of teaching for a few months. Corona will eventually leave us, but the effects of internet use will not. For the yeshivas, it is not a simple choice, and one has to respect them if they decide to forego the internet option.

    in reply to: Help! Husband OTD #1848424
    rational
    Participant

    CD, it was illuminating to see how so much gibberish can be written by one person.

    Your angst and paranoia were enough not to read what I wrote. I did not write “the poor lady”. But I guess that people who think mishegassen see what they want to see and actually believe it. Next time read, think, and then write, in that order.

    in reply to: Moshiach is coming this year! #1848425
    rational
    Participant

    “Anyway, it’s good to see that the world is waking up to the reality that Moshiach is coming, as we can see from what recent Gedolim have been announcing.”

    “Additionally, “corona” is Gematria “Moshiach”
    משיח : 358
    קורונה: 367
    קרנה: 355
    קרונה: 361
    קרונא: 357 wow, pretty close
    קראנא: 352
    קראנה: 356 wow! pretty close again! (yes, I know the rules of gematria, it’s ok to pick and choose and manipulate, and be off by 1. Or more, but who’s counting? Certainly not you.

    DC, I’ll write to you, bli neder, in a few weeks or whenever you say. I will be writing that you once again have proven yourself to be a fool.

    ‘”

    rational
    Participant

    To Accuracy and Honesty
    The facts speak for themselves. You and your (educated? internet exposed?) friends have been compliant. Most others have not. Denial doesn’t change the facts. You know very well what the Gedolim said to do and what they said did not need to be done. You have internet. Read the statistics, read where people are sick and where they are not, read who died and who did not. Read who is sick and still at home infecting their households and who is not. Stop playing the persecuted. It doesn’t fly anymore. A serious cheshbon nefesh is in order, and you should be the one calling for it.

    rational
    Participant

    The frum community is almost 100% compliant, only three weeks too late. Chachomim l’achar maa’seh. Where is the regret from the “no worse than winter flu” crowd? Where is the cheshbon nefesh of the”closing down the batei medrash is worse than the disease” rabbonim? I doubt we’ll see it,

    Edited. Now is not the time to interject overall disdain for other Jews lifestyles into your covid 19 related comments.

    in reply to: Chicken for the seder – I need advice, fast! #1846169
    rational
    Participant

    I respectfully disagree. While roasting on a rotisserie, the meat is roasted by the fire itself, hence the term tzli. When covered in an oven, it is not baked (cooked) by the fire, but by the boiling heat of the juices of the meat itself. These hot juices are considered liquid. In the rotisserie, the fat and juices drip out, unlike the oven where the liquid juices are maintained inside.

    I cannot see any problem of mar’is ayin if something is in an oven. Furthermore, since there are different minhagim , and some allow for baking meat, or even using a rotisserie, there can be no issue of mar’is ayin.

    in reply to: Help! Husband OTD #1845631
    rational
    Participant

    The unfortunate lady asked for (and is receiving) serious and considered advice, not for mishegasen.

    In response to others who automatically assume that someone who is OTD has left for the physical taivos of the secular world, this is a patently incorrect assumption.

    in reply to: Chicken for the seder – I need advice, fast! #1845632
    rational
    Participant

    It is minhag, not halachah. The issur (Ashkenazic, sefradim permit) is roasting lamb on a rotisserie. Roasting in an oven is not roasting, but baking. Again, those who do not roast (bake) meat or chicken do so on the basis of minhag.

    in reply to: Seder at home #1845630
    rational
    Participant

    It would be unfortunate if mistakes were perpetuated simply because our revered teachers were not aware of the correct pronunciation. I know of no gemara that mandates errors or mistakes. בלשון רבו does not mean בטעויות רבו.

    I also heard as a young man only B’chaye, but it turns out that it is incorrect. No one’s fault, really, over time many words become adulterated, it’s part of language and dialect development. Rabeinu Bachye lived in Moslem Spain in the 11th century and not in Bobroisk or Eishishok in the 19th century. However, the correct pronunciation is Rabeinu Bachye or possibly Bachyai. Please tell your rebbeim, I’m sure they also would want to pronounce someone else’s name the proper way.

    in reply to: Seder at home #1845366
    rational
    Participant

    Rabeinu Bachye

    in reply to: We need a Pinchas to take action to stop the magefah!! #1845321
    rational
    Participant

    yes, and the word מגיפה written differently is also גם יפה, “quite beautiful”. feel better already?

    in reply to: Help! Husband OTD #1845241
    rational
    Participant

    DC, leave the lady alone. There’s enough nonsense out there these days.

    in reply to: We need a Pinchas to take action to stop the magefah!! #1845174
    rational
    Participant

    Actually, we need scientific knowledge to stop the mageifah.
    The solution has certainly not emanated from these who claimed that “it is no worse than the common cold” or those rabbonim who thought that large numbers of talmidim learning in a small beis medrash would do the trick.

    in reply to: Garlic for Coronavirus #1844192
    rational
    Participant

    “All I’m saying is that I believe that the garlic helped me and it may help others who are having symptoms of the coronavirus, or any virus or disease for that matter.”

    Edited  You are suggesting that other people try your remedies without an ounce of rational or scientific basis, let alone proof. You tried it and liked it? Good for you. Don’t suggest it to others, you are in over your head.

    in reply to: Garlic for Coronavirus #1843496
    rational
    Participant

    Philosopher: I hope no one was trying to denigrate you.
    I have one question: You must have done dozens of things the day you took the garlic. By what rational or scientific criteria are you showing that it was specifically the garlic that made you feel better?
    Temporal juxtaposition does not prove causality.

    in reply to: Question #9 #1842960
    rational
    Participant

    Place of birth is not the same as origin. Most Jews in the U.S. are of European origin, most Sephardic Jews are of North African origin. Of course, Syrian Jews would be of Middle Eastern origin.

    This question occasionally carries importance. There are genetic diseases, syndromes, predispositions to certain diseases and other health-related tendencies that are associated with certain geographical origins. For instance, the Tay-Sachs gene defect is associated with eastern European origins, particularly the Northern Poland-Lithuanian area.

    This information can be used to form public health policy, location of screenings, availability of certain special medical equipment or specialties, etc…

    A hypothetical example: Suppose a certain origin predisposes to the eye disease called glaucoma, a silent disease. Suppose a certain neighborhood has a large number of people of this origin. It would be a good idea to conduct a glaucoma screening in this neighborhood as a means to identify possible people with this disease.

    in reply to: Coronavirus davening at home #1842953
    rational
    Participant

    Joseph is correct, davening with a minyan is always preferable to davening b’yechidus. That is a no-brainer.

    That said, one can use the extra time at home to practice reading Hebrew so that the davening flows smoothly and one feels comfortable with the nusach hat’filah. Good kavanah requires one being capable of reading the words properly, a skill not usually emphasized in yeshivos.

    in reply to: Corona-Safe Chol Hamoed Activities for Children #1842940
    rational
    Participant

    Activity for the kids, young and old: Teach them some basic biology, physiology, and epidemiology so that they won’t be ignorant anymore. That way they are more likely to behave carefully next time there is an epidemic or pandemic and won’t be misled by ignoramuses.
    They will also be able to understand the difference between winter flu (influenza virus) and more serious (Corona) viruses. Maybe they will also understand a bit about why after some viral infections the body attains a certain degree of immunity from infection of the same virus.

    in reply to: Are you a bechor? #1842509
    rational
    Participant

    “Also, some poskim say the same for a deceased father who was a bechor.” What are you talking about or was this a typo?

    No, not a typo. However, this very old minhag (approximately 700 years) seems to have expanded in some circles, including the aforementioned addition of the deceased father. If you are looking for the original minhag, then
    1. Women first born also need to fast
    2. Non-bechorim who are hygienically scrupulous (איסטניסים) also fast.

    How many abide by the original minhag?

    in reply to: Adding a 2nd Adar #1842236
    rational
    Participant

    Don’t worry. It was a poorly thought-out idea and it isn’t going to happen. Your arguments are good ones, and the Israeli Supreme Court used those same arguments to torpedo the idea.

    in reply to: Online classes? #1840758
    rational
    Participant

    Joseph is correct. Let’s keep our children dumb. That way it’s easier to control them later on when their bodies have grown but their brains have not.

    in reply to: Lessons for us from the Black plague #1840753
    rational
    Participant

    I sincerely hope Akuperma is right, but every single epidemiologist strongly disagrees. I refer everyone to a long and serious article written by Tomas Pueyo, you can google it.

    in reply to: Shuls Closed While Restaurants Opened?! #1840431
    rational
    Participant

    Um, Lakewood Yeshiva?

    in reply to: Are our mistakes (not regarding mitzvos/sins) from Hashem? #1840429
    rational
    Participant

    “We have true Gedoilin that Paskened that the Age-Gap is the problem.”

    A psak. Well, that was a good laugh. Thanks.

    rational
    Participant

    Sheva Brochos after the wedding is a minhag and not an obligation. After the seven day period one can make a party for the couple, but without the sheva brachos.

    in reply to: “Freilichen Tamid”? #1839175
    rational
    Participant

    הרבי מברסלב: מצוה גדולה להיות בשמחה תמיד

    in reply to: Purim 2020 Minyanim in Lakewood #1839113
    rational
    Participant

    Oy, how far have we fallen?
    There is no such date as Purim 2020. It is Purim 5780.

    in reply to: Lousy choices #1838453
    rational
    Participant

    Again

    I have a chicken, it is my chicken
    You have a chicken, it is your chicken
    We have a chicken, it is our chicken

    I am a chicken, I’m a chicken
    You are a chicken, you’re a chicken
    We are chickens, we’re chickens

    As you can see, your and you’re have different meanings. When they are used incorrectly, it is confusing for the reader.

    in reply to: Purim Safety #1838319
    rational
    Participant

    Drink only after eating the main course of the se’udah. Stay overnight at the host.
    Go home safely on Wednesday

    in reply to: Bar Mitzvah Invitations #1838318
    rational
    Participant

    My suggestion:
    Tell him you will order the standard invitations, but the “savings” will be donated to a tzedakah of the boy’s choice.
    Win in chinuch, win in mitzvos. Same price.

    in reply to: Lousy choices #1838317
    rational
    Participant

    So if you are a democrat.
    Shorten “you are” with “you’re”, as in “So if you’re a democrat”

    Please learn this simple rule of English. It will make it easier to understand “your” messages.
    Thank you
    A safe and happy Purim

Viewing 50 posts - 151 through 200 (of 369 total)